We were interested to read in the Catholic World for August, the “Experiences of a Missionary” in Michigan, who is engaged in propagating the Catholic faith in non-Catholic communities. He runs across sundry Seventh-day Adventists in his tour, which reminds him that this “sect is the most venomous enemy of Catholicity in these parts.” The Catholic Mirror is then taken severely to task for its short-sighted course in publishing those articles on the Sunday with which the readers of the REVIEW are familiar, and which compose the tract, “Rome’s Challenge.” The missionary says, immediately following his “venomous” statement:—
“And yet some of our Catholic journals have favored it [the sect] on the question of the observance of the Sunday as against Protestantism generally. I am persuaded that this is bad policy, to say the least of it.” “Do not be too eager to make men give up the truth by showing them that they are illogical.” “Our policy is to favor the right side among our jarring brethren, rather than compel consistency.” “To play off error against inconsistency is not fraternal. Furthermore, the Seventh-day Adventists incline to be Old Testament Christians, Puritans of the worst sort, and are making a propaganda of much energy, and not without results.” “The reader will in all this pardon what seems a digression, but I have been almost everywhere assailed with quotations from one of our oldest and most respectable Catholic journals, against the Scripture basis of the observance of the first day of the week, claiming that it has not any Scripture authority whatever, etc.”
Quoting then the hypothetical statements in the “Catechism of the Council of Trent,” he continues:—
“Can these tones of a voice so venerable and authoritative be harmonized with the following extract from a prominent Catholic weekly, with which I have been deafened by Seventh-day Adventists all over southern Michigan?”
“Thus, it is impossible to find in the New Testament the slightest interference by the Saviour or his apostles with the original Sabbath; but, on the contrary, an entire acquiescence in the original arrangement; nay, a plenary endorsement by him whilst living, and an unvaried, active participation in the keeping of that day and no other by the apostles for thirty years after his death, as the Acts of the Apostles have abundantly testified to us” (“Roman Catechism,” third Commandment).
“Let us not favor those among our adversaries who hate us most. The narrowest of sects, shown by their literature to be most bitterly anti-Catholic, are these judaizers, all the more hopelessly wrong if consistently logical with their Protestant premises, wrong-headed and bitter-hearted Seventh-day Adventists. Of course I treat them with every kindness, but I thank God that “consistent Protestantism” is narrowing down into this concentrated essence of bigotry, and I am very sorry that they can quote a Catholic “organ” in praise of their “consistency.”
Immediately after this vituperative effusion, the amiable gentleman gives a list of questions received and answered by himself. The first in the list is the following:—
“Question.—It is claimed by Protestants that the Catholic people in America, as they become Americanized, are imbibing the principles of Protestantism, and will soon join hands with the Protestants in one common faith. Is that so?
“Answer.—We claim, on the other hand, that Protestants, according as they become Americanized, approach nearer to the Catholic Church. America’s political principles, based as they are on the dignity of man and the need of a strong central government to secure human liberty and equality, are to the political order what Catholic principles are to the religious order. Enlightened Catholics believe that the providence of God in establishing this republic has prepared the way for the return of the northern races to Christian unity in the Catholic Church.”
But while the priest is gratified to see Protestantism as a body approaching nearer Catholicism, Haman-like, his peace is disturbed by this “venomous sect,” which alone represents “consistent Protestantism,” aided by the confession of a respected Catholic organ, and by it praised for their consistency.
But the voice with which the Mirror acknowledges the force of consistent truth, has gone to the world. And though this crafty priest and thousands of others try to hush that testimony, it will still speak to the consciences of honest people, Protestant and Catholic.
We thank God that to us it is given to stand in the very place assigned us, “consistently logical with our Protestant premises.” What a caricature does this man produce in arraying “truth” and “consistency” in antagonism! He mistakes popularity for truth, as do a multitude of others. Truth and consistency are boon principles. He accords to us the latter; God’s word assures us that we have the former. The writer of those things voices that sentiment of malignity with which error always assails the truth, a sentiment which will soon furnish the animus for universal execration and persecution of those who keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus. We are glad that against this mighty flood of error with which Catholicism is now sweeping the world, God lifts up the standard of truth,—a truth consistent with the principles of saints and martyrs of the past,—and has called Seventh-day Adventists, weak and insignificant though they be, to defend it. Let us stand in the name and Spirit of Christ, having our loins girt about with truth. G. C. T.