AdventAI

The True Sabbath.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 46., November 22, 1892

A BROTHER sends us a copy of a little pamphlet entitled “The True Sabbath,” by W. L. Phillips, with the request that we review it, as it is affecting the minds of some in the localities where it is circulated.

There is not much to review. The pamphlet consists of twenty pages, sixteen of which are devoted to an attempt to pull down the true Sabbath, and four pages to bolster up a false Sabbath, which has been imposed upon Christendom by a mixture of heathenism and Christianity; and the book is pieced out with testimonials from five individuals who are, like himself, lost in their own fog. His heading, therefore, is incongruous and a misnomer.

The argument in the case before us is considerably simplified, because Mr. P. confines his line of thought chiefly to one point; namely, an effort to prove that the ten commandments constituted the old covenant; and as the old covenant has passed away, and we are living under the new, therefore the seventh-day Sabbath is not now binding. The whole effort, therefore, turns on the question whether the ten commandments did constitute the old covenant or not. And right here he takes his position, which is just exactly the opposite to the truth; for the ten commandments did not constitute the old covenant. And with this false assumption to start with, all his reasoning based thereon must be also false. All his labor in drawing conclusions from that which is utterly untrue in the start, is therefore worse than labor lost. If a man at Albany wishes to go to Buffalo, but starts east toward Boston, he will not reach Buffalo by traveling in that direction; and the farther he goes, the worse he is off. Such is Mr. P.’s reasoning to show that the Sabbath is done away because it belongs to the old covenant. He goes in just the opposite direction to that in which he should go to arrive at the truth.

But are not the ten commandments called a covenant?—Yes, but never the “first,” or “old, covenant.” Here is a plain distinction which the Bible makes; and we can never arrive at the truth if we fail to note and discriminate in reference to the distinctions which the Bible plainly sets forth. In the sense in which the ten commandments are called a covenant, the words of which they are composed are of course called “the words of the covenant,” and the tables on which they were written are called “the tables of the covenant,” and the ark where they were deposited, is called “the ark of the covenant.” And these few expressions are all the proof that our author adduces to show that the ten commandments were the old covenant. These forms of expression are all used in reference to the commandments, in the special sense in which they constituted a covenant; but they were not the first, or old, covenant, as we shall see.

1. A covenant “made,” is a covenant which did not exist before it was made. But the old covenant was made with the children of Israel, when the Lord took them by the hand to lead them out of the land of Egypt. Jer. 31: 32; Heb. 8: 9. “The Lord made not this covenant with our fathers,” said Moses to the children of Israel. Deut. 5: 3. This is what is called the first, or old, covenant. It was not known before that time. Its terms, conditions, and promises did not till that time exist. Now, if that was the ten commandments, then the ten commandments did not exist before that time, and until then, on this ground, there was no law against murder, idolatry, lying, stealing, etc. But there was a law against all these things, as the entire Bible record shows, and as every candid person will admit. “Sin was in the world,” says Paul in Rom. 5: 12–14, from Adam to Moses. But “sin is not imputed when there is no law.” Cain was a murderer, and was branded as such by the Lord for his sin. Other commandments can also be traced from Adam down, as well as that. The ten commandments therefore could not possibly be the covenant which was “made” with Israel when they came out of the land of Egypt.

2. Again: what ground do the ten commandments cover?—Simply this, namely, our relation to God and to one another, no more and no less. And these relations existed as soon as the parties to them existed. This is an axiomatic truth. The law governing such relations exists in the very nature of things, just as soon as the relations themselves exist. It never has been, nor could be, from first to last, right for any creature that God has made to have other gods, worship idols, blaspheme or profane time which he had made holy. Nor could it ever be right for any such beings to treat each other in any way different from that enjoined in the last six commandments of the decalogue. Nor can these obligations cease to exist so long as the relations to which they refer exist. What inconceivable absurdity, therefore, to say that these ten commandments could be a covenant “made” with any particular people, at any particular age of the world, which did not exist before, and which might come to an end afterward.

