AdventAI

DISCUSSION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION

From Review and Herald, Vol. 41, No. 3., December 31, 1872

BETWEEN ELD. J. H. WAGGONER, S. D. ADVENTIST, AND ELD. PETER VOGEL, DISCIPLE.

THIRD PROPOSITION.

“Do the Scriptures teach that the seventh day Sabbath is to be observed by Christians throughout the gospel dispensation?”

ELD. WAGGONER, affirms; ELD. VOGEL, denies.

ELD. WAGGONER’S SECOND AFFIRMATIVE.

No one doubts that there have always existed persons ready to “wrest the Scriptures,” but common courtesy, to say nothing of Christian courtesy, demands that such an application to an opponent be omitted in a discussion of this kind. Eld. Vogel might bear in mind that he was not solicited by me to engage in this debate, and the unprejudiced reader can best judge which, if either, of us falls under this strong condemnation.

He seems to lay it to heart that I refer back to former propositions, as if the past scene of conflict brought sad memories to him. These questions are closely related, and there are truths underlying all which I intend shall not be lost sight of. No doubt if he could control both sides it would result much more to his satisfaction. If he has been accustomed to have an opponent conduct his affirmative according to his direction he may now have the benefit of a new experience. He has made strong complaints that, in a previous discussion, he had to lead out though in the negative. In all my observation I have never seen a stronger effort made to lead an affirmative than in his last article. In this I predict his failure.

But one question in the past demands further attention; it is his position on the Hebrew. And I will now explain to the reader, and should have done so before, that there is no indefinite article in the Hebrew. As, “In a beginning,” “The seventh-day is a Sabbath,” &c., the “a,” or its equivalent, is not in the original; of course the translators must determine when to supply it.

The reader will remember that I quoted a section from Crosby, in which he stated that, in poetry, the article is not so much used as in prose; and that in prose, manuscripts greatly differed in the use of the article. This I referred to the Hebrew as well as to the Greek, to prove that exceptions existed to the rules quoted by Eld. Vogel. And my claim of exceptions went no further than Crosby’s statement. On this Eld. V. replied, “The Hebrew, concerning which Eld. W. maintains a respectful silence, has no such exceptions as he would force on the Greek text.”

And here I must withdraw the admission I made that Green does not notice exceptions to those rules. That was according to my impression when I wrote; that impression being strengthened by the circumstance that Eld. Vogel quoted directly from Green, and yet denied that the Hebrew had any such exceptions as I claimed on Crosby’s statement. But having since examined Green’s grammar I find that he opens full as wide a field of exceptions in the Hebrew as Crosby does in the Greek; and this takes from Eld. Vogel even the slight excuse I was willing to make for him in regard to his sweeping assertion.

Green says, “The article is frequently omitted in the brief and emphatic language of poetry, where it would be required in prose.” § 247, p. 274. He instances as follows: Ps. 2:2, kings of earth, for kings of the earth; 72:17, in the presence of sun, for the sun; Isa. 21:12; watchman says morning comes, for the watchman and the morning; Dan. 8:13, to give both—sanctuary and—host,” &c. And he further gives instances of its omission in prose, as Ex. 27:21, in—tabernacle of—congregation; 1 Kings 16:16—captain of—host,” and others.

In his Chrestomathy, of Gen. 2:4, where it is literally, “in day the Lord God made earth and heavens,” he says, “This inversion of the accustomed order imparts to the expression a sort of poetic character, whence the omission of the article.” p. 88.

Here we have, 1st, a section stating the frequent poetic omission of the article. Isa. 56, on which Eld. Vogel lays so great stress in his speculations, comes under this head. Also Isa. 58:13, first clause. 2d. A claim for “a sort of poetic character” for a sentence in Gen. 2:4, to bring it under the rule for poetic omission, showing that the line between poetic omission and prose omission is not clearly marked.

3d. Instances (which may be greatly multiplied) where it is omitted also in prose. These are exceptions to all the rules.

These points give as large scope for exceptions in the Hebrew as I claimed from Crosby in the Greek, and show that I was fully justified in applying Crosby’s remarks as a regulation of Eld. Vogel’s assumption.

