AdventAI

AN INTERESTING LETTER.

By A. O. Burrill

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 45., November 13, 1894

[THE following letter received by me from the Honorable C. E. Start, Tara, Grey Co., Ontario, will be of much interest to lovers of liberty through the English-speaking world.— A. O. BURRILL.]

“Tara, Ont., Sept. 15, 1894.

“DEAR SIR: I have your letter of the 12th instant respecting Lord’s-day cases.

“The charge against James R. Barber was that on the 11th day of June, 1893, and previous Sabbath days, he, the said James R. Barber, did work at his usual labor of farming at his farm on concession 12, in township of Derby, Grey Co., and upon which charge the said James R. Barber was on the 29th day of June, 1893, convicted by and before the said James Cochrane as such justice of the peace, the charge having been laid by one Charles Speer.

“I moved before the common pleas division to quash the conviction on the following grounds:—

“1. Defendant is a farmer and not a merchant, tradesman, artificer, mechanic, workman, laborer, or other person within the meaning of the statute to prevent the profanation of the Lord’s day.

“2. The conviction discovers no offense, as it does not charge that the defendant on the day in question did any worldly labor or work of his ordinary calling.

“3. The said conviction is uncertain, and does not specify the act or acts alleged to have been done by defendant which constitute the alleged offense against the statute.

“The action was argued before the court at Toronto, on the 9th day of Feb., 1894.p. 718

“The judges at first seemed prepared to have held, but that the authorities on the point prevented it, that a farmer would be within the meaning of the act; and in fact, when finally yielding to pressure and making the order to quash, they insisted on putting the decision on the ground that the conviction which has been returned does not disclose any offense, not showing what it was the defendant had done, which constituted the alleged profanation of the Lord’s day.

“The court was not at all influenced by the fact that the defendant belonged to the Seventh-day Adventist Church. They thought the statute was passed to enforce a decent observation of Sunday, and that without regard to the religious convictions of any particular sect or individual who might deem it his duty to keep holy any or some other day in the week, he must under the statute refrain from labor on Sunday out of deference to the views of the majority of the community.

“It was therefore simply a dry question of law whether the statute applied to a farmer, and whether those proceedings showed any offense. The judges decided with us on both these points, and therefore quashed the conviction, but without costs.

“There can be no doubt about it. A farmer may labor on the Lord’s day if he likes, simply because he is a farmer. I have a great number of authorities to support my views, and the Barber case has confirmed them.

“Yours truly, “G. E. START.”