THEOLOGICAL CALCULATIONS.
By M. E. K.
The theologian referred to in the Review of Jan. 3, under the head of “Theological Imaginations,” not satisfied with theological imaginations, has gone into theological calculations as well. There is probably no point in theology that has so bothered the theologians for many years, and even for generations, as the fourth commandment. When the early church drifted into the apostasy that resulted in the papacy, and in so doing took unto herself the pagan holiday of Sunday in place of the Sabbath of Jehovah, she made a wide divergence between her practice and the plain precepts of the word of God, which the theologians have worried over since. The Catholic and high church theologians have one way out of the difficulty, the Presbyterians and Methodists another, the Christians, or Disciples, another, and so on ad infinitum. None of these diverse and contradictory theologians will allow that the position of any of their allies is correct, and so one pulling one way, and another hauling another way, the longer time lasts, the greater is the confusion of sentiment upon that commandment, which, divested of all theological blundering, is as clear and as easy to be understood as the other nine commands of the same divine law. The theologians of this time who have placed themselves in defense of the “day of the sun,” are obliged, by the necessities of the present time, to make new discoveries, and go into minute calculations that the theologians of the past did not have to do. In former days, when the Church and the State were united, a point of theology having once been established by the church, whether it was the celebration of the mass, the adoration of a relic, the observance of a day of worship, the baptism of infants, or any other thing evolved from the theological brain, the people had to come to it and receive it. It was not to be supposed that they had any conscience of their own in the matter. The theologians thought themselves capable of exercising the function of conscience for all the people. But a marked change has come over mankind in the matter of conscience, especially among the nations of western Europe and America. The people of these countries are not so willing to allow others to do their thinking and lay down religious duties for them as they were in past ages. The idea of liberty in religious things has become an essential part of modern thought. It is now generally believed that there can be no civil liberty without religious liberty; that religious tyranny will at once pave the way for the overthrow of the civil liberties of the people; and that when a man surrenders his religious rights, he surrenders his all. This being the settled convictions of the larger portion of the American people, any and every attempt to oppose the rights of conscience in this country meets the merited condemnation of liberty-loving people. Therefore, those people, who upon the subject of the day of the week to be observed as the Sabbath are desirous of thinking and deciding, not only for themselves, but for all other people, to the extent of having those who dare to think otherwise arrested and fined, are obliged in some way to make it appear that the enforcement of Sunday-keeping is not an infringement of conscience; that the Sabbath commandment does not relate to our duty to God, but rather to men, and as a duty toward man it may and should be enforced. To compass this end, that new invention, the “civil Sabbath,” also called the “American Sabbath,” was produced and exhibited to the public. The gilding of civility that was put upon it by the theologians was so exceedingly thin that the religious nature of the thing could be distinctly seen by any close observer, and so the religious Sabbath, with its light veneering of civility, has not yet attained the success that the theologians who formed it had confidently hoped it would. But the theologians are not discouraged! Why should they be? The theologians of the past have succeeded in avoiding the plain text of the fourth commandment, and shall the theologians of this day acknowledge the superiority of men of former days to “darken counsel by words without knowledge?”—No, indeed! They will prove themselves equal to the occasion. This is especially true of the theologian of the Allegheny Seminary. He has made an original theological survey of the ten commandments, and has been able to run a boundary line in a place where no surveyor ever went before, and to make a calculation that no other person ever had the sagacity(?) to make. It is allowed by all Biblical students as far as we know, that the decalogue contains an epitome of our duty to God and to our fellow-men. It has also generally been held that the first four commandments contain our duty to God, and the last six the duties we owe to mankind. Upon this ground Roger Williams took the position that the civil government had no right to define and punish Sabbath breaking, since the keeping of the Sabbath is a duty we owe to God alone. The theologian above referred to does not take kindly to this position, that the civil law ought not to enforce the fourth commandment, and therefore he proposes to divide the law of God in a new place, to obviate this difficulty. Thus, he says, upon the question as to where the line is that separates the duties we owe to God, from those we owe to mankind, “there is nothing revealed.” He has therefore taken the liberty to reveal it himself, and to draw the line through the fourth commandment, instead of at the end of it! He has found “by a count of the lines,” the exact center of the law,—the point where duty to God ends, and that to man begins! It is in the fourth precept, after the word “holy”! Thus he says:— “The first sentence of the fourth commandment, ‘Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy,’ is above the reach of civil law. We could not if we would, compel men to observe the Sabbath religiously, but the remainder of the fourth commandment, which turns at once to a prohibition of vagrancy, ‘Six days shalt thou labor,’ and regulates rest and labor for the whole week, is as suitable for re-enactment in civil law as the fifth, sixth, or seventh commandments.”
Notice the expression. It does not read we would not if we could, but we could not if we would. According to this, all that prevents their compelling men to observe the Sunday religiously, then, is because they cannot do it. If they could make a man go to church, if they could, like King Olaf, say, “Be baptized, or thou shalt die,” most gladly would they do it. But they cannot do it. We are not living in the Dark Ages. The intelligence of the times will not allow even theologians such authority as that, and so they are compelled to take a circuitous route, and by a “count of the lines” and a little nice calculation, to get, almost, if not quite, what they want. The point of this new discovery resulting from this close calculation and count of the lines, is that as the civil law cannot enforce the Sabbath “religiously,” it devolves upon it to enforce it some other way,—irreligiously, we suppose! Indeed, we do not know of anything more irreligious than hypocrisy, or anything that makes hypocrites faster than observing a day as the Sabbath when the observers all the time know it has no Sabbath character. Really, the civil law has no more right to regulate labor and rest than it has to regulate eating and sleeping. “If the Legislature can prescribe the days of rest for them (the people), it would seem that the same power can prescribe hours to work, rest, and eat.”—Decision of Supreme Court of California. God may set apart a day that those who love and serve him may use to his honor and glory; but what good will it do God, or the State, or the individual who does not love and serve him, to spend that day in idleness, which is always more destructive of morality than honest labor? To “remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy” brings a blessing to those who keep it. To keep it only as a day of leisure and idleness, as the majority of people do, is not to keep it at all, and is a positive curse to nine tenths of those who thus keep it. As far as the State is concerned, vagrancy upon one day of the week is just as bad as upon another. The man who gets a good living for himself and family cannot be a vagrant, though he works every day in the week or no day at all. It therefore follows that civil law has no right to “re-enact” the law that says, “Six days shalt thou labor;” and this attempt, by a “count of the lines,” to seek for a pretext to enforce a day of idleness upon the people of this country, is a presumptuous and heaven-daring interference in, and perversion of, the law of God. That theologians will thus dare to inject their own thoughts, conjectures92 and speculations into the only law that God gave to mankind, shows how great is their opinion of self, and how little true respect they have for the law of God. Theologians of past times, and of the present, have heaped every indignity they could think of upon the fourth commandment. They have said that it was a “yoke of bondage;” that it had been abolished; that it had been changed; that it commanded the observance of Sunday; that it commanded the observance of any seventh day, after six days of labor; that it is not obligatory upon Christians; that it may be kept in the spirit and be broken in the letter at the same time! etc., etc. And now we have it divided! A part of it is to be rendered to God and a part to our fellow-men, and all to be done on the first day, while the commandment specifies the seventh! In view of all this, we are constrained to ask, Is there anything that a theologian, so-called, will not attempt to do? M. E. K.