BY ELDER J. F. BALLENGER.
(Sheridan, Ill.)
In the Michigan Sabbath Watchman of April, 1892, Joseph Cook is quoted as saying:—
“If anything is settled, it is that the Lord’s day as it was approved by Constantine, was instituted by the early church on the basis of apostolic precept and example.”
It is hardly possible to conceive how any person could state in fewer words more that is at variance with the facts of Scripture, history, and the admissions of theological writers, than is contained in the above quotation. We are glad that the time has come when the reading public do not take for granted such sweeping declarations, simply because they are made by one who has obtained a little notoriety. People who read and think, require that statements which involve the present and future welfare of mankind must be backed up with more than the mere assertion of some pulpit orator or noted public speaker.
When Joseph Cook or any one else says that the so-called Sunday Lord’s day is settled on the basis of apostolic precept or example, he is stating what he knows to be in direct opposition to the facts of both Scripture and all authentic history, and is thus flinging insult in the face of every well-informed person upon this question. Those who have read history upon the subject of Sunday observance know that Dr. Peter Heylyn, the historian, states the truth when he says:—
“Take which you will, either the fathers or the moderns, and we shall find no Lord’s day instituted by any apostolic mandate; no Sabbath set on foot by them upon the first day of the week.”—“History of the Sabbath,” p. 229.
And this statement of Dr. Heylyn’s is corroborated by the testimony of Dr. Neander, the great church historian, who says:—
“The festival of Sunday was always only a human ordinance, and it was far from the intentions of the apostles . . . and from the early apostolic church to transfer the laws of the Sabbath to Sunday.”—Rose’s Neander, p. 186.
Once more: Sir Wm. Domville says:—
“Centuries of the Christian era passed away before the Sunday was observed as a Sabbath. History does not furnish us with a single proof or indication that it was at any time so observed previous to the sabbatical edict of Constantine, in A. D. 321.”—Examination of the Six Texts, p. 291.
In the light of such testimony as the above, and also in the light of the fact that the New Testament is as silent as the grave concerning any precept or example for Sunday observance, how can men make such absurd statements as they do? We should not like to do it, believing as we do that for “every idle word that men shall speak, they shall give account thereof in the day of judgment.”
But let us refer to the above quotation again, and show that neither the speaker nor those who quote him believe the statement themselves. You will notice that the writer says:—
“If anything is settled, it is that the Lord’s day as it was approved by Constantine, was instituted by the early church on the basis of apostolic precept and example.”
Now let us inquire, How did Constantine approve the observance of Sunday? All we have to govern us in the settlement of this question is his own words, as found in his famous Sunday edict of A. D. 321. Does he in that edict approve the Sunday as a Christian institution? His words are, “Let all the judges, and towns-people, and the occupation of all trades rest on the venerablep. 563 day of the sun.” Does Mr. Cook believe that the early church, with a command and the example of the apostles, established Sunday-keeping in honor of “the venerable day of the sun?” They surely did, if they established it as approved by Constantine.
But further: This famous Sunday law which shows how Constantine approved Sunday-keeping, did not forbid the farmer from working; for it says, “But let those who are situated in the country, freely and at full liberty attend to the business of agriculture.”
Do the advocates of Sunday believe that the early church by a precept and the example of the apostles, allowed the farmer free and full liberty to follow his occupation on Sunday? If they do, why are they clamoring so loudly for civil law to stop all labor on Sunday? Do they want to require “somewhat more of the people than the apostles commanded,” and thus ape the Roman Catholic Church and become pious above what is written?
The sainted Richard Baxter once said: “I will not fear that God will condemn me for not doing more than he has commanded in his word.” And by the way, we would ask our Sunday-keeping friend to point us to the chapter and verse where God has commanded us to keep Sunday, and until they can do this, will they cease trying to compel us to do more than God has commanded?
The advocates of Sunday-keeping would like to have the people believe their bold and groundless statements that this question is settled by the authority of the Scriptures or history, when at the same time they know that there is not a theory or practice held anywhere in the theological world to-day that is any more lacking for scriptural support than the practice of Sunday observance. They are also aware that the question is being agitated, and there are tens of thousands of people, both in and out of the churches, who are finding out the truth on this question, and are asking their religious teachers why they keep the day in the absence of any reliable testimony either human or divine. And these teachers presume to stop this inquiry by their bold and sweeping assertions, thinking to impress the people with the idea that their superior learning and prominent positions ought to be a sufficient guaranty that their statements are correct, and should be received without any further investigation. But it seems to us that these men ought to learn from the history of the great Reformation in the sixteenth century, that the onward march of truth is not to be stopped by the mere ipse dixit of those in high positions. When the bold reformers accused the clergy of teaching contrary to the Scriptures, they were met by the priests with no higher authority than their own statements, backed up by the weight of their exalted positions. But this did not satisfy the earnest inquirer after truth; his query was not what the priest says, but, “What does the Bible say?” And we are thankful to know that in this last great reformation upon the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus, there are multitudes who are not satisfied with the mere statement of the minister, however high his position in the world of letters. They are no less anxious to know what the blessed Bible says, and are not going to be satisfied with anything less than a “thus saith the Lord.”