PETITIONERS AND PETITIONS

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 13, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 49.

Read the full edition

PETITIONERS AND PETITIONS.

THE claim was made in Congress by Senator Hawley, and re-affirmed by representatives of the Church party in whose interests he was working, that forty million of the people of the United States were petitioning Congress for Sunday-closing of the World's Fair. Afterward the Christian Statesman quoted and indorsed a statement from Senator Pettigrew that one fourth of all the signatures on the petitions sent in to Congress were from Pennsylvania. This apparent discrepancy the Statesman now undertakes to adjust by saying that “petitions and signatures are not synonymous.” This statement shows just where the fraud in connection with the petitions for Sunday-closing comes in. One signature is alleged to stand for more than one (a great many more, it may be) petitioner. The signature of one minister is counted for those of his entire church. The signature of Cardinal Gibbons attached to his letter favoring religious legislation, a few years since, was in the same way made to represent the whole Catholic membership in the United States. It ought not to be necessary to tell any fair-minded person that such a method of obtaining and counting petitioners is fraudulent in its very essence.
Where did Senator Hawley and the Statesman get their forty million petitioners? By reference to the Statesman of Aug. 6, we discover the process of mathematical conjuring by which they were made to appear and terrify the members of the fifty-second Congress. It is furnished by Mr. Crafts himself, thus,—
“The members of evangelical churches, of which all but two or three small bodies have so protested, number thirteen millions. Add twice as many more for the members of their families, the usual allowance for ‘adherents,’ and we have thirty-nine millions. Nine States out of ten that have voted on this subject by legislature or State commission, have voted against Sunday-opening. Adding those in these States who are not members of evangelical churches, would carry the numbers of those who by their religious and civil representative bodies asked for closing, far above forty millions, without counting those unofficially represented by the three Catholic archbishops who have declared for closing, nor those, not otherwise counted, who are in the constituency of numerous agricultural and industrial organizations that have voted for it.”
No wonder the legislators at Washington were frightened at such a spectral array, and were glad of any way to appease them; but let us also make a calculation. Let us see if the rule is so poor that it will not work both ways.
According to Mr. Crafts's statement, there are thirteen million evangelical church-members in this country. The Catholics, he says, are unofficially represented in the matter, and as Cardinal Gibbons favors Sunday-opening, it may fairly be presumed that the bulk of American Catholics also favor it, he being their leader. But to be as fair as possible, we will leave them out of the matter entirely, not counting them as petitioners on either side. This leaves about forty-five million United States citizens who are not members of any church. Now as these thirteen millions are largely composed of young people, it will certainly be a fair estimate to say that twenty millions of people between the same ages are not church-members. These have not petitioned for Sunday-closing, and may therefore be presumed not to favor it. Now “add twice as many more for the members of their families, the usual allowance for ‘adherents,’ and we have” sixty millions! These are opposed to Sunday-closing, or at least have not signified any desire for it. This, as the reader will see, is a third more than the number who have petitioned for Sunday-closing. What will Congress do in the face of a calculation like this? Will they dare to “insult” these sixty million citizens by refusing to repeal the closing law? We shall see.
This, of course, simply illustrates the absurdity of the Statesman's calculation, and shows the fraudulent nature of the claims with which Mr. Crafts and others frightened the members of Congress last summer. We think it not improbable, however, that nearly, if not quite, sixty millions of our citizens either are opposed to Sunday-closing of the Fair, or do not care whether it is closed or not. As the various State commissioners were not authorized to represent the people of their respective States in the matter of Sunday-closing, we have not deemed that point worthy of notice.
To this add the fact that whenever and wherever the people of the country have spoken upon the subject directly and individually, there has been a very large majority in favor of Sunday-opening, as instanced by the six thousand postal-cards sent out by the World's Fair directors, the replies sent to the New York World and the Chicago Post, etc., and the ghostly nature of Messrs. Hawley and Crafts's forty million petitioners becomes apparent. There were a great many more “petitions” than petitioners.
The Statesman admits that out of 150,000 petitions sent out to church-members, only 10,000 came back to be forwarded to Congress, but in explanation says that many of these 10,000 petitions were adopted by “church congresses of ministers and laymen acting for whole denominations.” The readiness which these self-styled “successors of the prophets” manifest to think and act for other people in matters both spiritual and temporal, is truly remarkable. But the people can dispense with their services in everything pertaining to the World's Fair. They are fully competent to think and act for themselves. L. A. S.