THE RELIGIOUS TEST OF CITIZENSHIP

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 16, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 41.

Read the full edition

THE RELIGIOUS TEST OF CITIZENSHIP.

On the 25th of Sept. there occurred an incident at Philadelphia that may be taken as a noticeable sign of the times. It is reported that Judge Arnold, of the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, refused on that date to grant naturalization papers to a Hungarian, because of his expressed disbelief in a deity of any kind. The Judge remarked: “We don't want any more infidels in this country; there are enough in it as it is.” So far as we are aware, this is the first case on record where this test has been applied in this country to foreigners seeking citizenship. While we regard infidelity as a heinous offense in the sight of Heaven, and as a withering blight upon humanity, we are not aware that, as yet, the laws of our country permit it to be regarded as a sufficient cause for refusing citizenship to foreigners, or for disfranchising those who are already citizens, whether native or foreign born. It is not probable that the action of Judge Arnold would be sustained, were the matter to be brought before a higher court. Judge Arnold's action may be regarded as the direct outgrowth of National Reform agitation, and as a forerunner of what that movement seeks to make the universal custom of the country. The adherents of that movement state boldly that this is a consummation that they are zealously aiming at; and that the test to be applied shall consist of such construction of religion as may be agreed upon by the leaders of the several denominations. Their work has begun to bear visible fruit, a sample of which is seen in the case under consideration. The incident is already being seized by the friends of National Reform, and used to the best advantage to roll along their car. As an instance of such efforts, we quote herewith an article that appeared in the Pittsburg Times of Oct. 6, under the heading “A Bold Prophecy:” —
Rev. Nevin Woodside, pastor of the Grant Street Reformed Presbyterian church, preached a sermon yesterday on the action of Judge Arnold, of Philadelphia, who refused to grant naturalization papers to an infidel Hungarian. The text was: “For they are God's ministers.” After defining the meaning of the text and its application to the existing state of things in the United States, Dr. Woodside said: “All civil government is taken from God's government and laws, and finds only substantial foundation in the revelations and teachings of the Bible. Men are banded together for mutual protection, and make the laws for their own government. All civil law is the product of God, and men are obliged to keep it, and reverence its Maker. We elect men to offices, and equip them with the law, which is God's law, and this they are bound to administer. A judge is a minister of God, and he must administer the law according to fundamental principles, which are the principles found in the Holy Scriptures. The Covenanters of Scotland, the Presbyterians of Ireland, the Puritans of England, the Huguenots of France, the members of the Reformed Church of Holland, believed that Jesus Christ was the only mediator between God and man; kept the Sabbath, and observed all the laws of the Bible.
“The laws administered in our courts are but the teachings of the Scripture formulated into law, and the judge, elected by the people or appointed, is but administering the law of God when he decides the cases that come before him. The common law of the United States is Christianity. The security of liberty to all classes of citizens, the protection of churches, the enactment and enforcement of laws which prohibit the violation of the Sabbath day,—all go to show that this is a Christian Government. Every State in the Union, with one exception, recognizes the Christian Sabbath as a divine institution, not communistic. It is a scriptural government. God gave the people the right to choose their representatives and rulers. Our Government guarantees the right of conscience to all people, and does not compel men to worship according to a certain form. The Constitution of the United States is a moral one, and we can hold office under it, and take part in the administration of the laws of the country.
“Was the judge in Philadelphia right, recently, when he refused to naturalize an infidel foreigner?—Yes. All honor to him! The infidel was not qualified to become a citizen of the United States. According to our Constitution and laws, being—as I have already said—pre-eminently Christian, the infidel cannot occupy a place among its citizens. The first commandment says, ‘Thou shalt have no other gods before me,’ and in a recent decision the judge had a precedent for excluding the infidel from citizenship. The time is not far distant when Ingersoll and his followers will be prohibited from all rights of citizenship in this country, and no infidel be permitted to plead a case or sit as judge.”
In the utterances of Rev. Mr. Woodside is seen the plausible manner in which the subject can be handled. The question is set forth in a manner well calculated to gain the assent and support of all who are not avowed infidels, and such assent will no doubt very largely be given. Those who do not stop to reflect upon the final outcome of the adoption of a religious test of citizenship, or who, foreseeing that outcome, are desirous of its accomplishment, will put their shoulders to the wheels and help move along the car of National Reform, regardless of consequences. But this movement is in direct opposition to the basis of the form of government of this country, and subversive of the principles of true liberty.
Mr. Woodside's manner of handling the question shows how ingeniously and yet positively the Sunday-Sabbath is to be woven in as a part and parcel of the test that it is proposed to establish. Thus is the way being prepared for the realization of the words of Dr. Jonathan Edwards, in an address delivered by him in 1873 before a National Reform convention held in New York City. In considering the opposing forces of the movement, he spoke of atheists, deists, Jews, and seventh-day observers, and then said:—
These all are, for the occasion, and as far as our amendment is concerned, one class. . . . They must be counted together. . . . They must be treated as, for this question, one party.
And so it is coming; and he who cannot discover the onward progress of the movement, like a dark and ominous storm-cloud rising from the west, must be blind indeed. The signs of the times are constantly growing more and more decisive and unmistakable. Who will correctly discern them, and prepare to stand accordingly? G. W. M.