BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
(Concluded.)
In Jer. 31:31, 32 the Lord announced his intention to make a new covenant with the house of Israel. Here are his words:—
“Behold, the days come, saith the Lord, that I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and with the house of Judah; not according to the covenant that I made with their fathers, in the day that I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt; which my covenant they brake, although I was an husband unto them, saith the Lord.”
The reader will note the circumstance that the Lord charges Israel with having broken the Sinaitic covenant. To break a covenant means to violate its terms. But if the Israelites violated the terms of the first covenant, they either did something which that covenant forbade, or else they had failed to do something, which by its terms they had agreed to do. In either case, it follows that the covenant in question was one which contained conditions. The same principle holds true in reference to many other expressions in the Scriptures relating to that covenant. Here are several of them: “Because they continued not in my covenant.” Heb. 8:9. They will “provoke me, and break my covenant.” Deut. 31:20. “Transgressed my covenant.” Josh. 7:11.
The expressions, “To continue in a covenant,” “to break a covenant,” and “to transgress a covenant,” predicated as they were of the Hebrew people, all imply that the covenant in question was conditioned upon the faithful performance on the part of said people of certain specifications to which they had agreed. In short, they prove that the first covenant, as heretofore argued, was a covenant to which certain conditions were attached. The way is now open to test the question whether the ten commandments really constituted the first, or Sinaitic, covenant in the primary sense of that word.
The writer submits that they could not have done so from the obvious consideration that a covenant in the primary sense of that term, as already shown, is an agreement between certain parties, either to do, or not to do, certain things; whereas the ten commandments contain no such agreement. Standing alone, they simply require the worship of Jehovah, and forbid idolatry, blasphemy, Sabbath-breaking, the dishonoring of parents, murder, adultery, theft, false witness, and coveting. Let the reader examine them critically, and see if such is not the case. It is frankly conceded that they are several times styled a “covenant;” but it is emphatically denied that they are ever called “the first covenant.” There is a wide difference between the two appellations. There are very many things which might be called “a covenant,” but there is but one thing which could be denominated “the first covenant.” As already argued, the ten commandments could not have constituted the first covenant, strictly speaking, since that covenant was an agreement between God and the people; whereas the ten commandments are not of that nature, but simply prohibit the people from doing, or command them to do, certain things.
Do you ask, then, why they were ever styled “the covenant?” The reply is, that even though a satisfactory answer could not be given to that question, it would still be true that they are not the “first covenant” in the primary sense of the term, because their very nature forbids such a conclusion. Rejecting, therefore, an explanation which involves an absurdity, let us see if there is not a direct and satisfactory way out of the dilemma. Already it has been assumed that ordinarily a covenant contains both promises and conditions, and that the latter are often spoken of as “a covenant,” or as “the covenant;” that is, they being a part of the covenant, are put in the place of the whole covenant for the sake of convenience. Looking upon the subject in the light of this fact, the task becomes an easy one.
The people in entering upon the covenant had agreed to obey the voice of God. The ten commandments were uttered by that voice, and cover all moral obligation. Those commandments, therefore, furnish the conditions upon which the first covenant was based. To keep the commandments would be to keep that covenant. To break them would be to break that covenant. They might, therefore, with the most perfect propriety be styled, as they are in the texts cited by the objector, “the covenant,” “God’s covenant,” etc.* The writer, to prove that in adopting this construction, he is not resorting to a new and novel view for the sake of bolstering up his peculiar Sabbath opinions, appends the following quotation from an authority who supports first-day observance, and stands very high in the scholastic world:—
“Generally, however, the form of a covenant is maintained by the benefits which God engages to bestow being made by him dependent upon the fulfillment of certain conditions which he imposes upon man. Thus the covenant of Sinai was conditioned by the observance of the ten commandments (Ex. 34:27, 28; Lev. 26:15), which are therefore called Jehovah’s covenant (Deut. 4:13); a name which was extended to all the books of Moses, if not to the whole body of Jewish canonical Scriptures.”—Comp. Dic. of the Bible, art. Covenant.
The reader will take notice that the preceding quotation sustains fully all that the writer has said to the effect that the first covenant was a covenant with conditions, and that the ten commandments are in the Scriptures styled “the covenant,” because they were the conditions of the first covenant, and not because they were the covenant as a whole.
The position of the Antinomian in this controversy is expressed in the following syllogism:—
“The ten commandments are in certain scriptures styled the covenant, God’s covenant, etc. They are so styled because they constituted the first covenant. The first covenant was abolished. Therefore as the ten commandments were identical with that covenant, they are no longer binding upon any one.”
