“Then the Church sat down at her ease, and said: ‘I am rich, and in goods increased; I have need of nothing, and nought to do, But to laugh and dance and feast. I will welcome the world to my festal halls, With attractions varied and new; And thus easily done, with frolic and fun, I will give to the Lord his due.’”
On a certain occasion “Jesus sat over against the treasury, and beheld how the people cast money into the treasury.” Mark 12:41. The motive and manner of giving to the Lord should be regarded as much as the amount given. Matt. 6:1–4. God even curses services of any kind performed in a wrong spirit. Jer. 23:36–40. As we come to the annual period of multiplied church entertainments, such as fairs, festivals, concerts, tableaux, and amateur theatricals, I wish to utter some words of testimony to God’s professed people, concerning these methods of winning the heart and purse of the world:—
1. These methods of raising money for the Lord are all contrary to the precepts and examples of his word, and, therefore, they cannot please him.
They are counterfeit methods of giving, and they cultivate bogus benevolence. The simple method of free-will offerings alone is approved, and all other methods are virtually condemned. Study Ex. 35:5, 21, 29; 2 Cor., chaps. 8, 9; Luke 6:35; Matt. 10:8. One tenth, or more, cheerfully and directly given, was the law of Old Testament stewardship, and it is the privilege of the New. What if Moses had instituted a grand carnival or bazaar to draw the surrounding heathen into his camp, and get means to build the tabernacle? How would it comport with the character of early Christians to read in one of Paul’s epistles a suggestion that the saints at Corinth get up some amateur theatricals or Isthmian games to raise money for the poor saints at Jerusalem? or an exhortation to Lydia to stir up the godly women of Philippi to get up a grand fair, festival, or baby show, with all our latest modern devices? Man’s method may procure more money, but God’s way will procure the greater blessing. No other way can be acceptable to him.
2. These unblessed devices are belittling, contemptible, and sometimes positively dishonest.
It is almost a shame to even speak of them in detail. What shall we say, what would the Master say, of a bevy of vain and bedizened young ladies, fascinating and cornering susceptible young men, to sell them commodities above value, and which they did not want? What of the many devices like grab-bag, fish-pond, ring-cake, and raffle, involving the gambling principle? What of the church of God peddling out small wares and fun to the world? or getting up a variety show to replenish her treasury? How belittling to the church, how dishonoring to God, and how contemptible in the eyes of the world!
Said an infidel to me: “I think your God must be in great need of money, by the tricks the churches practice to get it for him.” Many of the pious grieve over these things, and hang their heads for shame. Even those who aid and attend these performances cannot well approve them. Why have they not conscience and courage enough to witness against them? No intelligent Christian can ask God’s blessing upon such practices, nor expect it to rest upon money so procured. Says the Christian:—
The primitive churches had their “agapae,” or “feasts of charity,” or love, where social intercourse of a strictly religious character was enjoyed by the disciples of the Lord. Instead of these ancient and pious festivals, we are now accustomed to a class of social gatherings of an entirely different character, which are inaugurated and perpetuated for the special object of obtaining money. Concerning them, a writer remarks as follows: “At almost every street corner for the last few days we are hailed with, ‘Don’t you want a ticket to the —festival?’”
When church-members are truly converted to God, and have a religion that goes pocket deep, there will be no need of calling in the flirts and fops and loafers of the town to dicker over rag dolls and India-rubber babies, and other tomfooleries, to raise money “for the support of the gospel.” If churches cannot live without dishonoring the Lord, then let them die decently and speedily, and when such cumberers of the ground are cut down, there may be room for other trees that will bear good fruit. And if ministers of the gospel cannot be supported without resorting to such means to obtain a livelihood, let them go into worldly business with their backslidden churches, and leave their room for men whom God has really sent to preach his word. The commissioned messengers of Almighty God, sent to warn a slumbering world of approaching judgment, will not be dependent upon such sources for their support. This whole system of supporting religious worship by the sale of gimcracks and the giving of entertainments is a fraud. A religion that cannot be sustained without such devices is not worth sustaining, and the ministry which is dependent for its support on this sort of backsheesh, begged from the votaries of the world, the flesh, and the Devil, is a disgrace to the gospel which it professes to proclaim. It is almost like sending Christ out begging bread of his enemies.
When the blood-bought church of God, with all her store of wealth, resorts to such miserable shifts to get help from the world, what must worldlings, with their lavish outlay for the pleasures of sin, think of the value of our salvation? Rev. R. M. Patterson, D. D., of Philadelphia, a remarkably observant and intelligent pastor, says:—
One particularly disgraceful phase of that general inconsistency of the Christian life which is so harmful to the progress of Christ’s cause, may be noted—the growing disposition to administer churches as if it was a part of their mission to provide entertainment for the people. Fairs, concerts, comical lectures, oyster suppers, turning the dedicated house of worship into a place of hilarious amusement, are fearfully demoralizing to the religious life. They dispiritualize the people; merge the high sense of obligation into pleasure-seeking; blot out that line of demarkation between the church and the world, which cannot be destroyed without debasing the one and affording rare comfort to the other in its sins. The piety of congregations which tolerate such things has lost the high old Puritan type. They are full of weaklings, with itching ears and sensual stomachs, who measure a church by its amusement-producing capacity. In the end no congregation gains by having them.
