AdventAI

CATHOLICS AND THE LIQUOR BUSINESS.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 34., August 21, 1894

The recent decision of Mgr. Satolli in regard to Catholics selling liquor has stirred up much comment everywhere. It should be understood that this decision of Satolli was simply the enforcing, by his authority as the American apostolic legate, a former decision rendered by Bishop Watterson. That decision is not nearly as strong as many think it is. The following extract from Bishop Watterson’s decision will show his idea of regulating the liquor traffic:—

“If there are saloon-keepers in your parish who call themselves Catholics and yet carry on their business in a forbidden and disedifying way, or sell on Sundays, either openly or under any guise or disguise, in violation of civil law, and to the hurt of order and religion and the scandal of any part of the community, you will refuse them absolution, should they perchance come to receive the sacraments, unless they promise to cease offending in these or other ways, and to conduct their business blamelessly if they can, or get out of it and keep out of it altogether.”

It will be seen by the above that as long as a Catholic does not sell liquor on a Sunday, and does not carry on his business in a “disedifying way,” he is all right! It is not perfectly clear to a person uninitiated in the mysteries of the liquor traffic, how that soul-and-body-destroying business may be carried on in a way to edify any one; but probably the priests of Rome, who draw such large sums of money from the Catholic liquor-dealers, will be able to formulate some rule by which it may be done!

The extent to which the power of that church will be used to prevent Catholics from selling liquor is further shown by a controversy between the editor of the Wine and Spirit Gazette and Archbishop Corrigan, of New York. Commenting on the decision of Bishop Watterson, and its confirmation by Satolli, the editor said:—

“Fully two thirds if not more of the retail liquor-dealers of the country are Roman Catholics. Some of these are liberal contributors to church funds. . . . We voice the sentiments of a large majority of the liquor-dealers of this city and Brooklyn, in saying we dare Archbishop Corrigan to enforce in letter and spirit the decree against the liquor traffic, just issued by Mgr. Satolli, the papal delegate. Let the archbishop do it, and watch the consequences.”

To this very spirited and unequivocal letter the archbishop replied in the following words:—

“New York, July 28, 1894.

“Editor Wine and Spirit Gazette,—

“Sir: Returning to town yesterday I found on my desk a copy of your journal of July 25. In reply to your expressed wish, I have the honor to say that I loyally accept the principles laid down by his excellency Mgr. Satolli, both in their spirit and to the letter. More than this, no Catholic can refuse to accept them. As to the fear of the consequences, I have yet, thank God, to learn what fear is in the discharge of my duty. Please to remember, however, that acceptance of principles is not to be confounded with the blind application of the same, on all occasions and under all circumstances.

“Respectfully,

“M. A. Corrigan, Abp.”

And that is to say that the archbishop accepts the principle, but he will carry it out only when and where he thinks it best and politic to do so! Really, the last part of his letter practically nullifies the grandiloquent statement of loyalty to Satolli and to the cause of temperance with which his letter begins. The editor of the Wine and Spirit Gazette very properly declares that the archbishop’s letter does not touch the spot, and that it is only a skillful evasion of the question. The application of the principles of temperance as they are understood at the present time is a new thing for Catholics; hence a reform of this radical character will necessarily proceed very slowly; and the probability that Catholics will within a short time confine themselves to milk and water for drinking purposes, seems at this writing to be very remote.

M. E. K.