In addition to this Gesenius makes a statement of great importance in this question. He says, “The predicate of a sentence does not take the article.” Lex., p. 240. This shows further how wide the range of exceptions is, and stamps Eld. V.’s theory as speculative.

In his last he makes another effort, as futile as previous ones, to bolster up his argument. Of Lev. 23, he says, “It comes under the rule of enumeration,” but he gives no authority to explain his rule or justify his assertion. Is not this “a kind of equivalent” to a “re-mention”?

On my showing the fallacy of his quoting texts on “a holy convocation,” to sustain his position he asks, “What possible bearing against the rule could it have?” But he adduced them to sustain the rule; and if their disproof has no bearing against the rule, it is only because as proof they had no bearing in favor of the rule! “That’s all.” But why, then, did he offer them?

Of Ex. 20:10, he says, it “is not indefinite;” which is true, but it has not the article. But further, he says, it is definite by construction; and refers to three sections of Green’s grammar, quoting neither. This will be instructive to his readers, not one-hundredth of whom ever saw Green’s grammar, and if they had it, could not possibly determine to what statement of the three sections he refers; for there are many statements in those sections which do not apply to it. The section first cited, 246, 3, says that nouns may be definite without the article by construction, but it gives no explanation applicable to this text. The last cited, 2257, says, “The preposition (named) to, belonging to, with or without a preceding relative pronoun, may be substituted for the construct relation in its possessive sense.” If to this he refers, it will apply to Exodus 16:23, as fully as to chapter 20:10. The true reason why it is definite is that it comes under the law of predicates, and so does Exodus 16:23, which therefore does not require the article. Eld. V. says he uses his argument on the Hebrew for those who know that his remarks are just. If there is any one who knows that, I would be glad to be introduced to him.

Now a few words in regard to this controversy over the Hebrew, which I only regret on account of its having introduced into our discussion some expressions not easily appreciated by the mass of our readers. Eld. Vogel unqualifiedly denied that such exceptions existed as I claimed on the Greek; and every one can see that the very life of his argument depended on his assertion in this respect being true. But I have shown that exceptions do exist in the Hebrew to the full extent of my claim on the Greek. It is certainly true that Eld. Vogle knew that these exceptions existed, or he did not. If he did not, it is evidence that his knowledge of Hebrew is too superficial to entitle his criticisms and opinions to confidence. But if he did know of their existence, why did he so positively declare that they did not exist? As I did not see his heart, I will not offer any solution of this mystery, but shall charitably hope that his comment on 2 Pet. 3:16, which he applied to me, may not be found to apply to himself at last.

I shall now proceed in my affirmative; havingp. 23 passed through the Gospels, I quote from the book of Acts, the inspired Church History of this dispensation.

Acts 13:14, 27, 42, 44: “But when they [Paul and Barnabas] departed from Perga, they came to Antioch in Pisidia, and went into the synagogue on the Sabbath day, and sat down.” “For they that dwell at Jerusalem, and their rulers, because they knew him not, nor yet the voices of the prophets, which are read every Sabbath day, they have fulfilled them in condemning him.” “And when the Jews were gone out of the synagogue, the Gentiles besought that these words might be preached to them the next Sabbath.” “And the next Sabbath day came almost the whole city together to hear the word of God.”

Inspiration here sets down what took place on certain Sabbath days. These occurrences were nearly fifteen years after the crucifixion, and this was penned still later; and (as circumstances show, and it cannot be denied) as that was the seventh day, these texts prove that the seventh day was called the Sabbath day, at that time, by the apostles, by the Gentiles, and by the evangelist. And again, as they said the prophets were “read in the synagogue every Sabbath day;” and the seventh day was, and the first day was not, the day in which the prophets were read in the synagogue, it is proved positively that the seventh day then was, and the first day was not, Sabbath day. Behold the harmony of the Old and New Testaments! The O. T. says the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord—his holy day. The N. T. recognizes both titles, the Sabbath and the Lord’s day, and points unmistakably and only to the seventh day. The prophet predicts that the Gentiles shall be called, and they shall take hold of the Sabbath. And the N. T. says at one time they gladly received the word, and requested that it might be preached to them the next Sabbath. While the prophets looked forward into this dispensation and speak of the Sabbath to be kept, not a word in either Testament—in all “the Scriptures”—recognizes any day of the week as a Sabbath but the seventh; and both Testaments do recognize that day as the Sabbath in the plainest terms.

