In the June number of the Arena, Rev. M. J. Savage contributes an article, in which he discusses the rights of children,—not their legal rights, but their ideal, or natural, rights. Probably to none of our readers will the idea be new that children, not less than grown-up people, have rights; but it has been so common in this world, for rights to be disregarded by those who have had the power to do so, that the enlightenment of the present age has not yet been able wholly to reveal the long hidden truth that every human being possesses rights, and that the existence of such rights is not all dependent upon the ability of the possessor to assert them. To some, therefore, the thoughts here presented may seem strange, but rather so, we think, from the standpoint of precedent, than from that of reason and truth. The subject at least is one which is worthy of careful study. Mr. Savage says:—
The first right of a child is, to be well born. Some one wittily says that a child cannot be too careful in the selection of its parents; and this covers a great truth. If it were possible for a child to have anything to say in regard to so grave a matter as that, it would be the most important act in the child's life. A child has a right to be well born, to be started right; not to be weighted, crippled, burdened, hampered, from the outset, by physical disabilities, by moral twist or taint, by intellectual defect.
The existence of this ideal right is of course contrary to the idea that those persons who would transmit such serious disabilities and defects to their children have the right to enter into the marriage relation,—not to their legal right to do this, but to their natural right. He continues:—
The next right is to a happy childhood. A happy childhood! This may be taken away from the child in one of many ways. It may be taken away by the selfishness of the father or mother, by their carelessness, by their indulging in perpetual faultfinding, nagging, interfering, the result of “over-nerves” on the part of either father or mother. It may be the result of a temper not properly controlled, the result of superstition. It may be because the child at too early an age is put at task work for the sake of increasing the income of the family. There are hundreds and thousands of children in this city of Boston who, as they grow up to maturity, will never be able to look back to a dewy, sunny, sweet, bright sunrise and early morning of life. And yet I believe that the child, as he or she goes on in the world, can have no finer thing than that to look back upon. And it is not merely the rest that may come of it, though that is indeed important enough of itself to make it worth our while. How many of us, in spite of the hardship or poverty, perhaps, which was hardly appreciated or realized,—how many of us who did have a happy childhood, find ourselves wandering in that old land, when we are worn and weary, and finding rest and peace in sweet associations with the shadowy forms of those who walk on earth no more! It is worth while for one to keep this as a romance-land, a fairy-land, a place to which the old man can go back to unburden and refresh and rest himself for an hour.
But it means more than that. As a man goes on in life, there come great crises,—hours when he needs something to hold to,—when perhaps he loses his faith in men or women; and if he has this ideal memory, there will be one woman at whose shadowy feet he will forever bow in reverence, finding an accession of trust come to him for life at large, and rise a braver and stronger man for the worship of his mother. But if he can add to this that superb respect for his father which makes him feel that, whatever else happens, however he may look upon other men, there has been a man, then he will find it easy to believe in humanity, in the possibilities of the future. So this may be not only comfort and peace, but also strength and support and guidance in future years.
The third right of a child is the right to be properly educated. I shall divide this part of my subject into two or three parts. It has the right to be educated into a fitness for self-support; and this is a right the importance of which is constantly growing with the spread over the earth of democracy, and with the social and industrial ideals which we believe in and cherish in this country. This is the prime end, in my judgment, of education. Teach the child, boy or girl, that he or she has come into a world that is not rich, but that is comparatively poor,—a world where he has no right to take away from the store of accumulated wealth without adding at least as much, by his own effort, in its place.
When you have taught your child self-support, when you have taught it the principles of right and wrong, the ideals of a noble life, then you may enter, if you will, the other field, which sometimes is regarded as being the principal thing in the matter of education. Teach these things first that I have pointed out,—self-support, the main lines of right and wrong, as they run through this world; and then, for the joy of the child, for the enrichment of the child's life, put into that child's hand, if you can, the keys by which to unlock all the world's store-rooms of inherited wisdom and achievement. . . .
One more right of the children,—the right to a rational religious education. I speak and write, when I have an opportunity, with a great deal of feeling on this matter; for there seems to me to be such a carelessness, such an inscrutable fatality on the part of thousands of liberals in this country, as, it seems to me, to be almost impossible to comprehend. I marvel at it. Many liberals seem to think that liberalism means “don't care,”—means indifference,—means that it does not matter; that one thing is just as good as another, and that none of them are worth much. Thousands of people have outgrown the old ideas. They fear no more, and so they think that life is a mere race of “go-as-you-please.”
