A CONTRADICTORY APPENDIX.
By L. C. Chadwick
(Barbadoes, West Indies.) The following interesting quotation is an extract from an editorial by the Rev. J. T. Gracey, D.D., in the Missionary Review of January, 1892. If it were not that we should regard any reference to the death of such faithful, devoted men and women as the missionaries referred to, with due respect, one might be tempted to be amused at the variety of ways of dying, here so graphically portrayed. The following is the extract:— We ought to pause to shed a tear at the grave of the missionary dead of 1891. The list is but an appendix to the 11th chapter of Hebrews. Bishop French ascended from Arabia; Bishop Boone, having only for a short time been enrobed in the mantle of his father, the renowned missionary, died in China; Newton, “the beloved,” of the Panjab—“a man sent from God whose name was John”—was followed to a better than India’s palaces by Winter, of the Delhi Mission, who loved his special work more than he did a bishopric. Amid the lamentations of thousands, that “good servant of the Lord,” Bishop Caldwell, was laid to rest after fifty-four years of labor in India for India; Dr. Luther H. Gulick, the founder of a large missionary family, went up to the “bosom” of the “father of the faithful;” and dear and great John Inglis dropped his finished translation of the visions of him of Patmos, to open his eyes on the beatific vision of the Ancient of days; Redslob, the Moravian sentinel on the outer patrol limit of Christendom on the edge of Thibet, awoke to know the richer meaning of Nam Thang Song, and to find it “all bright again” forever; Mrs. Bennet, more than sixty years in Burmah, went to join again the Judsons and the Boardmans; Sheshradi, the first Asiatic whom America ever honored with a doctorate of divinity, found a fitting sepulcher in the sea for his body, while his soul went to the “sea of glass;” and Goloknath, of Jaland(e)r, was carried to his burial by “devout men,” and honored by the presence at his funeral of European officials and a thousand Hindus and Mohammedans. Time would fail us to tell of others who have gone from the remotest mountains and valleys, from habitations of cruelty and spiritual solitude, to the “general assembly” and the “church of the Firstborn” on high. All this the author calls “an appendix to the 11th chapter of Hebrews.” But he would have us believe that this list of “missionary dead” have all gone to their reward, and are enjoying their well-earned and promised enjoyment of eternal happiness; but here he contradicts in his appendix the plain statement of the chapter referred to, for the apostle Paul, after giving a long list of faithful dead, says:— These all, having obtained a good report through faith, received not the promise: God having provided some better thing for us, that they without us should not be made perfect.
An appendix should not contradict that to which it is added, but when once even the wisest theologians cut loose from the teachings of the Bible, there is no telling into what kinds of inconsistencies they will be led to go, in carrying out their erroneous and unscriptural ideas.