Eld. V. said that Isaiah prophesied that a day called Sabbath would be kept in this dispensation; but as “every Sabbath” in the language of the N. Testament includes every seventh day, and excludes the first day, it follows that that prophecy is fulfilled in the seventh day, or it has failed—for it is not fulfilled in the first day, as that is never called the Sabbath day.

Acts 15:21: “For Moses of old time hath in every city them that preach him, being read in the synagogues every Sabbath day.”

This is most important testimony. (1) As the preceding, it proves that “every Sabbath” includes only the seventh day. (2) It was the words of the apostle James; they were inspired of God. (3) It was spoken full twenty years after the resurrection of Christ, when that new “day called Sabbath” should have been taking that title by some inspired authority, if such a thing was known to the servants of God. (4) It was spoken in full council of “the apostles and elders,” and his words are virtually the words of the whole council. The bearing of such facts as these is not to be mistaken.

Acts 16:13: “And on the Sabbath day we went out of the city by a river side, where prayer was wont to be made; and we sat down and spoke unto the women which resorted thither.”

This took place in Philippi in Macedonia; and so it appears that the Sabbath was kept outside of Judea and its synagogues. And inspiration continues to give it that honored title.

“Acts 17:1, 2: “Now when they had passed through Amphipolis and Apollonia, they came to Thessalonica, where was a synagogue of the Jews. And Paul, as his manner was, went in unto them, and three Sabbath days reasoned with them out of the Scriptures.”

These were the identical “Scriptures” wherein they learned what day was the Sabbath and the Lord’s day.

Acts 18:4: “And he reasoned in the synagogue every Sabbath, and persuaded the Jews and the Greeks.”

This was at Corinth, nearly twenty-five years after the resurrection of the Lord. And still, by the authority of the Holy Spirit, the honored title of the Sabbath was given to the seventh day. In the absence of all proof that any body knew that the first day of the week was the Sabbath or the Lord’s day, and in the absence of any explanation to the effect that the Sabbath was either changed or abolished, the unbiased reader must conclude that inspiration recognized and sanctioned the rest-day of the Lord—the Sabbath day—as an institution perpetuated under the gospel.

A new and unknown institution cannot take the name of the known institution without full explanations being given. This is a truth which admits of no exceptions. It must be admitted as a rule; to violate it is to practice deception. Were a man to give important testimony concerning what transpired in the city of New York, it being also well known that he was well acquainted with that city, no query could arise as to its locality, that city being so well known. But should it afterward be found that a place was, or was to be, laid out in the copper regions of Northern Michigan, to which it was designed to give the name of New York City, and that the man in his testimony referred to that new and unknown city, giving it the title of a city well known to everybody, without any explanation, all would pronounce him guilty of gross deception. And so of Rev. 1:10. He who says that John meant another day than that which was well known as the Lord’s day, is bound to give certain proof that that other day was, AT THAT TIME, well known by that title, or he makes the apostle guilty of just such deception as I have supposed. All to whom John wrote knew that the Lord had, in the most terribly majestic manner, and by many plain statements, reserved the seventh day to himself as his holy day; his rest day from the work of creation; upon which he had placed the divine benediction, and sanctified it as a day for sacred use. Wherever “the Scriptures” had extended their influence, the seventh day was known to be the Lord’s day. And that title cannot be transferred to another by inferences and suppositions. We may allow people to parley over inferences where there is no direct testimony, and even then it is unprofitable. But where there is direct testimony, inferences can have no governing influence.

