LUTHER'S VIEW ON COMPELLING CONSCIENCE.
By Martin Luther
The laws of secular governments do not extend farther than the concerns of our external selves and our possessions, or whatever is external and material on the earth. But over the believing soul God cannot and will not consent that any one shall assume control, besides himself. Wherever, therefore, any secular power presumes to make laws for the soul, it thereby meddles in matters belonging to the jurisdiction of God alone, and such interference can only prove injurious, if not ruinous, to souls. This we will make so plain that any one can grasp it. Whenever human laws are imposed upon souls, to compel these to believe in accordance with the dictates of those imposing them, it can surely not be the word nor the will of God; no, God's word is not in such enforcements. But if God's word is not in it, it is, to say the least, uncertain whether God wants it so or not; indeed, one may be sure that anything of that kind will not please him. For it is his will that our faith shall be purely and solely based upon his divine word. Hence it follows, that when secular powers undertake to legislate for the souls of men, they will simply press them away from God and into ruin by any such actual requirements which aim to compel them to believe that which can never be pleasing to God, just as though it was right and acceptable in his sight. For whoever countenances and believes that to be right and good which is unjust, or at least uncertain of his divine approval, denies the truth; and as God is the truth, he denies God himself. No one shall or can rightfully assume control over a soul in any way whatever, unless he is able to show and lead her the right way to heaven. But this, no human being of himself is able to do; in fact, no one can do it but God only. Anyway, no man has power over the soul; for no man can either kill it, or make it alive if dead; he can neither take it to heaven nor consign it to hell. Now I want to know, how much wits there can be about that man who presumes to give commands in any domain where he has not the least authority? Who would not consider him insane, that could undertake, with the least expectation of its coming to pass accordingly, to command the moon to shine whenever he wished? Besides that, it may be seen from this: Every power rightfully can, ought, and may exercise authority only, where she is able to see, estimate, judge, change, recognize, and improve. For what kind of court could that be, which would blindly judge in matters that cannot be perceived or ascertained by the senses? A judge must be very minutely conscious of the details in the case, if his judgment is to be sound, unbiased, and thorough; in short, one that will bring everything in the case to light. But the thoughts of the soul can be read by none but God; before him alone they are open; hence it is impossible and vain to compel any one to believe this or that by force of human laws. With all that, these blinded people do not see how utterly vain and impossible the thing is which they propose to do. For, however harshly they may legislate, however threateningly they may rage, they cannot bring people any farther than that they mechanically make them go through certain motions externally; for they cannot compel the heart, even though they rent themselves over it. It is a true saying that thought is free! Do I hear you object to this, because Peter and Paul enjoined upon us to “be subject unto the higher powers?” I answer: Your point is not well taken! The Scriptures speak in their own behalf. Paul (in Rom. 13:1) has reference to the legitimate power of authority or right. But you have already seen that no one but God can have authority over the soul. Hence Paul cannot mean for us to be subject to any power in matters wherein such power has no authority or right to act, from which it becomes plain that Paul is here speaking of temporal and external matters, which are to be regulated or set in order. This his words show most plainly and unmistakably. Peter aims at the same thing when he says: “Submit yourselves to every ordinance of man.” 1 Pet. 2:13. It is evident that no human ordinance can legislate to heaven, or dominate over the soul, for all human enactments are per se confined to this earth, limited to the exterior walk of men and their associations with one another; they concern matters in which men can see, recognize, judge, punish, or spare. All this our Saviour has with most excellent discrimination pithily comprehended in the words: “Render therefore unto Cæsar the things which are Cæsar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s.” Matt. 22:21. But, if imperial power extended into the realms and power of God, and were not separate and distinct therefrom, would Christ have made any such distinction as he here makes? Now, as already shown, the soul does not stand under the power of emperors, or human631 potentates of any kind; they can neither train nor lead it, can neither kill it nor make it alive, cannot bind or loose it, neither keep it nor set it free, which they surely must be able to do, if they have any legitimate God-given authority over it at all. Again: Peter says: “We ought to obey God rather than men” (Acts 5:29), by which he most plainly sets bounds to all earthly power or authority. For if we had to do all that the secular powers demand of us, such words would be vain. But perhaps you object on the ground that the secular power does not compel us to any particular belief, but prevents simply by external measures that any should be misled into false doctrines or practices. I reply: Work of that kind belongs to the church solely, and is intrusted to the same and its undershepherds by the Great Shepherd on high, but not to the rulers of the land. Indeed, the word of God itself must here enter the arena. If that cannot set them right and keep them from error in doctrine or practice, then surely can the secular arm of authority do it much less, even though the world should be filled with blood in the attempt. For in worldly matters it is just as little allowed as in things spiritual, to use violence, even though by that means wrong might be overcome, and right established. But how much more is it inadmissible in the far more exalted matters of spiritual concern, to use violence, without even having justice, not to say God's word in favor of such proceedings! God's word itself must enlighten the mind and the heart, and where this is allowed free course, errors will soon vanish, and light and truth reign supreme, both in doctrine and practice.—Translated for the REVIEW from the German, by A. Kunz.