Of all the beliefs cherished by mankind which have in their support neither reason nor revelation, one of the most wide-spread is that of the immortality of the soul. While the other great error which, next to this, has come to dominate Christendom,—namely, the keeping of the first day of the week as the Sabbath, instead of the seventh day, which God ordained,—has come in rather as an effect than a cause, being the offspring of sun worship, this stands as the fruitful parent of a host of other errors. It has a larger progeny of superstitions and degrading practices to answer for, than perhaps any other doctrine in the whole range of religious beliefs.
As the first and inevitable idea that springs from it is that of the conscious state of the dead, making good the words of the serpent to Eve, “Ye shall not surely die,”—it lies at the very foundation of all the various forms of heathenism. In Christian creeds it leads inevitably to the abhorrent dogma of eternal misery for the lost, and thus becomes a fruitful source of infidelity. It paves the way for a belief in the doctrines of rewards and punishments at death, and the Romish purgatory. It fosters such degrading practices as saint-worship, invocation of saints, prayers for the dead, baptism for the dead, and Mariolatry. It compels one logically to deny the scriptural doctrines of the personal second coming of Christ, the general resurrection of the dead, and the future general judgment. With the more mercifully inclined, it leads to restorationism, and universalism, while with multitudes, both in the church and out, skeptics at heart, and chafing under moral restraint, it blossoms out into the last grand delusion of Spiritualism, which is destined to play so important a part in the closing scenes of this world’s history.
Those who think that the Bible teaches the doctrine of the immortality of the soul, are of course solicitous to show that it is sustained by its testimony. By such, much stress is laid upon the record of man’s creation, in the book of Genesis. This is right; for if man is endowed with the attribute of immortality, we might expect to find it brought to view, if anywhere, in the record of his creation. And it is confidently claimed by some that it is so brought to view. It is supposed that the breath of life which is said to have been given to man, or the manner in which it was given—breathed into his nostrils—signifies that there was given to him a soul which can never become unconscious, and can never die.
But a fact soon appears which entirely demolishes such a conclusion; for the very same record, specifying the different orders of animals which perished in the flood,—fowl, cattle, beast, every creeping thing, and man, declares that they all alike had in their nostrils the “breath of life.” No argument, therefore, in behalf of an immortal soul in man, can be built up on this expression, unless we are willing to allow the same to all classes of animals and creeping things which live by breathing.
And the argument attempted on the words “living soul,” in the declaration, “and man became a living soul” (Gen. 2:7), fares no better; for this expression, like “the breath of life,” is applied alike to all the different orders of animals. The word “life,” in Gen. 1:20, and the words, “living creature,” in verses 21 and 24, and here applied to fowl, fish, beasts, and creeping things, are the same words which, in chap. 2:7, are applied to man, and translated “living soul.”
Still it is supposed by some that the peculiar use of certain terms in the original Hebrew, do indicate that the “breath of life” as applied to man was something different from the breath of life as applied to the lower orders of animals, and moreover that it was imparted to man in a different manner, “breathed into his nostrils,” which is not said of other animals, and therefore must mean something different in the case of man. Thus a correspondent has sent us a criticism, from a friend of his, on these points, in which the Hebrew terms in the texts in question are thought to stand as an objection to the view we hold. The points he makes are these: The Hebrew words for “breath of life” in Gen. 2:7, are nishmath hhayim; and here man alone is referred to; but in Gen. 6:17 and 7:15, where animals alone are referred to, the words are, ruahh hhayim; and in Gen. 7:22, where both men and beasts are referred to, both words are used and joined together thus: nishmath-ruahh hhayim. So the conclusion he draws, is, that the word nishmath (from n’shah-mah) denotes the breath of life peculiar to man, and the word ruahh, that which is peculiar to beasts; and that this fact, taken in connection with the statement that God breathed into man’s nostrils his breath of life, is sufficient to prove an immortal soul for man.
