Congressional Interference.
By M. E. K.
The feelings of the popular clergy of this time in regard to the rights and wishes of those who oppose them in their Sunday-law legislation, was well expressed a few days since by a prominent Methodist Episcopal minister of Chicago. Thus he said: “But even though the great mass of the people did demand an open, godless Sabbath, Congress would have no right to respect such wishes.” That is to say, Congress has no right to respect the wishes of the majority of the people, if the people dare to oppose the wishes of the churches. In such a case, General Grant’s famous saying that “this is a Democratic republic, where the will of the people is the law,” would be reversed, and the people would be compelled to submit to the minority. The reason given that Congress would have no right to respect the wishes of the people in such a case, is as remarkable as the position itself. “The law of the State of Illinois is quite specific, in pointing out that no work shall be performed on the Sabbath, except work of charity or of actual necessity. For Congress to permit the Fair to be open on the Sabbath day, would be for it to permit the violation of one of the most important laws of the State of Illinois. Congress would have just as good a right to give permission to the people to break any other law of the State, as to break this law.” It being true that the law of the State of Illinois is quite specific in regard to the Sabbath (Sunday), what right has Congress to interfere in the matter at all? Cannot Illinois enforce her own laws to suit herself without the interposition of Congress? What is this action of Congress but an unwarranted interference with the prerogatives of a sovereign State, to make her enforce her own laws? If we should ask a constitutional lawyer why Congress might not properly make a law that men in Illinois should not steal, he would undoubtedly reply that Illinois, as a sovereign State, has a right to define and punish crime within her borders, and that in regard to such matters Congress has no more right to interfere than the State of Indiana has to say what shall be called crime in Illinois. But Congress assumes this right in regard to the conditions accompanying the World’s Fair appropriation. Congress has therefore violated the Constitution in two ways: (1) By legislating in regard to a religious institution; (2) by interfering with the internal affairs of a sovereign State, and in regard to a point upon which that State has a specific law of its own. When Congress can thus step outside of its rightful jurisdiction, and under color of carrying out the State laws, invades the sanctity of an independent State, in matters which are expressly forbidden it to do by the Constitution, what guarantee have we that State laws will not finally be entirely subservient to national laws, and the country, instead of a federation of States, become a centralized nation, whose laws shall all be made at Washington? If the Constitution and the feelings and rights of the people can be ignored by Congress now, and the people do not rise in righteous indignation and demand their liberties, will not the clergy, who have their united hands upon the throat of religious liberty, succeed in their purpose of choking it into submission to their will? They certainly are seeking to do so, and they are persuaded that the petitions of those who oppose their wishes should not be regarded. In regard to this, the same minister quoted above, referring to the fact that but few members of the Catholic Church are calling for the closing of the World’s Fair on Sunday, says: “It is this class of the Church of Rome, and this class alone, who are competent to give expression to the true Christian sentiments of that church.” And that is to say that those who do not petition as he and others of his class do, are not competent to say what ought to be done! The churches, especially the pastors, are the self-appointed judges of the competency of the people, and if they bring in a report of incompetency, Congress will take action accordingly! This is only equaled by Joseph Cook’s famous saying lately reported in the papers, “that while the quantity of signers for an open Sunday at the Fair might be greater than those for a closed Fair on Sunday, yet the quality was inferior!” Surely, when no one who opposes church domination is competent to express an opinion, all such people being of an inferior quality to church people, the mountain of the Lord’s house is established in the top of the mountains, when no one but members of popular churches are competent to express an opinion.