JUDGE NOT

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 7, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 6.

Read the full edition

“JUDGE NOT.”

“Judge not, that ye be not judged.” These are familiar words to all Christian people; their import and authorship are undeniable; yet probably none of the words of Christ are more often or more generally disregarded by Christian people.
To judge a person is to pass judgment upon him, upon his actions or character. This is usually done by some statement uttered upon the spur of the moment, but it may be done by either words or acts. It involves the motives of the one who performed the action and the circumstances under which it was done.
It ought to be evident to any intelligent person upon a moment’s thought, that there are good reasons for this Scriptural injunction. One reason is that no individual is qualified to pass judgment in the way that it is usually done. In a court of law, judgment has to be passed upon a person for having committed a crime, and sentence pronounced and executed, in order that peace and good government may be preserved; but in such cases no person is condemned without a careful examination of all the evidence that can be produced both against him and in his favor, nor is “hearsay” evidence allowed any bearing in determining the verdict. The accused has always the right to be brought face to face with his accusers, and be given a chance to make a good defense. But how is it at the bar of public opinion? At that bar men are tried and condemned, even by their brethren in the church, by a process that would not be tolerated for an instant in any proceeding at law, where minds are governed by only worldly motives. Without jury, without judge, without advocates to present his cause or witnesses to speak in his defense, and with often no evidence that would be allowed in court, the victim is condemned and treated as if his guilt were an established fact, and when no good whatever is to be gained by his condemnation. Manifestly, such things ought not so to be.
But, says one, of course it is not right to circulate reports about our neighbors, and judge them by things that we hear, but I only tell what I positively know to be true. Is that so? Well then, you have no right, as a Christian, to do even that. Truth is not a defense to evil-speaking. “Speak evil of no man.” Such were the words of St. Paul to Titus, written for the instruction of the church; and he did not add, “unless you know it to be true,” but left the words to apply to all men, the guilty and innocent alike. The question is not, Is the person innocent or guilty? but, Is it right to indulge in evil-speaking? and the apostle has answered the question in the negative.
But very often we cannot help knowing a person to be guilty, and to have acted from bad motives. Must we not then judge that person, whether we would desire to do so or not?—No; it is not, even then, right or necessary to judge. We may know the person to have done wrong, simply because we cannot help knowing it; but that which forces itself upon our knowledge, without any effort on our part, does not involve an act of judgment. The judging in such a case consists in taking it upon ourselves to say how guilty the person is, and what he deserves to have. And we hardly ever give expression to our opinions in such a case without putting them in this very form. It is as natural almost as it is to breathe. Evil-speaking is wrong, whether the thing spoken is true, or not; and judging is doubly wrong, because it is not only evil-speaking, but an assumption of power and authority which belong to God. We cannot with our finite minds measure the guilt of a wrong-doer, though perhaps we cannot help knowing that he is guilty. In the first place, we do not know all the circumstances of the case, and so would be obliged to judge the whole case from only a partial view of it; and secondly, even if we knew all the circumstances having any bearing upon it, we are not able to measure the force which they exert upon the mind or nature of the one who transgressed; for we have no unvarying standard of human nature, but scarcely any two individuals in the world are constituted alike. We can in many instances, by carefully proceeding according to all the known rules of justice, measure the transgressions of an individual with respect to human laws, which concern only the outward acts, and where the standard of right is only such as man has erected; but what mortal, or jury of mortals, can measure his guilt with respect to the law of God,—the absolute standard of right—and which takes cognizance of the secret thoughts and intents of the heart?
To refrain from judging is not a matter of mere etiquette, not something to which is attached only the importance of good manners (though were it only so it would be important enough); but it is something which in the sight of God and the angels in heaven is exceedingly improper and displeasing. God’s word contains much more on the subject than the solitary text which introduces this article. The same divine Being who said, “Judge not, that ye be not judged,” said in that same discourse, “Whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment: and whosoever shall say to his brother, Raca [vain fellow], shall be in danger of the council: but whosoever shall say, Thou fool, shall be in danger of hell fire.” Matt. 5:22. Jude tells us that even “Michael the archangel, when contending with the devil he disputed about the body of Moses, durst not bring against him a railing accusation, but said, The Lord rebuke thee.” The apostle Peter mentions a class of whom he says, “Presumptuous are they, self-willed, they are not afraid to speak evil of dignities. Whereas angels, which are greater in power and might, bring not railing accusation against them before the Lord.” 2 Pet. 2:10, 11. And thus the presumptuous (that is, assuming an authority and wisdom which he does not in any degree possess) evil-speaking, judging, person fulfills the oft-heard saying that— “Fools rush in where angels fear to tread.” (See also Rom. 2:1; 14:10, 13; 1 Cor. 4:3, 5; James 4:11, 12.)
And not only is judging a wrong with respect to those who are judged, but its effect is most disastrous upon the spirituality of the judger; for it cuts directly across the commandment to “love one another.” Its effect is to cause coldness and bitterness to exist in the place of unity and love. Christians are to love all men, even their enemies. This leaves no room for judging any. A Christian spirit will cause an individual to esteem others better than himself (Phil. 2:3) and will manifest Christian charity, which “covereth the multitude of [our brother’s] sins.” L. A. S.