AdventAI

UNION OF THE CHURCH WITH THE STATE AND THE THEATER.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 37., September 13, 1892

For the past few weeks, Englewood, one of Chicago’s most populous suburbs, has been the scene of a most interesting Sunday-closing battle, in which the National Religious Liberty Association has taken no small part, with the result that the gospel of liberty has been preached to thousands.

The history of the struggle briefly told is as follows:—

There is a theater in Englewood which up to within a few weeks, has not given Sunday performances. A performance was advertised for Aug. 21. Across the alley from the theater is located the First Baptist church of Englewood, built on property purchased from the owner of the theater, and built after the theater had been built and operated. Following the announcement that the theater would give a Sunday-night performance, a meeting was called to protest against it. The leaders in the movement were the officers and members of the Young Men’s Christian Association, although most of the churches were identified with the movement.

At this meeting a committee of ten was appointed to take steps to prevent the advertised Sunday-night performance. This committee petitioned the Mayor and Chief of Police, invoking them to enforce an old ordinance of the town of Lake (which, prior to its annexation, included Englewood), which prohibited Sunday amusements, and prevent the play.

As an excuse for enforcing the law, which the attorney for the theater management declares was abrogated by the act annexing Englewood to Chicago, it was asserted that the theater disturbed the services of the Baptist church across the alley. To ascertain the facts in the case, the writer went to the scene of the excitement the evening the performance was advertised to be given, and made a careful investigation. The writer was in the church while the theater orchestra was playing, and did not hear it. At the close of the church services, three members of the church were asked if they had heard the music from the orchestra, and replied that they had not. A prominent member of the church was asked, if in case the theater was occupied Sunday nights by the Salvation Army with its bass drum, cymbals, and tambourines, whether he would have them arrested, to which he answered, “No.” He was then shown that it was not the music which disturbed them, if it disturbed them at all, but the fact that the music was made by people who did not observe the day in harmony with their ideas of Sunday observance, to which he answered plainly that it was not a question of disturbance, but a question of law. They had the law, and they proposed to enforce it.

After becoming satisfied that the whole matter was a case of religious intolerance, the writer introduced himself to the managers of the theater, explaining to them that it was not from sympathy with theatrical presentations that the National Religious Liberty Association had interested itself in the attempt to close the theater, but because of its interest in the great principle of religious liberty involved.

While conversing with the managers, the leader of the closing movement came up and began discussing the question with the ticket seller, who was selling tickets and admitting people to the entertainment contrary to the church edict. Seeing the office door open, he crowded himself in, and wanted to discuss the matter with the managers. The attorney for the managers introduced the gentleman to the writer, and he was asked to be seated and talk the matter over. After listening for a few minutes to the expounding of the principles of religious liberty as applied to the case in hand, he seemed dazed; and without attempting a reply, he beat a hasty retreat.

The principles of religious liberty presented, interested the managers and their attorney, and from this resulted the Association’s free use of the theater the following Sunday night.

The managers of the theater desired to test the matter in the courts, and for that reason, opened their house and asked to be arrested. But the church people were wily, and only a few minutes before the entertainment was to begin, notified the managers that they would arrest the actors, and not the managers, as was first agreed.

This would prevent the play from proceeding, and also prevent the managers from appealing to the courts for redress, since the actors were under contract to play in Milwaukee the following night, and would not subject themselves to arrest and the consequent detention, by going onto the stage. To intimidate them, policemen were placed on the wings of the stage, and to intimidate the people who desired to see the performance, a squad of police, egged on by the State church men present, stationed themselves across the entrance to the theater; but they were afterward ordered from this position by the policeman in command, when he discovered what the church had done.

To witness this battle between the theater and the church with the police power of the city at its command, more than a thousand people filled the streets in front of the theater. To render the situation still more complex and exciting, the Salvation Army marched by, beating their drums, cymbals, and tambourines, and thereby making much more noise than the theater orchestra, which, out of respect for the church, did not use its drums or cymbals. Words cannot picture the scene as it appeared to the writer, so prophetic in character, and so full of meaning to him who views events in the light of the third angel’s message. The State church was triumphant, and the theater compelled to dismiss its audience.