3. The violation of any of these precepts always and everywhere, from first to last, was, and is, sin. They can no more be changed than God can change his character or abdicate his throne. And on account of the immutability and perpetuity of these principles, and the fact that God cannot treat with the sinner or confer upon him spiritual blessings only on condition of his repenting and being obedient to these commandments—this is why they are called a “covenant,” and the only sense in which they are ever so called. They are the only basis on which God can bestow favors, and so are his universal “covenant” with all his creatures. Hence God in speaking of them calls them “my covenant;” and Moses, in speaking of them in relation to God, calls them his (God’s) covenant. They are never called a covenant “made,” but a covenant “commanded.” “And he [God] declared unto you his covenant, which he commanded you to perform, even ten commandments.” Not so did the Lord speak when he made with that people the old covenant. We find a record of this, beginning with Ex. 19: 3–9. Here the Lord came to them with a proposition, If ye will do so and so, then I will do such and such things for you. They could enter into the arrangement or reject it, just as they might choose. Here was a covenant “made with” them which was not made with their fathers, a covenant such as every covenant must be which is “made,” an arrangement based on mutual conditions and promises between two or more parties. And when the Lord came to them with this proposition, the condition on his part was that they should keep his covenant, which was already, it thus appears, in existence. Never does the Lord give to the people any option or choice in regard to his commandments. His law is righteousness and truth, and he who would enjoy his favor must keep it.

“No love,” says Mr. P., “in the old covenant,” or, as he calls it, the ten commandments. But from what did Christ quote the two great principles, which he calls the two great commandments, namely, to love God with all the heart, and our neighbors as ourselves? Matt. 22: 35–40. He quoted them from what Mr. P. calls “the old covenant.” (See Deut. 6: 5 and Lev. 19: 18.) And yet these principles, which Christ gives the very highest place in the scheme of morality, Mr. P. has the effrontery to assert were not known in that age! These were but a summary of the ten commandments, which showed their nature in that age as well as in this.

Christ, in the plainest and most explicit manner, taught the perpetuity of that law in this dispensation. Matt. 5: 17–20. He thus incorporated it into the new covenant. All the principles of the new covenant were set forth before Christ died upon the cross, the act by which he closed up, ratified, and sealed the new covenant. Nothing could be added to it after that. Gal. 3: 15. But nobody pretends that Sunday-keeping came in till after that. Sunday-keeping is therefore too late. It has no place in the new covenant.

The few glittering generalities and rhetorical flourishes he introduces in regard to the first day of the week,—the vanquishing of the powers of darkness, the great triumph, the pouring out of the Spirit, etc., we need not stop to notice. They were all very interesting and glorious events, but they impose no obligation. There are services ordained which appropriately commemorate Christ’s death, burial, and resurrection, but not by a rest day.

Mr. P. mentions no act by which the Sunday institution was ordained, for there was no such act: he gives us no title of honor or sacredness applied to that day; for no such title was ever bestowed upon it. He gives us no law for its observance; for no such law was ever promulgated. And then he quotes Col. 2: 14–16, which, if it applies to a weekly Sabbath at all, abolishes Sunday as well as the seventh day. He reminds us of the story of the captain of the Mulligan guards, who, in showing off his wonderful dexterity as a swordsman, gave his saber such a sublime flourish, that he slashed off his own head.

The old covenant, with its types, shadows, offerings, and ordinances, has passed away, giving place to the new, with its gospel ordinances, blessings, and privileges. But the moral law remains the same, the transcript of the principles of God’s government, and the rule of life for his creatures in all ages; and it will be the standard of judgment in the last day. Eccl. 12: 13, 14; James 2: 8–12. That law still requires the observance of the seventh day, God’s great memorial, the creation Sabbath, which the world needs as much to-day as it ever did.

Let the reader beware lest any man lead him to trample on the requirements of God. Take heed, says Christ, that no man deceive you.