III. The law of which the Sabbath commandment was a part, was not abolished, but is now binding. The Scriptures show that two different laws, or systems of law, were given to the Jews. One, a law of moral precepts, which pointed out sin; the other, a remedy for sin. Not an original necessity, as I have before shown, but growing out of the necessities of man as a transgressor. Neither of these laws was original to Israel. “The fall” involved all mankind, and the promise of “the seed to bruise the serpent’s head” was given, not to a nation, but to the race. Sacrifices were before Moses or Abraham. If others did not have the same knowledge of God that Abraham had, it was not for want of opportunity, but (as Paul says) because “they did not like to retain God in their knowledge.” Noah was righteous, but the world was filled with violence and wickedness. Lot was righteous, but the men of Sodom were sinners. Abraham was chosen, because he was faithful, to fulfill in him the promises which God had made to the race; and when the fear of God had almost departed from the earth, and men had lost sight of their responsibilities, as Pharaoh, who asked, “Who is the Lord that I should obey him?” God separated the descendants of Abraham, and revived amongst them the knowledge of his law, the light of which had almost ceased to shine on mankind. And God’s long-suffering as well as his justice will be appreciated when it is borne in mind that he gave as a reason for putting off the fulfillment of a promise to Abraham’s descendants, that “the iniquity of the Amorites is not yet full.” Gen. 15:16. God will not infringe on perfect justice to fulfill any of his gracious purposes. Rom. 3:23–26.

Had the world at large maintained respect for God and his authority, Abraham need not have been separated from his kindred. And had not all the nations “changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshiped and served the creature more than the Creator,” there would have been no occasion for God to renew the knowledge of his law. But, under the circumstances, there was need of that awful manifestation of divine power and glory, to impress deeply on their hearts that which mankind had shown themselves so prone to neglect and forget.

The question of law is one of fundamentals; it embraces within itself all other questions. Without law there can be no government. Both duty and pardon recognize the existence of law; but duty is before pardon, as obedience is better than sacrifice; and prayer is abomination if made in disrespect of the law (Prov. 28:9); and to say, Lord, Lord, to the Son of God, will not admit into the kingdom of Heaven, without doing the will of his Father.

The difference between these two laws is not only evident from their natures, but is recognized in the Scriptures. Thus the Lord said to Moses, “Come up to me into the mount, and be there; and I will give thee tables of stone, and a law, and commandments, which I have written.” Ex. 24:12. By comparing the Scriptures, we learn that this law comprised the ten commandments—neither more nor less—which God had spoken with his own voice. It was distinguished from all others by being spoken by the voice of God and written by himself; and separated by being put into the ark, over which atonement for sin was made; and it was also distinguished by express recognition. Said the Lord by Jeremiah 6:19, 20: “Behold I will bring evil upon this people, even the fruit of their thoughts, because they have not hearkened unto my words, nor to my law, but rejected it. To what purpose cometh there to me incense from Sheba, and the sweet cane from a far country? Your burnt offerings are not acceptable, nor your sacrifices sweet unto me.” Thus they could offer their offerings and sacrifices and not keep the law, showing that they were not parts of the same law.

And again, chap. 7:22, 23: “For I spake not unto your fathers, nor commanded them in the day that I brought them out of the land of Egypt, concerning burnt offerings nor sacrifices. But this thing commanded I them, saying, Obey my voice.” When they heard his voice he spake his law, the ten commandments. Deut. 4:12, 13. Thus plainly does the Lord separate his law from all secondary matters.

ELD. VOGEL’S SECOND NEGATIVE.

I did not accuse Bro. Waggoner of wresting the Scriptures; I simply stated the fact that they could be wrested, with the inference that one of us does this, and left it entirely with the reader to decide who that one is. Nor would I be understood that the wresting is intentional. I am conscious of the strictest integrity, and cheerfully accord the same to Eld. W. On no other ground could I call him brother.

I have no wish to dictate a course for my brother, nor have I made an attempt to do so; I have only insisted on the observance of universally recognized rules of honorable discussion, which he has violated, and assures us that he will continue to do so. The reader will not be at a loss to know what this means. It shows that Eld. W. is not satisfied with the work he has done. Men usually let well enough alone. We must, however, not be too hard on him. For while I could afford to lose both of the former propositions without injury to my cause, he cannot; it makes the Sabbath of Jewish origin, and consequently it passed away with that dispensation. It is this that hurts.

Nor need he say, “The past scenes of conflict bring sad memories to me;” on the contrary, they are pleasing memories, as the confidence and satisfaction with which I repeatedly appeal to my work just as it is, fully attests.

A large share of my brother’s last article is taken up in Hebrew criticisms on a former proposition, which are incorrect in almost every essential feature. My first impulse was to notice them in detail; in fact, I wrote a reply to every item, but have concluded not to trouble the reader with them for reasons which will presently appear.

