The Rev. C. L. La Trobe was traveling one night by rail, the only passenger in the car, when toward morning the door opened, and two young men entered. As the day was about to dawn, perceiving a gentleman in black, sitting in a corner of the car and conjecturing him to be a clergyman, they proposed to have some sport at his expense. To attract his attention, they began a conversation between themselves as to the merits of the Bible and the Mohammedan Koran, declaring their decided preference for the latter. Perceiving this had not the expected effect of arousing him, one of them very gently touched his knee, with the remark, “You seem asleep, sir!” He answered that they need not wonder if he felt inclined to sleep, as he had been traveling through the night.
“We should be very sorry,” said the other, “to disturb you, but the gentleman and myself were conversing on a subject which we thought might not be wholly uninteresting to a gentleman of your cloth,—the comparative merits of the Bible and the Koran,—and we both agree, that, whether in respect of the weight of its matter, the depth of its philosophy, or the eloquence of its style, the Koran has decidedly the advantage. May we ask, sir, what is your opinion?”
“Gentlemen,” said he, “you have indeed chosen a most important and interesting subject for discussion, I have never read the Koran, and my idea of it is, therefore, very loose and general. You, of course, have deeply studied the two works, of the comparative merits of which you have given so decided an opinion. I would, therefore, if you will allow me, first ask a few questions, and having gleaned the needful information, shall then be happy to give my opinion. Does the Koran resemble the Bible in being divided into books and chapters?”
The other answered, “I believe so.”
“Believe so!” said the reverend gentleman, “it cannot be with you a matter of conjecture! Upon the supposition, however, that it is so divided, may I further ask, what may be the subjects of the respective books? Are they historical, or didactic, argumentative, or sententious?”
There was no way of escaping this direct questioning but by a confession of ignorance, and after a little further probing, the truth came out, that the party had never read the Koran.
“Perhaps, then, your knowledge of the Bible, with which you compare the Koran, is more extensive. Will you favor me with the names and contents of the several books of which the Bible is composed?” Ashamed to confess the full amount of his ignorance, the challenger turned to his companion and said, “You can answer him, Dennis.”
Dennis protested, that, though he had read something of the Bible when at school, he had never looked into it since.
“Then,” said the gentleman, addressing the first speaker, “I must say that I have not been fairly treated. You rouse me from my slumber to enter upon a discussion as to the merits of the Bible and Koran, and it turns out you have read neither the one nor the other. I should recommend you to obtain some acquaintance with the Bible before you venture another time to pronounce upon its inferiority to any book whatever.”
Upon this rebuke, the challenger was silent.
—Christian Herald.