THE notion that mankind is to be granted another probation after this life, is one that is making insidious advances into the various so-called evangelical churches. The old landmarks which were erected by Christ, prophets, and apostles are now being rudely removed. The judgment is robbed of its most startling features; for it decides nothing finally; and the coming of Christ is looked upon as an event that may occur, and only a few persons know anything of it, or as a fact of news that may be telegraphed as an important item for the daily press! The grand events which the Bible describesp. 730 as taking place at his coming,—the destruction of the wicked, the resurrection of the righteous dead, and the change of the righteous living to immortality, are so spiritualized away by the theologians of our day that they have lost their true meaning, and thus the people are being prepared for the deception of Satan when he will personate the Lord Jesus Christ, and will deceive those who reject the third angel’s message.
As an illustration of the doctrine of future probation, and the arguments that are used in its support, and which divert the minds of many people from the solemn issues now before us in this country in relation to the formation of an image to the beast, we call attention to an argument for the restoration and future probation of the Sodomites, who were destroyed by God because of their wickedness. It is argued that the Bible teaches that the people of ancient Sodom will have another opportunity for repentance, and as they were so utterly vile that the Lord did not allow them to live out the fullness of their natural lives, it therefore follows that if a second probation is granted to them, every other wicked person must have the same opportunity, since God is no respecter of persons. We join issue upon this point, and deny that there is any evidence that the Sodomites will ever have another opportunity of repentance. The Bible teaches no such doctrine.
To get the matter fairly before the readers of the REVIEW, we will make a quotation from a book which endeavors to sustain this theory:—
“Surely, if we shall find the restitution of the Sodomites clearly taught, we may feel well satisfied of the truth of this glorious doctrine of restitution for all mankind spoken by the mouth of all the holy prophets. And why should not the Sodomites have an opportunity to reach perfection and everlasting life as well as Israel, or as any of us? . . . Jesus’ own words tell us that the Sodomites were not as great sinners in his sight as were the Jews, who had more knowledge, although God rained down fire from heaven and destroyed them all because of their wickedness. (Gen. 19:24; Luke 17:29.) Unto the Jews of Capernaum he said: ‘If the mighty works which have been done in thee had been done in Sodom, it would have remained until this day.’ Matt. 11:23, 24. Thus Jesus teaches that the Sodomites did not have a full opportunity; and he guarantees them such opportunity when he adds, ‘But I say unto you, that it shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom in the day of judgment than for thee.’”
We fail to see any evidence in the texts of Scripture above quoted, or proof for the assertion that accompanies the texts that Sodom will have another opportunity for repentance. The Sodomites may not have had as much light as the Jews of Jesus’ time had, yet they must have had enough to condemn them, or else God did them an injustice when they were destroyed. Lot dwelt in Sodom. Peter says, “That righteous man dwelling among them, in seeing and hearing, vexed his righteous soul from day to day with their unlawful deeds.” 2 Pet. 2:8. They had become so unutterably vile that the Lord would not allow them to live out their natural lives. That is to say, he cut off their probation. He gave them up as he did the heathen. Rom. 1:26. If the Sodomites are worthy of another probation, they were certainly worthy of a continued probation. Peter says God “condemned them with an overthrow, making them an ensample unto those that after should live ungodly.” 2 Pet. 2:6. If they are to have a second probation, then to be an “ensample,” they should have received a second probation right there when the first probation expired; but they did not, but received condemnation; and in that condemnation and the destruction that followed, they are a true “ensample unto those that after should live ungodly.”
Their punishment in the final judgment may not be so severe as that of the Jews who rejected Jesus, but they saw and rejected enough light to bring condemnation, or else God acted in an unjust and arbitrary manner in destroying them. We cannot believe that he did. Nor can we believe that those who rejected the Lord Jesus Christ when he was here in the flesh, will have another opportunity for repentance, as this writer thinks will be the case. If all the evidences of the fulfillment of the promises of the Messiah in Christ’s birth, life, and miracles could not make men believe, what but an absolutely compelling power could make them? And the Bible holds out no hope that any one will be compelled to accept Christ, or that any greater influences will be brought to bear upon the unregenerate than have been used for them in the past.
The doctrine of another probation,—another chance for salvation in a future life, which chance in this life has been rejected and despised, is well calculated to make men careless and indifferent about salvation. Now the everlasting gospel is being preached. Eternal consequences depend upon our acceptance or rejection of it. “He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved, and he that believeth not shall be damned,” or condemned,—the same condemnation that fell upon the Sodomites. To look for another opportunity for salvation after this life, is to presume upon the mercy of God.
