AdventAI

WHY?

By B. L. Dieffenbacher

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 30., July 26, 1892

BY B. L. DIEFFENBACHER. (Evergreen, La.)

In the “Methodist Catechism,” published by Poe & Hitchcock, in 1867, I find the following questions and answers on p. 63:—

Question.—Why is the first day of the week observed by Christians as the Sabbath, and not the seventh day as by the Jews?

Answer.—To commemorate the resurrection of Christ, after which event the first day of the week was called the Lord’s day, and hallowed by the disciples and Christians.p. 467

Ques.—Does this change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week interfere with the original commandment?

Ans.—It does not, since that commandment evidently relates more to the portion of time which should be hallowed, than to the particular day of the week which should be observed.

I notice in answering the first question, it is stated that the first day of the week was hallowed by the disciples and Christians, but not by Christ. In this the very work of the “man of sin” (2 Thess. 2: 3, 4; Dan. 7: 25) is attributed to the apostles and Christians; which, as we shall see, is not just.

Of a truth the apostles were disciples, but a disciple is “one who adheres to the teachings of another.” The apostles were taught of Christ, and in giving them their commission, Jesus said: “Go ye therefore, and teach all nations. . . . Teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you.” And the promise was, “And, lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world.” (Matt. 28: 19, 20.

Now the apostles had the presence and power of Christ in their work. 1 Cor. 2: 2-4. But Christ had promised to be with them only as they taught the people “to observe all things” as he had commanded them; but there is no record in the word of God where Christ ever commanded the people to observe Sunday, the first day of the week, as a Sabbath, because he would rise from the dead on that day. Nor did he command the apostles to teach it.

It is also stated that the disciples and Christians hallowed the Lord’s day (Sunday). But this cannot be, since man has no power to change his own condition from sin to holiness (Prov. 20: 9; Jer. 13: 23), much less make holy a day of rest on which God never rested. But if they had commanded us to keep it without a command from Christ, then we would only have a man-made commandment, and we could only render vain worship by obeying it (Mark 7: 7), and thus “reject the commandment of God.” Verse 9.

Ques.—Does this change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week interfere with the original commandment?

Ans.—It does not, since that commandment evidently relates more to the portion of time which should be hallowed than to the particular day of the week which should be observed.

If this kind of reasoning will hold good when applied to the fourth commandment, it will hold equally as well when applied to the first and second. And the heathen who make and bow down to their gods of wood and stone, as well as all other idolaters, are free from the condemnation of these two commandments which forbid idol worship.

Let us apply the test.

Ques.—Does the change of worship from the true to the false gods “interfere with the original commandment?”

“It does not, since that commandment evidently relates more” to the worship of a god than that any particular god should be worshiped. God’s word would permit the heathen to worship his false gods on the very same ground that it would permit the Christian to observe his false Sabbath. The one has no more authority in the Bible than the other, and in fact, heathenism is the result of forgetting the true Sabbath, which reminds man of the true God, the Creator of heaven and earth.

Again: on p. 66 I read:—

Ques.—Does not St. James teach us if we break but one of the commandments, we shall fall into condemnation?

Ans.—He does. For whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all.

But if when the Christian substitutes the first day of the week for the Sabbath, instead of the seventh day, he does not fall under the condemnation of the fourth commandment, neither will the heathen who substitutes a false god for the true, fall under the condemnation of the first and second commandments.

Does God really mean what he says in regard to worshiping false gods in the first two commandments? Then why does he not also mean what he says in regard to the seventh-day Sabbath in the fourth commandment? Echo answers, Why?