Against this criticism several conclusive objections may be urged:—
1. The words n’shahmah (נשמה) and ruahh (רוח), are almost identical in definition. They are the two Hebrew words which correspond to the one Greek word pneuma (πνεῦμα). Gesenius defines the first to mean, “1. Breath, spirit, spoken of the breath of God, i. e., (a) the wind; (b) the breath, breathing of his anger; (c) the Spirit of God, imparting life and wisdom. 2. Breath, life, of man and beasts; Gen. 2:7; and breathed into his nostrils, nishmath hhayim, the breath of life; more fully, nishmath-ruahh hhayim, Gen. 7:22.” The same author defines the second (ruahh) to mean, “1. Breath, a breathing, blowing, i. e., (a) breath of the nostrils; (b) breath of the mouth. Often the vital breath, breath of life; fully, ruahh hhayim, Gen. 6:17.” etc.
So far as definition is concerned, therefore, there is nothing to distinguish man in these words, though one of them might be exclusively confined to him, which is not the case. As used in the Scriptures, n’shahmah is rendered “breath,” seventeen times, and ruahh, “breath,” twenty-eight times.
2. As already noticed, the words for “breath of life” in Gen. 6:17, are simply ruahh hhayim; but this passage is a prediction of the flood, wherein God told Noah whom and what he would destroy; and it was, “all flesh wherein is the breath of life,” “and everything that is in the earth shall die.” This must certainly include man; for the primary object of the flood was to destroy a sinful and utterly apostate race of men; and in his prediction of what the flood was to destroy, God would not confine himself to simply the lower animals, and leave out man, the chief offender. So here ruahh is applied to man.
3. And now we shall find that n’shahmah is applied to the lower animals as well as to man. This is proved by Gen. 7:21, 22. After stating the result of the flood, that all flesh died, fowl, cattle, beast, and creeping things, and every man, the record adds: “All in whose nostrils was the breath of life (nishmath-ruahh hhayim), of all that was in the dry land, died.” This is a plain declaration that all of the classes here mentioned had in their nostrils the breath of life, as here described.
If this is not so, and the distinction exists for which our friend contends, then the record should have read, “And all flesh died that moved upon the earth, both of fowl and of cattle and of beast, and of every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth, in whose nostrils was ruahh hhayim, and every man in whose nostrils was nishmath hhayim.” But no such distinction is made; but both terms are used, the strongest ever applied to man or beast, and applied to all indiscriminately. Thus again it appears that so far as physical organizations and vitality are concerned, man is not possessed of any superior principle over the other orders of the animal creation.
In addition to this, Solomon declares that they (both man and beasts) all have one breath (Eccl. 3:19); that is, that the breath of life in man is no different from that in any other animal. Hence the “breath of life” does not prove any immortality for man.
This being the case, it can hardly be supposed that any one will seriously urge any distinction based on the fact that this breath is said to have been breathed into man’s nostrils. We know that this breath was in the nostrils of man and beast alike; and we know how it was put into man’s nostrils—it was breathed in. How did it come into the same organs—into the nostrils—in the case of beasts? The only consistent inference is that it was put there by the same power in the same way; that is, breathed in. If any deny this, it will devolve on them to show some other possible way in which it could have been imparted. When it is said that the breath of life was in the nostrils of both man and beasts, and then it is told how it was placed in man’s nostrils, to assert that it was not given to beasts in the same way, and that therefore it was immortal in man, but not in beasts, is to reason without premises, build without a foundation, and draw inferences without necessity, which have no logical connection either with each other, or with the conclusion.
Man has no immortal soul; and this severs at one blow the great tap root of Spiritualism. It demolishes every pillar on which the superstructure of that great movement is reared. It is calculated to guard men, as nothing else can guard them, from this great delusion.
But the doctrine of conditional immortality does not in any way lower the dignity of man, or belittle the work of the Creator. He is endowed with an organization so superior that it enables him to exercise the highest mental, intellectual, and spiritual functions, and gives him a moral nature, and makes him a morally accountable being. As such, eternal life is set before him as an object which he may attain. And if he will comply with the conditions upon which it is offered, and unite himself to Christ through whom it is to come, there is before him a degree of exaltation which no seraphim can transcend—an eternity of existence, filled with all capabilities, joy, and satisfaction for himself, and through him, praise, honor, and glory to his Creator and Redeemer.