I wish to say kindly what I am about to say, but, nevertheless, as clearly as truth and justice demand. My firm conviction is that Eld. W. is incapable of making a safe criticism based on the original. Take, for example, the following: With Green’s Hebrew Grammar before him, and open at section 226 3, he pronounces Sabbath in Ex. 16:23, definite by construction! Now this is one of the simplest rules in Hebrew, and yet he blunders in applying it. It is a useless task to follow such a critic, and I have concluded not to do it. I do not ask those readers who have been accustomed to Bro. W.’s criticisms to take my word for what I say respecting his criticisms; let them consult an Hebrew scholar about his statement with reference to Ex. 16:23, and satisfy themselves.

There is, however, one statement which I must briefly notice because it has apparent weight, and where better scholars than he have blundered. I refer to the following quotation from Gesenius: “The predicate of a sentence does not take the article.” The old grammarians and lexicographers, both Hebrew and Greek, have generally laid down this rule, but facts are against them. Winer proves the rule to be false by a long array of examples and then adds: “Hence it follows that the oft-repeated rule, ‘the subject of a proposition may be known by its having the article,’ is incorrect.”—Gram. p. 115 (seventh edition, improved).

Let us now turn to Bro. Waggoner’s direct argument. I begin where I left off in my first negative. He lays his work out in three divisions, the first of which is to show,

1. “That the Lord claims a day in this dispensation, as he did in past ages.”

That the Lord claims a day, I cheerfully grant; and that Rev. 1:10 proves it is beyond doubt. So far we are agreed. We differ only as to what day is meant by “Lord’s day” in Rev. 1:10. When I take the affirmative of the next proposition, I pledge myself to show that this is said of the first day of the week. The mere fact that the Sabbath was called the Sabbath of the Lord (not the Lord’s day, however), and that Rev. 1:10 speaks of the Lord’s day, does not identify them as the same. Under the former dispensation, the Father was meant by the term Lord; under this dispensation, the term refers exclusively to Christ (1 Cor. 8:6). (1) I deny that Jesus was even called the Lord of the Sabbath, and call for the proof. (2) If the proof could even be furnished, and it were found that he was called the Lord of the Sabbath under the old dispensation, it would still remain to be proved that he is the Lord of it in the new.

2. “The Sabbath,” says Eld. W., “is recognized and familiarly spoken of in the New Testament without such explanations as would be necessary to guard against misapprehension if it were abolished.” Or, as he hereafter puts it, “The inspired writers of the gospel and the book of Acts speak familiarly of the Sabbath as of a known and observed institution, without any of these explanations which would be necessary to guard against misapprehension if it were abolished.”

That non-Christianized Jews observed it, we both agree to. That Judaized Christians also observed it is a matter of course. But that Christians intelligently observed it as obligatory in the new dispensation, remains to be proved. The mere fact that Christians for a long time observed the day proves nothing; for,

(1) They also observed the annual sabbaths. Are they therefore binding?

(2) They observed circumcision. Is it binding?

(3) They offered animal sacrifices. Are we to offer them?

To all these things my brother says, No. Yet, if the mere observance of the Sabbath proves its present obligation, then are these also obligatory, for they were observed. See my first article on “approved precedent.”

Will my brother say that these things were types and so met their fulfillment in Christianity? The same is true of the weekly Sabbaths. Read Col. 2:16, 17, and my comments thereon in argument 5, under the second proposition. Is this observing the Sabbath “without any of these explanations necessary to guard against misapprehension?”

Let us look at the matter from another standpoint. My brother quotes in full all the passages of the four gospels which speak of the crucifixion, the keeping of the Sabbath then, and of the resumption of work on the first day of the week, and then adds: “If Sabbath obligation had ceased, it will ever remain a marvel that this text [Luke 23:54; 24:1] is so particular to notice obedience to it, and so silent in regard to its cessation.” But he claims that ceremonial observances were abolished at this time. Will it “ever remain a marvel” that there is nothing said about the disciples’ ceasing in its very midst the observance of the feast of unleavened bread which they were then keeping? And why should all the disciples gather “according to the commandment” on the day of Pentecost, fifty days after the crucifixion, to observe that feast? Is not this also a “marvel”?