The 16th chapter of Ezekiel is also quoted to prove that the Sodomites will have another opportunity for salvation. Again we quote from the same book:—
“But let us examine the prophecy further. After comparing Israel with Sodom and Samaria, and pronouncing Israel the most blameworthy (verses 48-54), the Lord says, ‘When I shall bring again their captivity, the captivity of Sodom and her daughters, and the captivity of Samaria and her daughters, then will I bring again the captivity of thy captives in the midst of them.’ The captivity referred to can be no other than their captivity in death; for those mentioned were then dead.”
Let us see if this statement will bear the test of a careful examination. At the time Ezekiel wrote his prophecy, the children of Israel were in actual captivity to the king of Babylon. He tells us in the first chapter and first verse of his prophecy that he “was among the captives by the river of Chebar.” This being the case, when he speaks of “captivity,” we should suppose that he means real captivity, such as he and his people were suffering, unless there are the strongest reasons why it should not be taken in a literal way. We believe that in the 16th chapter he is speaking of actual, literal, and present captivity, and that no reference is made to a resurrection of the dead, or to anything that is now in the future.
Let us look at this chapter carefully: Three different and distinct peoples are spoken of as being in captivity together. They are represented by Jerusalem, Samaria, and Sodom. Samaria and Sodom are called the sisters of Jerusalem. All are pronounced guilty, but Jerusalem is the most guilty. Of the two sisters, Samaria and Sodom, Samaria is the elder sister of Jerusalem, and Sodom the younger. Samaria dwelt at Jerusalem’s left hand, and Sodom at her right hand. Verse 46. The claim is made that the Sodomites who were in captivity were the ancient people of Sodom, one of the cities of the plain which was destroyed by fire from heaven, and that the captivity they were suffering was the death thus inflicted upon them. This looks like a large structure, erected upon a very shaky foundation. If the ancient and dead Sodomites are referred to, parity of reasoning would demand that dead Israelites and Samaritans of a time coeval with Sodom’s overthrow are also mentioned, but there were no Israelites at Jerusalem at that time. Isaac, the son of promise, was not even born. Samaria also had no existence. There is no question but that the people of Jerusalem were in actual captivity when Ezekiel wrote. There is also every reason to believe that the Samaritans who lived near Jerusalem, at her left hand, were also in actual captivity.
To class together events 1,300 years apart, as though they took place at the same time, would certainly involve a great incongruity in the prophecy. Such an incongruity is forced upon us if we accept the position we are examining. That the different peoples here called Jerusalem, Samaria, and Sodom were contemporary, is evident from the fact that they are called “sisters.” Sisters do not live 1,300 years apart. The term “Sodom,” as used in this chapter, cannot therefore apply to that people whom God destroyed for their wickedness by fire from heaven.
To whom, then, does the term “Sodom,” as used in this chapter, apply? The answer is easy to find. It applies to that people who lived in the country near the Dead Sea, where Sodom had once stood, and which name, as the name of its most ancient city, still was applied to that country. It is also probable that they were guilty of the same sins for which the city of Sodom was overthrown. The Moabites and Ammonites occupied this country. They were one side of Jerusalem, and Samaria was on the other. A glance at the map of Palestine will show that this was their relative position. As we examine the following chapters of Ezekiel, the proof that by the term “Sodom” the Moabites and Ammonites are meant, becomes very apparent. The 16th chapter of Ezekiel is the first chapter of the book which mentions any other people going into captivity except the people of Israel. These are called Samaria and Sodom. But in chapters 21 and 25 the Moabites and Ammonites are especially mentioned as being also brought under the power of the king of Babylon and at the same time of Jerusalem’s overthrow.
With this idea, all is clear. The king of Babylon made a clean sweep through the country. He took captives on every hand,—Israelites, Samaritans, Moabites, and Ammonites, and took them away into actual captivity. So we read of the Sodomites, in chapter 16:50: “Therefore I took them away as I saw good.” That the reference in the margin refers to Genesis 19 does not amount to anything as proof that these words were fulfilled at the destruction of Sodom by fire. References are not inspired. “Taking away” is a very good expression to describe a literal going into captivity, but a very poor term to describe the destruction of people by fire and brimstone falling upon them from heaven. Comparing the chronology of Ezekiel with that of Ezra, who led the Jews back from captivity, we find that about one hundred and thirty years after the captivity referred to in Ezekiel, there was a returning of the Jews to their “former estate.” Ezek. 16:55. While the return of the Samaritans and Sodomites (Moabites and Ammonites) who were carried away is not distinctly announced, there is reason to believe that they also found their way back into their own land. There is no necessity for such return to be especially mentioned, as they are only referred to in the prophecy to institute a comparison between their wickedness and the wickedness of the people of Israel.
We believe that we have given sufficient evidence that there is no proof that the wicked Sodomites of Abraham’s time will have another opportunity to repent, and that we have conclusively shown that the prophecy of Ezekiel 16 referred to an actual captivity that had recently taken place, and that the whole of that chapter was fulfilled ages in the past. M. E. K.