By Rev. Wilhelm Beck.
FROM THE DANISH, BY J. G. MATTHESON.
- (Concluded.)*
It was this evil work, selling indulgences, etc., which principally instigated Luther to make public protest, and to nail his earnest objections against the Romish Church on the church door in Wittenberg, on All-saints' Day. It was against this indulgence work that he, day after day, preached a long series of sermons. And Luther never wanted to hear anything concerning a state between death and the resurrection, in which people could repent, and make further advancement. A man once asked Luther if he could not pray for the salvation of a dear friend who had died. He answered, “If you desire so much to do this, then do it once, and let that be enough.” By this he shows that he considered such work useless. The doctrine of the Lutheran Church knows nothing of such a state, between death and the resurrection. There is not a word said of this in the catechism of Luther.
But rationalism always returns with the old questions and considerations which they want to clear up outside of the Holy Scriptures, about this state of the dead between death and the resurrection. Its most abominable branch we find in Mormonism, which allows living persons to be baptized for the dead, in order that they may be saved in this conscious state between death and the resurrection. And the doctrine of purgatory has returned in our days also in the Lutheran Church, teaching repentance after death, which certainly is nothing but the old doctrine of purgatory, only in a more spiritual way, by offering prayers for the dead; and it has gone very far in this direction.
I have read a book by Maywahlen, translated by Kragballe, which really might be considered a perfect geography of the realm of the dead. We are brought around into so many different countriesp. 644 and divisions in this unknown realm, that a person wonders whence the author has obtained all this wonderful knowledge. But he has obtained it, and seems to be well acquainted with every corner of the unknown land. We might think that he himself had traveled through it. I have long been looking for a map to be published of the realm of the dead; but it has not yet appeared. All this is really nothing but rationalism. The intellect of man has formed ideas without any revelation at all in the word of God. But in the form wherein this rationalism presents itself, it may perhaps be called a rationalism of the feeling; for the real foundation of it is, that some one had a dear friend who died without being converted. The living friend says, “I do not like this, it is contrary to my feelings, that my father or mother or companion or some dear friend should be lost,”—and on account of this feeling, it is necessary that there must be a doctrine of repentance after death.
And yet it must be acknowledged that it is a small question in the household of faith, what relationship a dead person sustained while he was alive. It is a horrible thought that the person is eternally lost, whether he was our relative or not. And if this presses itself on our thoughts and feelings, we must consequently say, “I cannot endure this thought, that a single person should be eternally lost, and for the sake of this feeling, there must be repentance for all men; and so all men must be saved in the state between death and the resurrection.” But this is entirely contrary to the doctrine of the Holy Scriptures and our church.
Here on the earth is the theater of the great drama of salvation. Here Christ died for us, and finished the great work of paying for our sins, and redeeming us from the slavery of Satan, that we might be his property, saved and paid for, with a high price. Here is the baptism of Christ, wherein he renews us, that we may be children of God, whose sins are forgiven, on the condition of our living a holy life. Here is the Lord's Supper, in which he gives meat and drink, that we may live a holy life. Here is the word of Christ, with its calling, awakening, converting, comforting, sanctifying power.*
Here it must be heard. Here conversion must take place. Here the sanctification must be completed “while it is day; before the night cometh, when no man can work.” This gives very great importance to our life in this world, and exhorts us to “redeem the time,” to work out our salvation with fear and trembling, to strive earnestly to enter in through the narrow gate. This certainly presents death as a terror to the many who have died unconverted, and by whose death all hope is cut off. But it also gives the believer full peace in view of death, after which no falling away is possible, according to the word of God. “Be thou faithful unto death, and I will give thee a crown of life.” Rev. 2:10.
Yes, only unto death! After that, no unfaithfulness is possible. And this can only be so understood, when no conversion is possible after death; for it cannot be otherwise than that those who teach the possibility of conversion after death must also acknowledge the possibility of falling away after death. If a bridge has been laid over the great gulf between hell and paradise, so that those from hell can come over to paradise, then it also necessarily follows that those from paradise can come over to hell. It is a horrible thought to the children of God, that, according to this doctrine, believers who have lived together as man and wife in this life, and then were separated by death, would not be sure to find each other again, in the resurrection, among the blessed at the right side of the Lord, because one of them might fall away after death. This is the curse that has come out of this doctrine.
And yet this is not the only curse. I know that there are ministers who have preached the possibility of repentance after death in such a way, and with such earnestness, that their hearers have had no hope left, in their own case, of repenting after death, if they did not repent now, while they had an opportunity to do so. But I also know by experience that repentance after death has been preached in such a scandalous way, that the world has rejoiced and triumphed over those preachers who have pointed out the necessity of repentance in this life. And I also know, from my own experience, that this doctrine has leavened such a multitude of people, that it has become a principal article of faith to them, and has taken away all earnestness from the word of God.