During the following week, the Association printed several thousand large and small bills, announcing the meeting of the Association to be held the following Sunday night. These bills were posted and circulated free of charge, by the managers of the theater. Besides this, the theaterp. 583 managers distributed 32,000 pages of religious liberty literature at their own expense.

The bills announced as speakers, Elder A. T. Jones, editor of the American Sentinel, and Elder G. W. Ballenger of the Baptist denomination, and the writer. A letter was addressed to the Secretary of the Y. M. C. A., announcing the meeting, and inviting him to be present and state the reasons for the part his Association had taken in the matter, promising him a candid hearing and Christian treatment. He did not come. To checkmate our meeting and try, if possible, to break its force, all the so-called orthodox churches in Englewood withdrew their Sunday night appointments, and advertised an opposition mass-meeting to be held a few blocks away. In order to further injure our meeting, it was given out in the pulpits of the different churches that our speakers had failed us, and that our meeting had been abandoned. So arduously was the report circulated and believed, that some of our friends who had started to the meeting were made to believe that this was true, and were directed to the opposition meeting. Besides this, persons were stationed on the corners of the streets leading to our place of meeting to intimidate those who might desire to attend, with a religious boycott. Notwithstanding all this, more than a thousand people were present and listened to the addresses with marked attention, and responded at times with enthusiastic applause. Dr. A. H. Champlain, a resident of Englewood, and ex-president of the Cook county Board of Education, presided at the meeting.

Resolutions were presented, setting forth the principles involved in the forcible closing of the Marlowe theater and the World’s Fair on Sunday, and protesting against the union of Church and State involved in these actions. The remarks of the writer were intended to show that religious persecution was not confined to any time, place, or church; that all the necessary elements for persecution existed to-day in the hearts of men, and needed only an opportunity to manifest themselves, as shown in the recent persecutions in Tennessee, and the intolerant demands of the church for police power to close the theater. The fact was emphasized that the spirit of compulsion was not the Spirit of Christ.

Elder Jones founded his remarks on the words of Christ as recorded in John 12:47: “If any man hear my words, and believe not, I judge him not: for I came not to judge the world, but to save the world.” He showed from this that the church, in employing compulsion, was arrogating to itself a prerogative which Christ himself declared he had not come to this world to exercise. Again it was shown that he who had the gospel of Christ was possessed with almighty power, and that an appeal to the State to enable one to enforce his views of Christianity on dissenters, was a most humiliating acknowledgment that the one asking for civil power had lost faith in the power of the gospel.

By these and other Scripture arguments, it was clearly proved that Christianity was not on the side of compulsion, and no one, therefore, need fear to oppose these compulsory movements, with a fear that he was opposing Christianity. On the other hand, it is the duty of every man to oppose them in the interests of Christianity. An Englishman recently from the old country, repeatedly interrupted Elder Jones, and insisted on “airing” his views of Sunday observance. This furnished an opportunity to present the truth on this subject, and no part of the discussion was more entertaining to the audience than the following dialogue, which we give in substance:—

Englishman.—Don’t you believe in keeping the fourth commandment?

Elder Jones.—Yes; but what has the fourth commandment to do with Sunday?

Englishman.—Quote it.

Elder Jones.—(Quotes the commandment.) There, what has that to do with Sunday?

Englishman.—It has been changed.

Elder Jones.—Strange indeed! Ask me to quote the fourth commandment in support of Sunday observance, and then when I quote it, you say it is changed.

Englishman.—The commandment requires the keeping of a seventh part of time, and no definite day.

Elder Jones.—If the commandment is indefinite, God made it so, and intended it should be so. What right have you to make it definite?

Englishman.—The apostles changed the Sabbath.

