[The following article, under this heading, is from the September number of the Spectator, London. The use of the word “modern,” would imply that the editor regards what has recently taken place, as an outburst and strange phase of selfishness which is peculiar to these last days. This is true; and it therefore becomes a striking verification of the prediction by Paul that “in the last days perilous times shall come, for men shall be lovers of their own selves.”—Ed.]
It is frequently alleged by well-meaning men that the world is now governed by pity and feeling and consideration for the weak, that the maintenance of fleets and armaments indicates an unwarrantable distrust of neighboring nations, and that the maintenance of a strong police is a great and unnecessary expenditure. We wish all those who believe these smooth things would carefully study the case of the “Normannia’s” passengers as reported in recent telegrams. The “Normannia” arrived in New York with cholera on board, and was placed in quarantine, that is, was compelled to remain in the harbor, without communication with the land, in complete isolation. After the healthy passengers had endured extreme misery, the governor of New York, a humane and wide-minded man, proposed that Fire Island, an islet opposite Long Island, with a large hotel on it, should be purchased as a quarantine station, and the passengers be landed there where they could have some comfort, freedom of motion, and immunity from the danger of infection. He himself purchased the island and the hotel, the healthy passengers were transferred to a small coasting steamer, the “Cepheus,” and it was supposed that their sufferings from imprisonment, at all events, would be happily terminated. Those who thought so, however, mistook their epoch. The reign of the “law of love” has only commenced for those whose sufferings disturb the comfort of the lookers-on. The inhabitants of the shore of Long Island, which is behind Fire Island, rose in arms to prevent anybody from the “Cepheus” landing on the island. They threatened to drown the officer appointed by the governor to look after the passengers, and when implored to allow only the old women and children to land, sullenly refused. Mr. McPherson, a New Jersey senator of the United States, appealed to them in the name of God. “I appeal to you in the name of God,” urged the senator, “not to be longer led on to heartless cruelty by this attorney, but to give your consent to the women and children being taken from the boat, where they have nothing to eat, and no place to sleep in, where the common decencies of life can no longer be observed, and where the surroundings are foul from sea-sickness. Before you answer, think what will be done. Don’t bring everlasting disgrace upon your names. Be men!”
The appeal was in vain, and although the crowd was assured by competent health officers that there was nothing to fear, they preferred the sufferings of others, which they fully realized, to the smallest modicum of risk to their own persons; and it was not until they were overawed by the arrival of the militia, that they left the island to the unfortunate passengers. There was no pity for the feeble, while for the sick there was only abhorrence.
This selfishness is not confined to America. There is hardly a country of southern Europe where sickness, if it is of an infectious character, is not regarded with angry loathing, leading often to active cruelty; while in Hungary the peasants openly declare that they will inflict death, rather than incur the risks of it for their wives and children. Even in many places in Germany, the people absolutely refuse the sick admittance, and drive out crowds of Russian Jews to starve or perish beyond the frontier, because sickness may be among them. Nor are they wholly exempt from the same selfishness even here. We do not refuse admittance into hospitals, but after moaning loudly over the oppressions practiced on the Russian Jews, we, to avoid their competition as well as to avoid their disease, take advantage of the first excuse to declare that they shall not enter our ports. The “law of love” in our minds applies to any but the dangerously miserable. They are below the scope of Christian charity.
The law educates as well as coerces, and the people of Fire Island, who became humane under the coercion of soldiers, will forever after regard their inhumanity with a certain distaste as a tendency which they are bound to keep down. Their natural instinct was to shoot the weak rather than expose themselves to any risk of danger. Man in “a state of nature” is an exceedingly dangerous brute, quite capable, if his father has got scarlet fever, of shooting him down “to prevent the spread of infection;” that is, in fact, to keep it from himself.