What then can you say of the many Gentiles? Are they eternally lost? What, concerning small and unbaptized children who have died? Are they also lost forever? I answer, I know nothing of this. I do not want to preach anything else than what I can see plainly in the word of God. “The secret things belong unto the Lord our God; but those things which are revealed belong unto us and to our children forever, that we may do all the words of this law.” Deut. 29:29. And God has hidden from us what he will do to them. Unto us he has said, “Preach the gospel to every creature,” and, “Suffer little children to come unto me.” And instead of studying on that which we may never know, we might better, with greater earnestness, obey these instructions of the Lord.
But all those who died in the time of unbelief, when the gospel was not preached,—what becomes of them? Are they also lost forever? Would not that be unjust in the Lord? Let us cease to talk of injustice with the Lord. The Lord certainly does not owe us anything. He will visit the iniquities of the parents on the children to the third and fourth generations (Exodus 25), and it is not becoming to us to object to the word of God. I do not doubt that whole generations in those times of unbelief, will be lost, and thus in such times it will most literally be “a little flock” that will be saved. Do you say, “This is an awful thought,” then I answer, “The destruction of man is always an awful thought, whether it is nearly a whole generation, or some individuals out of a generation, that are lost.” Let us be careful that we do not sin, by preaching something that may be visited on our children in coming generations, because we induce them to delay their repentance until it is too late.
But those who repent on the death-bed? How can they be ripe for the resurrection, if there is no conscious state between death and the resurrection? I answer, “A day is with the Lord as a thousand years.” 2 Pet. 3:8. A plant which takes several years to develop, the Lord can, if it pleases him, develop in one day. This was done in the case of the thief on Calvary, who in one day was made ripe to be with Christ in paradise. And, after all, it is not our work, but the work of the Lord, that we are made ripe for the life of the saved ones.
But the great number of years that intervene between death and the resurrection, in so many cases! Must we really be like one who sleeps, all that time? If you think that this is a horrible thought, you forget that with death, time ceases to us, and eternity commences immediately after death is ended. To one who sleeps deep sleep, all time passes away. It is just like the twinkling of an eye, from the time you fall asleep till you wake again. I once experienced this in a remarkable manner. I had been watching for eight days at the death-bed of a dear brother. On the eighth day, I rode ten miles to attend a missionary meeting. When I sat down in the carriage, I was so weary that I fell asleep before we started. In the same moment (so it seemed to me), we went through a gate-way. I awoke, and thought it was the gate-way of the person's house from which we started, where I seated myself in the carriage. But it was the gate of the friend where we were going. I had ridden ten miles in a deep sleep, and it seemed like a moment to me.
To us who remain when our friends die, it seems a long, long time to think of their sleeping. But for those who sleep in death, the time from their death to their resurrection is only a moment. The person who falls asleep, awakes, and believes that he has but just fallen asleep; and then he sees Jesus coming in the clouds of heaven, with all the angels, to gather his children to their home. How any one can draw back at the thought of such a state between death and the resurrection, I do not understand. It is so pleasant when tired and sleepy, after a busy working-day, to lay one's head down to rest, and sleep soundly. How often we have experienced this! If one's life has been a real busy working-day in the service of the Lord, it must also be very pleasant to fall asleep, and rest from labor, with the full assurance that the voice of the Son of God shall awaken us from our deep sleep.
The best proof of the truthfulness of any doctrine is found at the death-bed of believers. And we find that on the death-bed every thought of a state between death and the resurrection departs from the believer. We have no use for it. Then we have only one thought—to fall asleep, and awaken with Christ. Thus Paul says, when he thinks of death: “To depart and to be with Christ.” Every thought of an intervening state is far from him. I have experienced something similar with a person who is very near to me. She lay like one to whom all of this life had been closed. Nothing could be seen but death, and to all human appearance there was no hope. But she was afterward restored. Then I asked her: “How was it in that moment? Were you dull and without thoughts?” She said, “No, I had my full consciousness; but I had no thought of you; only one thought filled my soul, How wonderful, that in a moment I shall be with Jesus and see him.” Thus when death comes, every thought of an intervening state between death and the resurrection, for growth and development, passes away. Then there is only room in the believing soul for this one great blessed thought and assurance, “To depart and to be with Christ.”
It is plain to me that if this blessed life of faith that has been awakened among us, shall develop soundly and truly, and be left as a blessed inheritance to our children after us, in coming generations, then we must protest earnestly against this unscriptural and un-Lutheran doctrine of a conscious state between death and the resurrection, with repentance and apostasy, growth and development. And whosoever may oppose me on this point, no one can deny that I have Luther on my side, and that I stand on the ground of the Lutheran Church with my protest.