The fundamental fallacy of this syllogism lies in the assumption that the ten commandments constituted the whole of the first covenant proper. Having shown as we have, that the ten commandments could not in the very nature of the things be a covenant at all in the primary sensep. 84 of that term, and as a consequence, that they could not have been the first covenant, the premises of our friends have been demonstrated to be erroneous, and the conclusions drawn from them false.
It now becomes incumbent upon the writer, while admitting that the first covenant is abolished, to make it clear that the decalogue was not necessarily abolished along with it. This he will do in the following manner: (1.) The keeping of the ten commandments furnishes to the people the conditions of the first covenant; (2.) those commandments enforce great moral principles that existed before that covenant was made, and must continue to exist for all time; (3.) those great moral principles having been codified in the decalogue and made the conditions of the first covenant, would exist by virtue of their own intrinsic morality even after the first covenant was abolished; (4.) therefore when the new covenant was formed, they were still in being, and from the very necessity of the case found a place in that covenant, since it is incredible that the second, or new, covenant, could have ignored great moral principles, the existence and obligation of which were essential to the well-being of society.
As an illustration will sometimes make a point more easy of apprehension than it is possible for a naked argument to do, the writer will have recourse once more to the covenant or agreement referred to above regarding the construction of a dwelling-house. Let it be premised that in the case cited, the contractor had engaged to build the house within a limited time, he to do all the work himself, and to do it according to the plan and specifications agreed upon. Let it be premised also that in process of time he found himself incapable from lack of skill, of completing the house in the style prescribed in the specifications, and as a consequence was compelled to forfeit his contract. Having done so, the other contracting party comes to him, and with unexampled liberality addresses him as follows: Neighbor B, you have failed to carry out your contract. I knew that such would be the case, but I thought that such a failure would prove a valuable lesson to you, and so I permitted it to take place. I am ready now to make another contract with you, based upon better promises. Heb. 8:6. You build the house according to the specifications of the contract which you forfeited, and I will give you the same amount of money that I engaged to give you originally, and in addition I will furnish to you free of charge a master-builder who is perfectly competent to do all of the work which you prove to be incapable of doing.
Do you not perceive, reader, that the foregoing illustration represents substantially the condition of things under the first and second covenants respectively? Under the first covenant, the people undertook to win eternal life by keeping the law of God perfectly in their own strength, without intelligently availing themselves of the help which heaven proffered.† A disastrous failure was the result. Jehovah knew beforehand what the come-out would be, but it was necessary in order to prepare the people to receive the promised Christ to destroy their overweening self-confidence. In due time, the second, or new, covenant was instituted, and took the place of the old one. The conditions of the new covenant were the same as those of the old one; i. e., the fulfilling of the righteousness of the moral law, or the ten commandments. The advantages which accrue to the believer through the better promises of the new covenant do not come through a license to sin (1 John 2:1); but instead, through the reception of more grace to enable him to keep the law, and through the infinite advantage which he receives from having the righteousness of Christ imputed to him, as fully as though it were his own.‡
THE DIRECT TESTIMONY OF THE SCRIPTURES ON THE COVENANTS.
Theories may sometimes prove to be faulty when standing alone, but when confirmed by the direct testimony of the Scriptures, they must be sound. It is proper, consequently, to make search at this point, for positive declarations of the word of God on the subject under debate. Jer. 31:31–33: “Behold, the days come, saith the Lord, that I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel, and with the house of Judah: not according to the covenant that I made with their fathers, in the day that I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt; which my covenant they brake, although I was an husband unto them, saith the Lord: but this shall be the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel; after those days, saith the Lord, I will put my law in their inward parts, and write it in their hearts; and will be their God, and they shall be my people.”
The scripture given above is a prophecy of the new covenant. It was written 606 years before the latter was made. What testimony does it bear upon this question? Does it, or does it not confirm the view that the law of God has no place in the Christian dispensation? What is the import of the words, “I will put my law in their inward parts, and will write it in their hearts; and will be their God, and they shall be my people”? To put the law in the hearts of the people is tantamount to giving it a place in their affections. The law spoken of is the law of God. When Jeremiah wrote, the decalogue, or ten commandments, was such in the highest sense of that term; but if the decalogue was to be enshrined in the affections of believers in the gospel age, then it exists at this time, and is binding upon all.
Reader, whose teachings will you follow, those of the inspired Jeremiah, or those of the uninspired Antinomian of our day?