Elder Jones.—(Quoted from American Sabbath Union, W. C. T. U., and other literature to show that they acknowledge that there is no apostolic command for the change of the day.)

Englishman.—The church changed the day.

Elder Jones.—Yes, the Roman Catholic Church.

Englishman.—No; the Catholic, or Universal, church, not the Roman Catholic Church.

Elder Jones.—It was the Roman Catholic Church, but granting your position for argument’s sake, you acknowledge that the church changed the Sabbath. What right has the church to force one of its church dogmas on people who do not belong to the church?

The convincing power of the gospel attended the words spoken, and the audience remained until half-past ten o’clock, giving marked attention.

An attorney present (an unbeliever) remarked to the writer that as he listened to the presentation of the doctrines of love as opposed to force, he felt like giving utterance to the words of Agrippa to Paul, “Almost thou persuadest me to be a Christian.”

Rev. G. W. Ballenger of the Baptist denomination, the third speaker advertised, could not be present, but telegraphed his regrets, and instructed us to read his position to the audience from his published discussion of the question of compulsory Sunday observance. Accordingly, the following quotation, among others, was read; and inasmuch as he is a Baptist minister, and the Baptist church is prominently connected with the movement to close the theater, it carried considerable weight with the listeners:—

“I am opposed to securing compulsory Sabbath observance, either by laws avowedly in the interest of such observance, or under cover of a purely civil enactment. I simply want the Sabbath institution to stand on its own eternal foundation, unaided by laws impelled by political strife, embittered by partisan feeling, as one of the blessed gifts of an all-wise and loving Creator to humanity for humanity’s good. The blessings of the Sabbath will be realized by all who observe it, but when an institution of the loving Creator is made by any man or set of men, a means to coerce or render less happy the lives of others, then the Creator is dishonored, religion is injured, and the individual is farther from the kingdom of God than though he had been left free to be won by the power of the gospel.”

Among the utterances made at the opposition mass-meeting, is the following by Rev. Chas. Reynolds, of the Congregational church:—

“We can frown down the Sunday opening of the play house, till we make it a by-word and a reproach in the community. We can put a stigma on the house, which it can never recover from unless it submits to the sentiment of the people. The theater will not be open on Sunday evenings long unless it is for church services. If there were no people to attend Sunday theaters, none would be open on that day. I have no animosity against the managers, but believe that they are misguided, and think that, under the circumstances, their venture will be a failure. As long as they persist in doing wrong, I will not attend, Sunday or any other day. I do not believe in boycotting, according to the common acceptance of the term, but if we succeed in closing this theater against Sunday shows now, other communities may profit by our action.”

At this meeting the following resolution was passed, among others:—

“Resolved, That a committee of five, of which Alderman E. J. Noble shall be chairman, be appointed by the chairman to employ counsel and whatever measures may be necessary to prevent such exhibitions on the Sabbath day.”

This committee appointed a sub-committee composed of Alderman E. J. Noble and Joseph Badenock, Jr., both prominent citizens and church men, to confer with the theater managers and adjust a settlement. The following from the Chicago Evening News of Friday, Sept. 2, tells the story of the shamefully compromising compromise:—

“The Englewood ‘church-and-theater’ fight is for the moment, at least, over.”
“A settlement has been arrived at between the contending parties, which is presumably satisfactory to both, though the terms are a little peculiar.”
“The articles of agreement were drawn up at a joint meeting of the theater people and two of the church party,—Alderman Noble and Mr. J. Badeneck, Jr. The discussion commenced last night, and continued to a late hour, and only after prolonged inquiry this morning, was it possible to discover the terms of the settlement.”
“Attorney J. McK. Cleland, president of the Englewood Young Men’s Christian Association, who has hitherto been the fountain-head of information regarding the struggle, was at a loss how to reply when asked what settlement had been arrived at. ‘You would better ask Alderman Noble,’ he said, ‘and talk with Mr. Fenn.’”
“‘Alderman Noble could not be found, but Mr. Fenn was in his real-estate office at 79 Clark street.”},{