AdventAI

THEORY AND PRACTICE.

By W. A. C.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 47., December 2, 1890

Crafts Against Antinomianism; and Dungan vs. Crafts.

Sometimes men who are greatly in error say some good things. Thomas Paine said, “A firm bargain, right reckonings, and oft settlements make long friends.” This is an excellent business rule, and all men would do well to follow it, though Mr. Paine’s views on the Bible were infidel.

Mr. Crafts can see no foundation for a septenary Sabbath in this dispensation without admitting the perpetuity of the decalogue, and especially of the fourth precept of the ten. Hence, in the Christian Statesman of Nov. 20, 1890, he takes the Disciples to task for their antinomian views. After affirming the immutability of the law of God, stating that “the decalogue cannot be put aside by us in any of its parts except by authority as divine and as specific as that which first proclaimed it,” he says:—

“It is claimed by the excellent people known as ‘Disciples,’ who keep the Lord’s day but do not call it ‘Sabbath,’ that Christ abrogated the decalogue as a whole, but re-enacted the other nine commandments as his own, leaving the fourth commandment reprobate. Certain passages in the epistles seem to declare an abrogation of the ‘law,’ but we can get their real meaning, at least the real meaning of the New Testament, only by collecting all its references to the old law, and comparing scripture with scripture. I have done this, and find that being ‘dead to the law,’ etc., manifestly means, in part, the change from compulsory obedience as a slave to glad obedience in the new adoption of sonship; in part that since my Substitute has died for me, I am as one dead to the violated law; in part that ceremonial laws whose purpose is fulfilled, are no longer binding. But I find no abrogation of laws which in their very nature are as appropriate in one age as another, and for one people as another. The decalogue, on the other hand, I find three times reaffirmed by Christ, and quoted by apostles as the supreme law of mankind.”

“The passages where a part of the decalogue is quoted and not the rest, manifestly cannot be made to prove that the laws not then quoted are abrogated. That would cancel, ‘Honor thy father and thy mother,’ and even, ‘Thou shalt have no other gods before me.’ It is said that every other commandment except the fourth is somewhere specifically referred to in the New Testament as still in force. But Christ’s words, ‘The Sabbath was made for man,’ as distinctly re-affirm the fourth commandment, as any other passage declares the first commandment to be binding always and everywhere. Let the Disciples add this to their proof-texts. We shall have little occasion to debate about abrogation of the Pentateuch when they give us back all the decalogue from the hands of Christ.”

This is a very good answer to antinomianism. But the query at once arises, If Mr. Crafts believes the fourth commandment to be binding, why does he not keep it? That says, “The seventh day is the Sabbath;” but he keeps the first day. Admitting the binding force of the fourth commandment, the Disciples can see no possible escape from the duty to keep the seventh day. We will let the words of a member of this denomination arraign Mr. Crafts upon this point. Prof. D. R. Dungan, in his work, “Sabbath or Lord’s Day—Which?” pp. 4, 5, says:—

“If God requires us to keep the seventh day of the week, keeping the first will not be obeying that command. And it is vain to talk of keeping the spirit of a law when we deliberately violate its letter. It is impossible to be religiously right and scripturally wrong at the same time. If God commanded all men to keep the seventh day of the week, and has never changed or removed that law, then we must either keep the seventh day or violate the commandment of God. This is so self-evident that to elaborate or repeat it would indicate a want of confidence in my readers.”

Thus, Mr. Crafts can see no foundation for observing any day without admitting the perpetuity of the law of the Sabbath; and admitting this, Prof. Dungan sees no escape from observing the seventh day. To justify the practice of observing one day in seven, Mr. Crafts tells Prof. Dungan and his brethren that they must not do away with the fourth commandment; and to save Mr. Crafts and those of his views from inconsistency, Mr. Dungan tells them they cannot consistently appeal to that in support of first-day keeping. And so they have it; one upsetting the other’s theory, and the other the other’s practice. To get Sunday-keepers to discussing the authority for Sunday-keeping, is like Paul’s propounding the question of the resurrection to the Pharisees and Sadducees. (See Acts 23: 6–10.) It is a fire-brand which destroys the error on both sides, and leaves the truth unharmed.

Of course, each tries to fix up his theory to agree with his practice. Prof. Dungan, after doing away with the law, makes a custom out of a single, first-day meeting, and then declares approved apostolic practice to be equivalent to a command. Mr. Crafts, while affirming the perpetuity of the law, declares, “We are not told to rest on the seventh day of the week, but on the seventh day after six of work. . . . The Sabbath is a movable feast. . . . There is nothing so petty in the fourth commandment as the specification of the day of the Sabbath.” But, as the above quotations show, each can see weaknesses and inconsistency in the other’s theory contrived in support of his practice. Without the fourth commandment, Prof. Dungan has no scriptural ground for observing one day in seven; and with it, Mr. Crafts has none for observing the first day of the week. The practice of both is founded upon the shifting sand of tradition and the commandments of men. There is but one way to get out of the dilemma and observe any day at all, and that is, admit the Sabbath commandment to be binding, and keep the day it specifies. Then there is sufficient ground for the rest day, the practice is consistent with the theory; and the position is invulnerable.

W. A. C.