Truth vs. Error

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 7, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 23.

Read the full edition

Truth vs. Error.

BY ELD. E. H. GATES.
The unscriptural doctrines of the immortality of the soul and the reward of the righteous at death, completely set aside, and make of no consequence, the doctrines of the second advent of Christ, the Judgment, the resurrection, and the restoration of the earth.
If men go to Heaven at death, what necessity is there that Christ should come to earth to get them? They are already there. If one of these doctrines is true, the other cannot be. But the Scriptures do teach the doctrine of the second advent, while nothing is said about the immortality of the soul. Which doctrine is the true one?
Of what use is a general Judgment at the end of the world, if men go to Heaven when they die? A reward at death presupposes a Judgment; for why should men be rewarded before being judged? God will certainly use as much wisdom in dealing with his creatures as those who administer justice here on earth; and who ever heard of a jury sending a man to prison or the gallows before his trial? While nothing is said in the Bible about rewards and punishments at death, it does clearly teach a future Judgment. If one of these doctrines is true, no necessity exists for the other; in fact, it cannot be true. Thus very little is heard in the popular preaching of the day about the day of Judgment. Another, and an unscriptural doctrine has taken its place.
The same thing may be said of the resurrection. If the disembodied spirit can exist independent of the body, and is better off without it, why should the old clog be brought out of the grave to again fetter the soul? If the doctrine of the immortality of the soul be true, the resurrection is of no use. On the other hand, if there is to be a resurrection, the other doctrine is proved untrue.
I lately read an article in the Christian Union, from A. P. Peabody, D. D., on the “Resurrection of the Body.” He says, “It is very strange that the literal resurrection of the body should have found and retained a place in the creed of the Christian church, while not only is it without any support from Holy Writ, but is opposed equally to the general drift of our Saviour’s teaching, and to the explicit statement of the apostle latest, yet foremost, in the sacred college.” Further on, he says, “If the redeemed can live in heavenly happiness in the mansions of the Father’s house on high for thousands of years, without the bodies that they left in the grave, what urgent necessity can there be that these bodies be given back to them?”
Very true. But the very fact that the Bible does teach a literal resurrection of the body, proves the other view to be unscriptural. It is not at all “strange” that the doctrine of the resurrection should find a place in the Christian church, for it is taught by all the inspired writers; but it is strange that the church has thrown it away, and filled its place with a doctrine which has not a word of support in the Scriptures.
That the earth is finally to be restored and fitted up as the saints’ inheritance, is one of the fundamental doctrines of the Scriptures. But who would ever learn that fact from the popular theology of the day? If the saints dwell eternally in Heaven, they certainly have no use for the restored earth. Then we are told that they are to exist as immaterial, disembodied spirits; if so, of what use will be a material earth for such ethereal beings? So another beautiful Bible doctrine must give way, and be lost sight of, before the claims of this usurper, immortal-soulism.
Nor does the trouble end here. Upon the doctrine of the conscious state of the dead are built several other false theories. The Catholic purgatory depends for its existence upon it. Without it, spiritualism, that offspring of hell, could not exist for an hour. Saint-worship, image-worship, and other monstrous dogmas of popery and paganism, sprang from that old lie told by the devil in the garden of Eden to mother Eve. And that lie has been handed down through the ages, and is now taught as the most orthodox doctrine of the Christian churches.
Let us but find the true doctrine of immortality through Christ, and all these false theories will be no more.