AdventAI

HAVE WE CLAIMED TOO MUCH?

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 14., April 5, 1892

The Seventh-day Adventists have for years unhesitatingly put forth the claim that the change of the Sabbath from Saturday, the seventh day of the week, to Sunday, the first day of the week, is a change for which there is no scriptural authority; but that the change was made through the power and influence of an apostate church; namely, the Church of Rome.

We are aware that those who have never given this subject much attention may think that we have claimed more than we can prove; but in this statement we have the general facts of history in our favor, backed up by the unanimous testimony of the Roman Church. The Catholic Church has taken to itself the credit (if there is any credit in it) of this change of the Sabbath. They point to the entire absence of scriptural proof as one evidence, and to the historic acts of their church as the other, that they have wrought this change in the law of God. Catholics taunt Protestants with inconsistency in claiming the Bible to be their only rule of faith and practice, while at the same time, in this matter of Sunday observance, they deny the Scriptures, and tread in the footsteps of the “mother church.” As an illustrative proof of this, we insert an extract from a late number of the Catholic Mirror, published at Baltimore, Md., the center, as it were, of Catholicism in this country, and under the very eye of Cardinal Gibbons.

“THE ‘SABBATH QUESTION.’”

“Rev. Father M. O’Keefe, pastor at Towson, whose invincible controversial communications to the Mirror, under the nom de plume of ‘Senex,’ have given him a wide reputation, lectured for the sodality of St. Vincent’s church on Wednesday night on the ‘Sabbath Question.’ In this discourse, Father O’Keefe entered into a popular, though learned, examination of the Sabbath day as distinguished from Sunday. He showed that, up to Christ’s death, Saturday was the Sabbath, and that Christ himself observed Saturday as such. For thirty years after the death of Christ it was so kept. After proving that Scripture nowhere ordains any Sabbath but Saturday, Father O’Keefe demonstrated how Sunday became the Lord’s day of the Christian. The determination of the question, of course, brings prominently forward, the divine foundation of the Catholic Church, as opposed to the human organization of Protestantism. Father O’Keefe spoke in his peculiarly erudite, forcible, and lucid way.”

The above from the Mirror, should furnish food for serious thought to every Protestant. There is no question but that in this statement the Mirror is substantially correct. It can easily be verified by both church and secular history. The only flaw we can find in it is that the Sabbath was kept by the church much longer than one would infer from the above statement. But this does not matter. If Christ and the apostles and the church generally, kept it for thirty years after the resurrection; and we know this from the Scriptures (Matt. 24:20), then the obligation to keep it now should be apparent to every one who holds to the all-sufficiency of the Scriptures, as do professed Protestants. And the fact that the great mass of Protestants treat this important subject lightly, shows to what extent they themselves still are under the influence of Rome.

The power of Rome has reached far beyond the actual boundaries of the Catholic Church. It is prophetically said of her in the word of God, that “all nations have drunk of the wine of the wrath of her fornication,” or in other words, of her false doctrines. And again we read that “all the world wondered after the beast.” Rev. 18:3; 13:3. We see in the Protestant Church of to-day much to show the fulfillment of these words. Although the Protestant nations and churches have shaken off some of the shackles which the Roman Church once put upon all the Christian world, the galling signs of their former slavery yet remain in the government-established religions of the Old World, and everywhere in the unscriptural doctrines still retained in the churches which have separated themselves from her communion.

The observance of the Sunday Sabbath is a sign of religious slavery to Rome, a recognition of her power to do what she claims she has done and can do again,—to dispense with the commandments of Christ. To the Catholic, this subjection of Protestantism to “the church” is a matter of intense self-satisfaction, involving as it does the question of the “divine foundation of the Catholic Church, as opposed to the human organization of Protestantism.”

To Protestants, the consideration of the claim of the Catholic Church to have changed the Sabbath, backed up as it is by the concurrent predictions of Scripture (Dan. 7:25) and facts of history, should lead them to consider, whether the Reformation, begun so nobly in the sixteenth century, has yet progressed so far as to eliminate from the reformed churches all the errors with which the body of the early church was overwhelmed by its fusion with paganism, from which union arose the “man of sin.”

The Reformation began with the then latest assumption of Rome, the power to sell indulgences to sin. It soon spread to image worship and other doctrines so vital to Romish superstition, that a separation from Rome could not be avoided. It seems to have been the design of God that the work of reformation should begin at the latest corrupt practice of Rome, and work back over her crooked and self-exalted course, until the work of reformation shall be complete. At the coming of Christ there will be a people on the earth who have so fully cast aside every “Babylonish garment,” that they will neither worship the beast nor his image nor receive his mark in their forehead or in their hand. Rev. 14:9, 10. Such a people will keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus. Verse 12.

We believe in the work of Protestantism as opposed to the dogmas of the Roman Church. And while the body has proved recreant to its trust and has almost ceased to protest, and many like the children of Israel, look back with longing eyes to the Egypt left behind, we believe the spirit of the Reformers still survives in those who, in the proclamation of the “third angel’s message” (Rev. 14:9–12), exalt the commandments of God above the decrees of an apostate church. May our work along these lines of reform be as unmistakable as is the occasion which calls it forth. M. E. K.