SHOULD SABBATH-KEEPERS ALSO KEEP SUNDAY?

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 25, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 42.

Read the full edition

SHOULD SABBATH-KEEPERS ALSO KEEP SUNDAY?

BY JOHN M. HOPKINS.
(Chatfield, Minn.)
In other words, should Sabbath-keepers, in order to avoid the scoffs of the world, and the persecutions inflicted because of violating the Sunday laws, cease to labor on Sunday? This is not a question of modern times only. While it is coming to the front in some localities, and while some teach that such a course is advisable, it is not new.
Respecting Sunday legislation in the fourth century, I read in the “The Two Republics,” pp. 320, 321:—
“At every step in the course of the apostasy, at every step taken in adopting the forms of sun worship, and against the adoption and the observance of Sunday itself, there had been constant protest by all real Christians. Those who remained faithful to Christ and to the truth of the pure word of God observed the Sabbath of the Lord according to the commandment, and according to the word of God which sets forth the Sabbath as the sign by which the Lord, the Creator of the heavens and the earth, is distinguished from all other gods. These accordingly protested against every phase and form of sun worship. Others compromised, especially in the East, by observing both Sabbath and Sunday.”
I am sorry that in this respect, as in many others, the history of the fourth century is being repeated. Certainly it is well termed a compromise, a compromise with the beast and his image. The command of God is, “Six days shalt thou labor.” And is it not a weak, time-serving, man-fearing, God-distrusting and dishonoring spirit to yield and compromise with the enemies of God’s truth by observing Sunday, after having kept the Sabbath? Nor was this evil confined to the fourth century.
“In the conclusion of the sixth century, Pope Gregory exhorted the people of Rome to ‘expiate on the day of our Lord’s resurrection what was remissly done for the six days before.’ In the same epistle this pope condemned a class of men at Rome who advocated the strict observance of both the Sabbath and the Sunday, styling them the preachers of antichrist. This shows the intolerant feeling of the papacy toward the Sabbath, even when joined with the strict observance of Sunday. It also shows that there were Sabbath-keepers even in Rome itself as late as the seventh century, although so far bewildered by the prevailing darkness that they joined with its observance a strict abstinence from labor on Sunday.”—Andrews’s “History of the Sabbath,” p. 376.
After speaking of various English Sabbath-keeping ministers and churches of the seventeenth century, of their trials and persecutions, and lastly of their weakened condition, the same writer says:—
“To what cause shall we assign this painful fact? It is not because their adversaries were able to confute their doctrine; for the controversial works on both sides still remain, and speak for themselves. It is not that they lacked men of piety and of learning; for God gave them these, especially in the seventeenth century. Nor is it that fanaticism sprang up and disgraced the cause; for there is no record of anything of this kind. They were cruelly persecuted, but the period of their persecution was that of their greatest prosperity. Like Moses’s bush, they stood unconsumed in the burning fire. The prostration of the Sabbath cause in England is due to none of these things. The Sabbath was wounded in the house of its friends. They took upon themselves the responsibility, after a time, of making the Sabbath of no practical importance, and of treating its violation as no very serious transgression of the law of God. Doubtless they hoped to win men to Christ and his truth by this course; but, instead of this, they simply lowered the standard of divine truth into the dust. The Sabbath-keeping ministers assumed the pastoral care of first-day churches, in some cases as their sole charge; in others, they did this in connection with the oversight of Sabbatarian churches. The result need surprise no one; as these Sabbath-keeping ministers and churches said to all men, in thus acting, that the fourth commandment might be broken with impunity, the people took them at their word. Mr. Crosby, a first-day historian, sets this matter in a clear light:—
“If the seventh day ought to be observed as the Christian Sabbath, then all congregations that observe the first day as such must be Sabbath breakers. . . . I must leave those gentlemen on the contrary side to their own sentiments; and to vindicate the practice of becoming pastors to a people whom in their conscience they must believe to be breakers of the Sabbath.”—pp. 491, 492.
We wonder how any one having an open Bible and a knowledge of its sacred truths, could ever observe two days. We wonder more how any one living under the sound of the third angel’s message, when the image to the beast is being formed, when in many places the dragon voice is being heard, and its cruel, persecuting power is being felt, can “compromise” this solemn question. But so it was in the fourth, seventh, and seventeenth centuries, and so it is now.
The man who keeps two days really keeps no day. No one can truly keep the Sabbath unto the Lord unless his heart is wholly given to the Lord. It is a sign “that ye may know that I am the Lord that doth sanctify you.” The Lord does not sanctify by halves; he must have the whole heart or nothing. There can be no room there for fear, for “perfect love casteth out fear.” There can be no room there for the beast or his image; for “no man can serve two masters: for either he will hate the one and love the other, or else he will hold to the one, and despise the other. Ye cannot serve God and mammon.” Job says, “If I beheld the sun when it shined, or the moon walking in brightness; and my heart hath been secretly enticed, or my mouth hath kissed my hand: this also were an iniquity to be punished by the Judge: for I should have denied the God that is above.” Job 31: 26–28.
That is it. Kissing one hand to God and the other to the sun, is virtually saying, “Good Lord and good Baal.” Such a course is a dishonor to the holy cause of God. It weakens the influence of those who thus do. They cannot really estimate and appreciate the importance of the work of God for this time. Their hearts are divided, and their work will be a failure. In the language of Elijah, we would say, “How long halt ye between two opinions? if the Lord be God, follow him: but if Baal [the sun], then follow him.” 1 Kings 18: 21.