THAT the subject of the relation which Christianity, or in other words, what Christianity is generally understood to mean—the popular churches—should sustain toward the State in this country, is rapidly coming to the front as a topic for public discussion, is readily seen by any one who scans the public prints of to-day. A few years ago the old, solid, American theory that the State and the Church should be kept separate was scarcely questioned. At the present time, while the separation of the Church and State is conceded in words, at the same time there are not wanting those who show that they do it more because of the established precedent than from a conviction of its being right. We judge thus from the fact that while men now talk in one breath that no such union should be allowed, in the next breath they make statements and lay down propositions, which, if carried out, would unite the State and the Church again as in the days when Constantine celebrated their nuptials in the fourth century.
A late copy of the Northwestern Congregationalist contains so many “straws” indicating the way the theological winds are now blowing, that we will quote a few statements in order that our readers may see the kind of theory in relation to this subject which is now being dealt out in many of the religious newspapers. The leading article on the editorial page begins by quoting President Strong of Carlton College, who says:—
“From the nature of the case, the State cannot teach religion. Her attitude toward it, in every grade of public education, must be that of indifference and silence. The rights of every taxpayer, atheist as well as theist, infidel as well as Christian, are to be respected, and under these rights the demand is more and more imperatively made that the secularization of our public educational system, from the district school to the State university, shall be complete. And this demand must be heeded.”
The above is solid common sense, every word of which ought to be commended by every American citizen, whether he be Jew or Christian, Catholic or Protestant, agnostic or infidel. Certainly Christianity, with her sublime record of progress against the opposition of the greatest powers on earth, and her confidence in the abiding presence of Him who said: “Lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world,” in whose hands is “all power in heaven and in earth,” should be the last to ask that any State or government should grant unto her any favor which is not also granted to every one else. It seems to us to be a manifest token of their lack of reliance upon God, and a desire to make an arm of flesh their trust for them to do otherwise. But the Congregationalist does not take kindly to the position of President Strong. Equality of all sects and people before the law is not satisfactory, as the following words of comment upon President Strong’s words will show:—
“We are not sure that the writer of this paragraph used the word ‘must’ to express anything more than that which is deemed necessary under existing conditions, rather than that which ought to be. However, if the statement was taken as expressing what ought to be, it would accord with the views of some other eminent men.”
“But if that position was right, the State ought to manifest its ‘indifference’ toward religion by taxing all church property and dismissing all chaplains from its service, whether in Congress, army, or prison.”
The above quotation from the Congregationalist is a certain proof that the author accepts the historic American condition of an equality of all religions before the law only as something “necessary under existing conditions, rather than that which ought to be.” According to this, then, the principles laid down by the author of the Declaration of Independence and the framers of the American Constitution, were not the principles which “ought to be;” for the position of President Strong and that of the fathers of the American Republic are in perfect accord. The conditions existing at the time our government was established are the same to-day that they were then, and will be the same as long as time shall last. Nor can we see any reason why discrimination in favor of church property should be made in the tax list. There is no better reason that the aggregate property of a church society should be exempt from taxation than there is that their private property should be exempt. What is to hinder a church from becoming a regular corporation, investing its money in houses and lands, and claiming immunity from taxation on the ground that it is “church property?” We have read of some of the large city churches doing that very thing, and renting their untaxable buildings for grocery and dry-goods stores and even for saloons!
This incessant petting and coddling of the Christianity of our day has had precisely the effect that might have been expected. The manifest support of the churches being the State, they have learned to rely upon the State for support; and instead of a robust Christianity which goes forth strong in the Lord and in the power of his might, asking no especial fostering care or favor of the State other than equal rights before the law, and the privilege to labor as did the Master and his disciples, we have a Christianity which clings with great tenacity to the supports which the apostles cared nothing for, and which feels exceedingly weak unless fostered by some governmental prop, and ready to cry out in alarm at any proposition that worldly and unfair supports should be removed. Neither can we see any justification for the government-paid army and navy chaplaincies. The spectacle of a body of men about to engage in deadly conflict, listening while a chaplain prays to Him who said: “Love your enemies, . . . do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you,” is even a greater incongruity than it is for a Mohammedan to—
“Pause and kneel unshod In the fresh blood his hand hath poured, To mutter o’er some text of God, Engraven on his reeking sword.”
For Mohammed taught that a “drop of blood shed in the cause of God, or a night spent in arms, is worth more than months of fasting and prayer.”