3. These methods abate and corrupt the spirit of gospel benevolence in the church, and bring it under bondage to the world.
Instead of “acts of worship” and exercises of benevolence, they are scenes of carnal revelry and selfish pleasure. They foster the worldly spirit of self-indulgence instead of the Christian spirit of self-denial as designed by the institution of almsgiving. They are tricks of traffic with the Lord, and devices by which to give him “what costs us nothing.” They are “giving made easy,” patents for the convenience of stingy saints. If men cannot be persuaded to give to the Lord, “hoping for nothing again,” in the spirit of willing and cheerful benevolence, we have the best reason to believe that he does not want them to give at all. Luke 6:35; 2 Cor. 9:7; Matt. 10:8.
The Sunday School Times waxes satirical, and with good cause, in speaking of the modern Sunday-school drama and church fair:—
“And now, brethren, let us get up a supper, and eat ourselves rich,” said a witty Presbyterian elder, in keen satire on the church-fair plan, when this church was proposing indirect methods of raising money for new and necessary expenditures. “Buy your food,” he said, “then give it to the church. Then go buy it back again. Then eat it up, and your church debt is paid.”
If that is the best way of getting all hands to contribute to a good cause, by all means let it be introduced into the churches for every Sunday service. Just think of it! The deacons or vestrymen pass around the boxes on Sunday morning; at the same time they offer to serve refreshments to all who give liberally. The pastor at his desk repeats appropriate sentences meantime. For example:—
Pastor.—“Give, and it shall be given unto you.”
Deacon.—(Reaching out the contribution box to a stranger in the congregation) A plate of ice-cream goes to every person who contributes twenty-five cents or more. Can you help us this morning?
P.—“There is that scattereth, and yet increaseth.”
D.—(To the father of a family) A bag of peanuts goes to each child who contributes not less than five cents; lemonade to the father. Let all take hold to-day. We need the money.
P.—“It is more blessed to give than to receive.”
D.—Tickets for the young people’s entertainment, only ten cents.
That is the church fair idea. If it works well in one place, why not in another? If it is the way of promoting God’s cause on week day evenings, why not make it available for the same cause Sundays? Can there be any doubt as to the folly of this double-faced, indirect method of trying to raise money for the Lord’s cause, in contrast with the straightforward, honest appeal to men to give of their substance to him on whom they depend for all things?
These methods are especially designed to draw money from the purses of “outsiders,” and thus spare “insiders;” but we should remember that the world, the flesh, and the Devil, claim a mortgage on all institutions which they help to support. We should not expect Satan to help pay for the weapons with which we assail him, nor allow the house of God to be divided against itself. The world expects its stock to vote in a church as well as in a railroad corporation. If we beg of the world to help us support the church, we must allow the world a measure of control in it, and it will gradually become “a church of the world.” Besides, it would greatly promote the spirituality and usefulness of many churches if their vain and showy extravagances were curtailed. Better be without silver or gold, with apostolic power, than as we are. Rev. C. H. Parkhurst naively says:—
One of the strongest points in the early church was that they had so little money.
4. Many of these practices are evil in their desecration of our places of worship.
Even if we do not regard places now as consecrated, like the temple, all agree in the expediency and importance of hallowed associations. After the memorable scene of transfiguration, Peter calls the place a “holy mount.” Reverence in worship is naturally connected with reverence for the sanctuary of worship. Certainly the spirit of the law in Lev. 19:30—“Ye shall keep my Sabbaths, and reverence my sanctuary: I am the Lord”—has never been made void. But what undevotional associations must linger on Sunday in the sanctuary where we lately attended a “neck-tie and apron social,” or saw the Sunday-school children play “Cock Robin” or “Mother Hubbard”!
After a literary entertainment in one of our churches, I asked a friend to what the church was dedicated? He replied, “We dedicated it at first to the Lord, but last night we dedicated it to Shakespeare, Dickens, and Bret Harte.” The law to tax churches that are used as play-houses and pay houses is just and equal. Our solemn ceremony of dedicating or consecrating buildings to religious instruction and worship, is manifestly a sacred farce if they are to be used as play-houses or club rooms.
Fair and festival, frolics untold, Are held in the place of prayer; And maidens, bewitching as sirens of old, With worldly graces rare, Invent the very cunningest tricks, Untrammeled by gospel or laws, To beguile, and amuse, and win from the world Some help for the righteous cause.
Christ twice cleansed the temple of abominations far less offensive than these, and if he were here nothing less severe than a whip of small cords would suffice.
(Concluded next week.)