A DIVISION AND A CURE

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 13, 1894

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 45.

Read the full edition

A DIVISION AND A CURE.

There is a division in the Reformed Episcopal Church,—a difference of opinion upon a very important point, affecting the interests of the whole church. The Episcopal Recorder, organ of this church, in its issue of Oct. 25, publishes a long letter from one of its bishops, describing the difficulty, and suggesting a way to harmonize the estranged parties. The question must be of grave importance; for at the close of the article the good bishop showed his desire for unity by this earnest ejaculation: “O that our brethren could see eye to eye on this question.” It must be very important, then,—something of faith and practice, for which adequate proof is found in the Scriptures. The quotation will now be repeated with what follows:—
“O that our brethren could see eye to eye on this question,—that the East could give up its monkish cassock, and the West its sacrificial surplice,—and that all could come together, without constraint, voluntarily, and simply in the interests of the peace of the church, on the common ground of the black gown, as the only special dress to be worn by any of our ministers in any of the services of our church.”
Here is a great difficulty indeed! One party is off on a cassock, and the other off on a surplice! What shall be done? The bishop is equal to the emergency. There is a “black gown” they can all get on, or get into if they will, and thus harmony may be restored!
But how do we know that the bishop himself is not off, too, in proposing the “black gown”? Where is the Scripture, positive or inferential, for the gown any more than for the other habiliments mentioned?—There is none. The whole controversy is out of the realm of Christian ethics or polity. Then why the great fuss? Does the integrity of the church depend upon a gown? Many professed Christians hold that Seventh-day Adventists are maintaining non-essentials because we stand for the maintenance of one of the commandments of Jehovah just as he spoke and wrote it; but how does the integrity of the law of the Most High compare in importance with a gown, the wearing of which never was commanded? As we consider this affair, it strikes us very forcibly that the generation of gnat-strainers and camel-swallowers is not yet extinct, and that probably it will continue as long as time lasts. M. E. K.