Again we quote from the Congregationalist:—
“We are in danger of making a fetish of the separation of Church and State. We draw inferences from this idea as though it were an ultimate principle of human rights. We need to remember, that, important as it is, it is simply a policy which rests on the basis of expediency. There was no separation of Church and State in the Hebrew commonwealth, which was founded under divine guidance, and we are by no means sure that there will be any such separation when the gospel shall so control the hearts of the masses that ‘the kingdom of this world’ shall become ‘the kingdom of our Lord and of his Christ.’ We only know that, under present conditions, this separation is a needful safeguard of both religious and civil liberty.”
When we read the above, we could hardly believe that we were reading an editorial in a professedly Christian and Protestant paper of the nineteenth century. One would think that such words must emanate from some monk of the Middle Ages, instead of a Christian editor of free America. The American policy of government in the separation of Church and State “rests on the basis of expediency!” Tell it not in America! publish it not in the land of Washington, Madison, and Jefferson! The reason given, that “there was no separation of Church and State in the Hebrew commonwealth,” is equally as absurd as is his conception of the reason why Church and State were separated by the founders of our government.
The Hebrew commonwealth has passed away. There is no command of God that the nations of the world should model their governments after the Jewish theocracy. God has not taken the American Republic, or any other nation at the present time, into any such relation to himself as he did the Hebrew nation. The difference in the relation which God sustained to the Hebrews and those which he sustained to other nations is thus set forth by Moses:—
“For ask now of the days that are past, which were before thee, since the day that God created man upon the earth, and ask from the one side of heaven unto the other, whether there hath been any such thing as this great thing is, or hath been heard like it? “Did ever people hear the voice of God speaking out of the midst of the fire, as thou hast heard, and live? “Or hath God assayed to go and take him a nation from the midst of another nation, by temptations, by signs, and by wonders, and by war, and by a mighty hand, and by a stretched-out arm, and by great terrors, according to all that the Lord your God did for you in Egypt before your eyes?” Deut. 4: 32–34.
When God takes another nation in the same way and with the same visible tokens of his special interposition that he did Israel, gives them laws with his own voice, and declares them to be his peculiar people above all other nations, then and not till then we shall be willing to believe that God wants another theocracy established in the earth. When the kingdoms of this world become the “kingdoms of our Lord and of his Christ,” earthly governments will have passed away in the fullness of the dawning of that day when Christ shall reign in “Mount Zion and in Jerusalem and before his ancients gloriously.” Until that time all these “safeguards” are needed. It is our profound conviction that the danger that we shall make a “fetish” of the separation of Church and State is not half so great as is the danger that some such union will actually be formed, and the former scenes of church domination, and consequent persecution be revived.
The basis of the separation of Church and State in this country rests not upon “expediency,” but upon the unalienable rights of man. As long as these rights are respected, Church and State will be kept apart both in name and in reality. The trend of thought among many of the religious people of this country at the present time is apparently in the direction of a closer relation of the Church to the State. Asp. 567 General Grubb recently said in a speech at the Asbury Park camp-meeting, “Politics should go hand in hand with religion.” This is the policy which is being pursued by Mr. Quay, and the kind of religion which he possesses is the kind which is sure to come to the front when politics and religion join hands. To assume an air of piety, to be very zealous for religious reforms, and to excel in the use of pious phrases, have been the means by which many demagogues have risen to high offices, and the road to the same goal is likely to be well trodden by the zealous aspirants for national honors at the present day in our country. The fathers of the American Republic lived at the time when the evil effects of the mutual dependent relation of the Church and State upon each other were painfully apparent, and they endeavored not only to avoid the evil effects of it for themselves, but to do the same for their posterity. As the result of this wise statesmanship, we have not been permitted to see the evils which they grappled and subdued, and many zealous people, not knowing what those evils were, are longing for the “old times” when the church dictated legislation, and the people were compelled to submit. Jefferson foresaw such a contingency, and foretold it in the following manner:—
“Besides, the spirit of the times may alter, will alter. Our rulers will become corrupt, our people careless. A single zealot may commence persecution, and better men be his victims. It can never be too often repeated that the time for fixing every essential right on a legal basis is while our rulers are honest and ourselves united. From the conclusion of this war we shall be going down hill. It will not then be necessary to resort every moment to the people for support. They will be forgotten, therefore, and their rights disregarded. The shackles, therefore, which shall not be knocked off at the conclusion of this war, will remain on us long, will be made heavier and heavier, till our rights shall revive or expire in a convulsion.”—Notes on Virginia.
To-day we see attempts being made, not covertly, but openly, to take away from the people the rights guaranteed to them by the Constitution, on the grounds that these rights were acknowledged as matters of “expediency” until some better day should come when these rights can be ignored and utterly destroyed! Fellow-citizens, shall this un-American, un-Christian, and iniquitous plan be carried out?—M. E. K., in Battle Creek Moon.