BY HAROLD STEARNS, M. D.
A LATELY published work which is in many respects remarkable, is “Natural Law in the Spiritual World,” by Prof. Henry Drummond, of Edinburgh. The author’s object is not so much to reconcile science with religion, as to show that the laws which govern the spiritual life are not only similar to natural laws but at least in many cases actually identical. To use the author’s own words:—
Is there not reason to believe that many of the laws of the spiritual world, hitherto regarded as occupying an entirely separate province, are simply the laws of the natural world? . . . In a word, is the supernatural natural or unnatural?
For example, take the doctrine of biogenesis, or the origin of life. In science there have been two opposing parties, the one claiming that there is such a thing as spontaneous generation; that is, that life is capable of springing into being of itself, independent of any pre-existing life; the other holding that all life springs from some pre-existing life.
In the religious world two similar theories have been and are still held, in regard to spiritual life. One class, and by far the largest, hold that there lies in man the power to attain to the spiritual life; that it is simply the final stage in the evolution of his moral nature, subject to the influence of education and surroundings as is his physical or intellectual development; the other class, though small in numbers, and looked down upon as unscientific, hold that the spiritual life is a gift from God, the source of all life, not attainable through any effort of ours, though free to all who place themselves in the position to receive it. This doctrine cannot be better expressed than by the wordsp. 179 of Christ himself: “He that hath the Son hath life; and he that hath not the Son of God hath not life.” “Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God.”
So far as the doctrine of biogenesis from a scientific stand-point is concerned, at the present time it can hardly be said that there are two sides to the question. The theory of spontaneous generation has received its death blow at the hands of the very men who have striven in vain to uphold it as an important part of the theory of evolution, and the opposite view has taken its place as one of the proved and unalterable laws of nature. But what is this law but the very one so clearly enunciated by Christ and all the New Testament writers?
When Christ said to Nicodemus, “Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God,” he laid down no arbitrary and unreasonable distinction, but a natural law. As soon might the mineral expect by striving to become a living plant, as man by his own efforts to become possessed of spiritual life. When the plant reaches down and takes up particles of inorganic matter, it then becomes organized or possessed of life. So God must reach down and give us the principle of eternal life, before we can become immortal.
The moral man may be very perfect in the eyes of the world, but he can never be anything but a beautiful crystal, unless he is “born again.” We surely need not be surprised to see the truths of science thus upholding the truths of revelation; for the author of both is God. But it will be both interesting and profitable to note how the application of natural law to spiritual truths supports the doctrines held by Seventh-day Adventists. Especially would we call attention to the relation of natural law to the doctrine of the annihilation of the wicked, which we believe to be both Scriptural and rational.
From what we have already said in regard to the doctrine of the origin of life, it would seem to be the most natural, as well as the most scientific, conclusion that death should be the portion of those who do not accept the conditions of life. Nothing could be plainer on this subject than the words of Christ already quoted, “He that hath not the Son of God hath not life.” But if we carry the investigation still further, and study into the law of degeneration as applied to the spiritual life, we shall find still further support of our position.
Prof. Drummond shows that there is in all nature a natural tendency to decay. While all things seem teeming with life, the shadow of death is everywhere. Take the principle of life out of the plant or animal, and the very things that seemed to nourish it are now the agents of death. The sun withers it, the air and moisture decompose it, and soon the organization is utterly destroyed, so that life has been well defined to be “the sum of the functions that resist death.”
This downward tendency of all things in nature, applies to man as well, in both his physical and his moral nature. There is no “happy medium” in which we can stagnate. By an inexorable law of our being, we must either retrograde or advance. The goal of one path is eternal death; of the other, eternal life. An eternal retrogression is a scientific absurdity. “The soul that sinneth, it shall die.”
From this brief review of the scientific aspect of these important questions, it is evident that the opposite of salvation is annihilation. But this conclusion, which is both scientific and Scriptural, is unorthodox, and therefore must be met, if possible. This Prof. Drummond attempts to do in the following language:—
Should any one object that from this stand-point the opposite of salvation is annihilation, the answer is at hand. From this stand-point there is no such word.
That is, science knows nothing of the annihilation of matter as matter. We need not dispute this fact, though we can hardly doubt that God has the power even to destroy matter, should he choose to exercise it. Nor need we enter into the vexed question of the nature of the soul. If it is not material, and subject to natural law, the above argument has no force. The question is, Has the doctrine of the annihilation of the wicked, which seemed to follow as the result of the working of a natural law, been met by the answer given above?—We think not; for we are not now dealing with matter as matter, but as organization. The essential thing in man is character, which is the result of organization.
It matters not what becomes of the identical particles of oxygen or nitrogen of which we are composed. These are constantly changing, and yet our identity remains unchanged. Insect, bird, beast, and man are but forms through which a stream of matter is constantly flowing. The Hudson and the Connecticut are both rivers. Both are formed of the same kind of material, and yet one is entirely distinct from the other. Each may be said to have a distinct character.
Now let us suppose that suddenly the thousand springs which are the source of life to these rivers, cease to flow. The water contained in the bed of the stream empties itself into the sea or is evaporated. The bed dries up, trees and grass spring up in it, and soon all traces of the river are lost. Not a particle of the matter of which the river was composed is lost, yet the river is utterly annihilated. So it is with our life, both natural and spiritual. Take away its source, which is God, and annihilation must inevitably follow, though not a particle of matter be lost.
Although the writers of the Bible may have had no knowledge of this scientific truth, yet the language they use is clearly in accord with the same. “The wicked shall be ashes under the feet of the righteous;” they “shall be utterly destroyed;” “into smoke shall they consume away.” The figure of burning is often applied to their destruction, and in this, science tells us there is no destruction of matter as matter, but only as organized matter.
The annihilation of the wicked, then, is not only a fact of revelation, but a fact of science. Surely, we can rejoice that the truths of God’s word are only made the brighter by the most exact and careful investigations of science. The gulf which now seems to separate science and revealed religion, is caused by error on both sides. The truths of the Bible and the truths of science can never come into conflict. Knowing this, and believing that we have the truth, we may fearlessly invite the attention of candid thinkers to it, and to the honest in heart it will come as a light from Heaven, shining “more and more unto the perfect day.”
In conclusion it will be only just to say, that the author of “Natural Law in the Spiritual World” has done a good work for revealed religion, in showing its naturalness, and divesting it of much that seemed mysterious only through our ignorance. In some cases, as in that to which we have called attention, his argument seems to have led naturally to conclusions he hardly dared to accept, and yet which were undoubtedly in the direction of truth.
Morrison, Col.