AdventAI

SOCIETY AND ANARCHY.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 40., October 11, 1892

It is a suggestive thought that in this free republic, under this government of the people, in this age of progress and enlightenment, nothing stands between society and actual anarchy except the fear of the military power.

Yet such is the fact, and everybody should look at it squarely. In three of the oldest and greatest States of the Union the whole military force is required to preserve civilized society from disintegration, at the hands of organized savage bands, which need only the stimulation of success in their barbarous enterprise to draw to their assistance a vast horde of other savages, who would unite with them to tear down the pillars of the social structure.

It has been our pride and our boast in the past that law and order and liberty had here a sufficient defense in the law-abiding and liberty-loving spirit of the self-governed and governing people. European visitors to the United States are impressed most of all by the absence of the military uniforms so frequently encountered by them at home. After our great Civil war, the volunteer armies of both sides rapidly returned to peaceful pursuits. They were not soldiers by profession, but only soldiers for an emergency. Their natural taste and sphere were peaceful, and, therefore, the disbandment of the vast armies took place without difficulty. In a few months the sight of a military uniform became as rare as it had been before the beginning of hostilities. The Federal army shrank to petty proportions, and it was employed almost wholly in defending the western frontier against red savages. The putting aside of the military spirit was so complete after the special occasion for its display had ceased, that even the military organizations of the States languished at that period. The people were tired of guns and gunpowder, military uniforms and martial music, and hence the maintenance of effective militia by the States has been a task requiring much effort since 1865.

Our great communities are distinguished from the European also by the comparative numerical weakness of their police forces. Order has been maintained with less show of authority and with less display of physical power. More confidence has been manifested in the self-control and law-abiding spirit of the people. Riotous ebullitions have occurred, of course, when the small part of a community not under the restraint of reason, have given vent to their savage instincts; but such unorganized and feverish outbursts have been easily repressed. They were not dangerous symptoms. They indicated no chronic and deep-seated social disease. They were simply the temporary aberrations of a few in communities generally sane. They followed no method, and had no settled purpose.

The riotous insurrections of these days are radically different. They are not sudden and unpremeditated explosions, but organized movements, with leaders whose sole function and business is to conduct them. They are carefully planned for the purpose of bringing into alliance with them all related and affiliated bodies in the wide system of organized labor; and they are undertaken not merely to get the immediate advantage of increased wages, but also to force all labor into the system. They are a part of a scheme to drive every workingman into combination with all other workingmen for purposes of offense and defense. Their aim is to strengthen and extend the organization which makes them powerful, so that it shall be resistless, whether by capital or by labor.

In other words, they are fighting for the control and domination of a reorganized social system. The great mass of their followers are honest and well-meaning men, but the policy of the leaders is rule or ruin; and for the furtherance of it they can always rely on lawless spirits in their own ranks, and on all the lawless elements of society outside of them. If, for instance, the rapine of the switchmen insurgents at Buffalo had not been stopped by military force, every ruffian in the town would have joined with them in the work of destruction; and thence the insurrection would have spread over the State, the labor unions affording it the nucleus of organization.

The ability of society to defend itself against such destructive forces by the exertion of military power is its only present security. That lesson has been taught in New York, Pennsylvania, and Tennessee. The day has come, alas! when even in this republic the guns of soldiers are necessary for the preservation of the social structure.

That is the fact to which the situation in three of the oldest and greatest States of the Union bears witness to-day. Society is forced to take up arms for its defense against anarchy.—N. Y. Sun.