Among various reasons “why Christians refuse the Saturday Sabbath,” which the United Presbyterian, published at Pittsburgh, Pa., has recently essayed to give, is the statement that “in the nature of the case, the resurrection of Christ is sufficient ground for the change of the day.” This is the generally-accepted belief of the Protestant world; and it seems strange that among intelligent Christians a reason so palpably insufficient for the purpose should have received such general credit. It should not require more than a slight examination of the subject to convince any intelligent person that in the very nature of the case, the resurrection of Christ can have no natural connection whatever with the institution of a weekly Sabbath.
In the first place, the event has no relation whatever to six days of work. The Sabbath institution, however, had such a relation and depended upon it. Without the first six days of work, there could have been no Sabbath at all. If, therefore, a new Sabbath came into existence with the Christian dispensation, founded upon the resurrection of Christ, it was an entirely new institution, and not a simple change of the day under a continuation of the original institution. Therefore also the fourth commandment can never be quoted with any forcep. 313 whatever in support of a Sabbath so originating. That God worked six days in creation and that Christ rose from the dead upon the first day of the week, are facts which have no possible relation to, or bearing upon, each other.
Again: The resurrection of Christ is of no force in establishing a weekly Sabbath, or; indeed, a weekly memorial of any kind. No event, however great, can establish a weekly memorial merely because it happens to fall upon some day of the week. As with every event, the resurrection of Christ could not but occur upon some day of the week; but did it therefore become related in some way to the week? —No; it will hardly be claimed, even by the most ardent Sunday advocate, that, because an event has happened upon some day of the week, it ought to be celebrated weekly. The birth of Christ bears just the same relation to the week as do the events of his death or resurrection. Why, then, should Christmas not be celebrated weekly? Does not his birthday recur as frequently as his resurrection day?—Certainly; both days recur once a year, and once only. It is, therefore, altogether improper to say that Sunday, meaning any Sunday in the year, is the day on which Christ rose from the dead; and for the same reason, altogether meaningless to observe every Sunday in the year in commemoration or in honor of that event. As well might one observe every Monday in the year (supposing Christ to have been born on that day), in commemoration or in honor of his birth. At most, there could be but one Sunday in the year upon which Christ rose from the dead; and as the particular day of the month would fall upon a different day of the week in each consecutive year, as with Christmas or the Fourth of July, it could fall upon Sunday about once in every seven years, and therefore, to keep the day upon which Christ rose from the dead, and keep it on Sunday, would necessitate that a person should observe just one Sunday in seven years!
The resurrection of Christ was an event; the Sabbath was (and is) an institution. The day upon which an event happens is not of weekly, but yearly, recurrence. An event has its anniversaries, and it can have nothing more. And as if to guard against even anniversary celebrations of the events of Christ’s birth and resurrection, Providence has shrouded both in such uncertainty, as regards the date of their occurrence, that no one claims the former to be observed upon the correct date, while the observance of the latter fall anywhere within a period of several weeks in the months of March and April, according to the year in which the date is computed.
There is but one proper observance which is of weekly recurrence, and that is the observance of the creation Sabbath; and let it be observed that the observance pertains to the day itself, and not—as with Sunday—to an event which happened on that day. This day—the Sabbath—marks the termination of the week, and must therefore be of weekly recurrence. It—like every other day—is an inseparable part of the week, and was at its institution blessed and set apart for man’s use in all subsequent ages. Until it can be shown that the first day of the week has undergone some like change in character, and that the original seventh-day Sabbath—the memorial of creation—has been by divine authority abolished, there can be no reasonable claim made for the propriety or sanctity of the Sunday Sabbath. But as even God himself cannot change the facts of history, the seventh day must ever remain a day set apart for man’s observance as the memorial of creation; hence the seventh-day Sabbath cannot have been abolished. And as this Sabbath must be preceded by six working days, Sunday must forever remain in character what it was at the first,—a common day of work.
From these considerations we think it must plainly appear that “in the nature of the case, the resurrection of Christ is” not “sufficient ground for changing the day.”
L. A. S.