The fact is that the disciples then knew nothing about the abolition of anything by the crucifixion, so they acted accordingly; and the writers of the gospels and Acts, as faithful historians, recorded events as they transpired. If they chose to withhold comments furnished by the light given on and after Pentecost, it was their privilege to do so. The bearings of the potential act, the crucifixion, to abolish everything of a positive nature in the preceding dispensation, were not yet made known to the people. To illustrate: A number of men are imprisoned for an indefinite period, and loaded with chains. The governor writes out a pardon, seals it, and gives it to some of the prisoners to be opened and read fifty days afterward to their fellows for the benefit of all. Let the chains represent the Sabbath, and the prison the Jewish feasts and whatever else is of a positive nature in the old law. You see that the instrument which procures the liberation of the prisoners is in existence before it takes effect for fifty days. Would it be sound logic for my brother to argue that the governor’s pardon did not free the prisoners from their chains (the Sabbath) simply because they were for fifty days after it was written ignorant of its nature and still bore their chains? Yet this is the way he reasons about the women’s keeping the Sabbath “according to the commandment,” i. e., as it prescribes.

Or, suppose that the prisoners so misinterpreted the governor’s pardon as to still cling to both their chains, or at least to the chains, for many years after, would this prove that there is no pardon in the governor’s writing? This, precisely, is my brother’s argument from Acts!

Suppose, again, that some of the prisoners interpreted the pardon aright, but found that some of the rest not only misinterpreted it, but had actually so fallen in love with the chains that they did not desire to be released, while still others believed the pardon to be entirely spurious and would look upon such as should throw off their chains as rebels against the government. Would it not be well for those who would undertake to reason with them, in order to avoid arousing excessive prejudice and to find readier access to them, to wear their chains for the sake of gaining such? This is what Paul and others actually did; and so he explains: “Unto the Jews I became as a Jew, that I might gain the Jews; to them that are under the law, as under the law, that I might gain them that are under the law” (1 Cor. 9:20). And so, precisely, James reasoned with reference to similar matters, not only for the sake of unconverted Jews, but also for the sake of such converted ones as did not fully understand the nature of Christianity. Hence he said to Paul when the latter came to Jerusalem, “Thou seest, brother, how many thousands of the Jews there are which believe; and they are all zealous of the law; and they are informed of thee, that thou teachest all the Jews which are among the Gentiles to forsake Moses, saying that they ought not to circumcise their children, neither to walk after the customs. What is it therefore? the multitude must needs come together, for they will hear that thou art come. Do therefore this that we say to thee.” And then follow the directions and Paul’s compliance with them. See Acts 21:20–26.

It is a fallacy to reason from the fact that “all” (the “many thousands” who believed kept this or that belonging to the law, and because Paul, James and other enlightened teachers conformed to their prejudices, feeding them with milk until they could endure strong meat, that therefore these are binding upon us. It requires as express legislation to carry a positive institution from one dispensation to another as it did to establish it at first. But there is no legislation with reference to the Sabbath, and this ends the matter.

Paul had also another reason for preaching on the Sabbath; he could then get an audience of such as he could not reach on other days. It was the day when the Jews, to whom he wished to preach, were assembled; and when they were in the habit of giving opportunity to read and explain the Scriptures (Luke 15:16, 17). To this also Acts 15:21 refers—“Moses of old time,” i. e., since many generations, Moses “hath in every city them that preach him, being read in the synagogues every Sabbath.” Nor is it at all strange that pious Gentiles should not only build them synagogues, as the centurion mentioned in Luke 7:2–5, but also habitually meet and worship with them, though there was no law requiring either. And the very expression, “Paul as his manner was, went in unto them, and three Sabbath days reasoned with them out of the Scriptures,” is proof that the writer of Acts knew the Sabbath not to be binding; for were it binding, it would be a matter of course that Paul would preach on that day, but since it is not binding it was necessary to tell that such was Paul’s manner, else we should not have known it.