It seems to me so strange that people do not understand that in this highest of all things is the last place for carelessness, for playing with the souls of their children, with the relations of their souls to the infinite Source and Father.
Teach your child false arithmetic, if you will; he will get that knowledge out of him very speedily in a short business experience. Teach him false geography—that the Grecian Archipelago is in the Indian Ocean; that is a matter of very slight importance. Teach him false history; it will make very little difference to him whether he can tell who came first, Richard III or Henry VII. Teach him falsely almost everything else, and it is of slight importance, compared with false teaching here. . . . Do not dare carelessly or thoughtlessly to train your child so that he shall become a block on the wheels of God's chariot which carries the desires, the trusts, and the longings of the race toward a better future. Train your child not as though you were infallible. Train the child to go beyond your teaching, but not to get behind it or on one side of it. Train your child to keep a clear-eyed vision of the highest and last truth that God reveals, and to listen with attentive ear to the last word he whispers. This, on your peril, is the most important thing you can do for your children.
On the subject of the rights of parents over their children, the same writer says:—
I believe our rights over our children are very few and very small.
What is the right that you have over your child? You have no personal, no selfish rights at all over your own child. You have invited an immortal [mortal] to come into your temporary keeping; and you have only the right to treat that as a reverent trust committed to you for awhile, which you are to discharge with the highest and noblest sense of responsibility which you can attain. That is your right over your child. People have had in the past an idea, and many people think still, that they have a right to use the service, the brains, the physical strength, of the child as a mere adjunct of the family, as a source of income. If a father or mother be very poor, and the child comprehends the situation, generally there need be no force to lead the child to do what it can to add to the general support. But the right of the father to compel him, is a very limited one, indeed; and it stops a long way short of the right to sacrifice the welfare, the future, of that life even to this exigency. Even for the sake of appeasing hunger in the home, I say no father, no mother, has a right to sacrifice the future of the child, so that in years to come the child shall feel, I have not had half an opportunity to become what was possible to me.
The following, with which Mr. Savage closes his article, while doubtless contrary to the opinions of many parents, is well worthy of thoughtful consideration:—
There is one other right which is often claimed, which I wish emphatically to deny. There are young men and women whom fathers and mothers never allow to grow up—whose lives are absorbed by the selfishness of parental love. I know cases where the mother would stand square in the way of the boy's best future out of what she calls love, but which, if you analyze it, is only a clinging, whining kind of selfishness, which could not bear the boy out of sight; a jealousy of any other love which the boy might cherish—standing in the way of his future, and yet calling it love. There is no love about it. It is the veriest selfishness, when it comes to the point of sacrificing the welfare of the boy to this desire to see him forever by the mother's side.
Then I have known cases of young women. Because the father or mother wanted them in the home, because they wanted their service, these parents would stand in the way of the grandest right that is before the footsteps of any young woman,—“the right to love, the right to motherhood, the right to a home, the right to the unfolding of that which is divinest and highest in her.” Do not dare to claim this sort of selfish absorption of the lives of your children as a parental right. It is not a right, but a wrong.
What, then, is the outcome? The one thing for father and mother to do is to make themselves needless just as early as possible. We do not know how long we shall be here. We need to make the boys and girls self-centered, independent, masters of themselves, masters of their surroundings, competent to deal with the practical affairs of the world, competent to choose the right and refuse the wrong, competent to walk alone or to choose their companions. We need not get rid of them. If we bind them by the hands of love, they will stay by that fast enough, as long as they can; but if you bind them by any other bonds, they will snap them as soon as they are able. Push them over the edge of the nest as fast as you can—not because you do not wish them to come back, but because you wish them to learn to use their wings. Teach the children, boys and girls both, to be independent. A healthy body, a sane mind, ability to earn one's own living, a knowledge of right and wrong, possession of a key to unlock the storehouse of the inherited wealth of the world, love for father and mother that shall be deathless, a happy memory of a happy childhood, the ideal of a manhood that makes service of one's age the noblest thing to be dreamed of, a consecration to the highest ideal of God, trust in him, a faith that can walk serenely out into the dark, a manhood, a womanhood self-poised, independent, able to walk alone,—is not that the ideal? That is the right of every child; and the only right that you have over the child is the right of bestowing this.
L. A. S.