AdventAI

Review of a Tract on The Christian Sabbath

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 26., June 28, 1892

A friend has sent us a little leaflet of four pages, on “The Christian Sabbath,” by one “Rev. A. Smith” of Saratoga Springs, N. Y., asking that it be reviewed. The only notable thing about the tract is that so many assumptions and conflicting views can be set forth in so small a compass. The writer first quotes the fourth commandment, which enjoins the specific seventh day, and says that any day will fulfill the “spirit” of the commandment. But God tells us to keep the commandment, not its spirit. This writer then says that we cannot keep any definite day, on account of difference of time, which is not only false but foolish; then, that the Sabbath was changed from the seventh day to the first day of the week, although no definite day can be kept anyway; then that the apostles did not condemn Sunday-keeping, so it must be right; that Christ appeared to his disciples every succeeding “Lord’s day” after his resurrection, for which statement there is not the first iota of proof; that the first day has been used for divine worship from apostolic times till now, which is wholly false; that the Christian fathers indorsed the Lord’s day, but not as a continuation of the Jewish Sabbath, thus contradicting the idea of any change; that the so-called Lord’s day commemorates creation (which it cannot do) and rest from the work of redemption (which work is not yet finished); that as a plurality of Sabbaths causes confusion, we should all keep the Lord’s day (why not the seventh day?); and finally that the Pharisees were very zealous for the Sabbath, but they were the chief opposers of Christ, and therefore we should not keep the seventh day! It would hardly seem that any one high enough up in the scale of being to be held morally accountable, could be affected by arguments so shallow and self-contradictory; and so we let it pass.