The explanation that the Sabbath, circumcision, and indeed all such “customs,” were no longer binding, was long withheld, because the people could not bear it. This may seem strange to some, but such is nevertheless the fact. On the same principle, God did not insist on monogamy for thousands of years, though such was his design from the very first; and for a similar reason also he suffered divorce on slight pretexts for many ages. Matt. 19:8. Even Peter, an inspired apostle, after preaching eight or ten years, had to be convinced by miracle that the Gentiles are also to be partakers of gospel blessings. And this is especially strange, since his commission read, “Go ye into all the world and preach the gospel to every creature” (Mark 16:15). Besides, he had, in his very first sermon, preached salvation for “all” (Acts 2:39), without understanding for ten years what that meant which the Spirit caused him then to say. In many things, for a long time, even the apostles saw “through a glass darkly.” Gradually, but yet as fast as they could bear it, light came. And so the Saviour had ordained: “First the blade, then the ear, after that the full corn in the ear.”

I do not claim that the first day of the week was ever called “Sabbath” by inspiration, except in prophecy. Hence the first day ought not to be called Sabbath now save in poetry and figurative language. By what right the first day was called Sabbath in prophecy, I must reserve for my next proposition, where it properly belongs. But to find a fulfillment of Isa. 56:6, in as yet unconverted Gentiles coming on the Sabbath to hear Paul preach is so strangely wild that it is difficult to believe that a man ever wrote it sober earnest. I fear my brother was nodding just then.

Isaiah 56:6, and all similar prophecies, no more predict the continuance of the Jewish Sabbath than the 7th verse—“their burnt-offerings and their sacrifices shall be accepted upon mine altar”—gives to us animal sacrifices and a literal altar, or than Isa. 66:23 insists upon the continuance of Jewish “new moons.” Such literalism would construe Zech. 14:20 into a present duty to literally write “Holiness unto the Lord” upon “the bells of the horses” rather than to insist upon righteous dealing!

3. Eld. W.’s third division is not yet sufficiently developed to need a reply. While awaiting the result, I will begin a negative argument.

1. The law is abolished; and since the Sabbath was a part of the law, it went with it, no matter when it was given.

The expression, “the law,” when referring to old dispensation, and not qualified to the contrary, either expressly, or by obvious implication, always refers to the entire body of the law as a whole, or to single commandments as parts of the whole. In other words, there is no such scriptural distinction as “the moral law” and “the ceremonial law.” Under the Jewish dispensation, the moral, the ceremonial, and the judicial, were part and parcel of one law. It was in the days of the Schoolmen, when men, preparatory to entering the ministry, spent sixteen years in hairsplitting, and called it “theology,” that the three-law distinction arose. But “what God hath joined together, let not man put asunder.” What in one sentence is called “the law of Moses” (Luke 3:22) is in another called “the law of the Lord” (verse 24); and what in one passage is called simply “the law” is in another called “the law of Moses;” compare Luke 16:16, “The law and the prophets were until John,” with Luke 24:44, “All things must be fulfilled which are written in the law of Moses and in the prophets, and in the Psalms.” Both of these passages refer to the whole of the Old Testament, with this difference in details, that what is divided in the second into “prophets and Psalms” is embraced in “prophets” in the first, since the Psalms are largely prophecy. I know of no instance where the ten commandments alone are called “the law,” simply.

1. When I say that the law is abolished, I have reference only to so much of the law as was positive; and this includes the Sabbath, which I have shown to be positive. Moral relations cannot be, and were not, abolished. This was foretold by Hag. 2:6, as quoted by Paul in Hebrews 12:27. “Yet once more I shake not the earth only, but also heaven.” This implies a former “shaking,” which took place at the giving of the law to the Jews; see Hag. 2:5; Heb. 12:15, 26. And the second shaking was to take place when Christ should come for the first time, or while the second temple was still standing (Hag. 2:7; Heb. 12:28). As to the things shaken or removed, Paul’s comment is, “And this expression, yet once more [&c.], signifieth the removing of those things that may be shaken [marg.], as of things that are made [and the Sabbath was “made,” Mark 2:27], that those things which cannot be shaken [namely, things not “made,” i. e., moral principles] may remain.” Heb. 12:27.

3. “Wherefore then serveth the law? It was added because of transgressions, till the seed [Christ] should come.” Gal. 3:19. But Christ has come; therefore the law has served out its time and is discharged.

3. “The law was [not is] our schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith. But after that faith is come, we are no longer under the schoolmaster.” Gal. 3:24, 25.