WILL SWITZERLAND IMPRISON PASTOR HOLSER?
By W. H. McKee
At the hearing of the appealed case of Pastor Holser, of Basel, before the Federal Court,—the Swiss court of last resort,—the appeal was denied, and the penalty of fine and imprisonment for Sunday labor in the publishing house under his charge, affixed by the Basel court, left in full force. The Factory Law, under which Pastor Holser was arrested and convicted, is a federal law, and it appears that the Federal Court has no power to construe a federal law, or to decide upon its constitutionality or unconstitutionality. That rests alone with the body that made the law,—the Federal Council. Therefore, the result of the legal action was a foregone conclusion from the first; there being really no judicial body having authority to revise the decision of the Basel police court on the important questions involved in this case,—and really nobody with authority to open the case at all after its decision by the police court, short of the Federal Council, which made the law under which the action was brought. Then, however, a wrong which had been done, as in this case, cannot be righted. The only thing possible now is for the Federal Council to interpret or repeal the defective law, that no one else may suffer injustice from it. Clearly, therefore, in cases brought before it involving the constitutionality of federal laws,—not only those in reference to Sunday labor in factories, but all federal laws,—the police court is actually the court of last resort. The court rejected the appeal without a dissenting voice. At this time Pastor Holser was making a circuit of the churches under his charge. When his appointments had been met, he returned to his office in the publishing house at Basel, and to his regular duties there. He was unmolested for five days, preaching on the Sabbath according to his usual custom, and going about the city in the pursuance of his ordinary duties. On the morning of the sixth day a notice was sent him from the police department requiring him to present himself at police headquarters, there being a clause in the order which stated that if voluntary compliance was not rendered, the order would be enforced. To this order Pastor Holser replied in these words:— “TO THE POLICE DEPARTMENT, BASEL: Your order to present myself, Oct. 23, 9 A. M., to begin three weeks’ imprisonment, is at hand. In response I can only say that I am engaged in the service of the Lord and cannot leave his work without his order. This imprisonment is prescribed in consequence of my keeping the commandments of God as he has given them in his word. In doing this I have wronged no one, and have done nothing worthy of imprisonment. Were it for having committed an unjust act, I would present myself on an order to do so; but I cannot lay down the work of the Lord at the command of men for the misdemeanor(?) of having kept the ten commandments.” During the day the public collector called to collect the fine, but he was told very plainly and simply that a fine for keeping the commandments of God could not be paid. And now comes the answer to the question before written, in the title to this article,—“Will Switzerland imprison Pastor Holser?” Just as I write this closing paragraph, Pastor Holser comes to the door in the charge of two officers, for a parting word and a shake of the hand before he goes behind the bars of the city prison of Basel. No amount of superficial leniency in the way of non-interference while his case went to the court of appeals and to the Federal Court, nor any degree of personal consideration shown him in the manner of his arrest, can be pleaded in extenuation. The fact remains which cannot be explained away,—Switzerland has imprisoned Pastor Holser for keeping the commandments of God! W. H. McKEE.