THE EVILS RESULTING FROM THE IMMORTAL SOUL THEORY.
By M. E. K.
THE doctrine of the immortality of the soul has been the fruitful cause of many other errors, which at various times and in different countries have been adopted and believed by mankind. The belief in the transmigration of souls, which forms the main theme of Buddhism, is based upon this doctrine. The barbarous custom of burning the wife with her deceased husband, which was so generally practised by some of the people of India, and which was kept up until suppressed by the strong arm of English law in 1829, was done in order that the husband might have the attendance of his wife in the other world,—something they would never have thought of doing only for their belief in the immortality of the soul. Slaves were often put to death upon the death of their master, for the same reason. Had not people believed this doctrine, the Mormon imposture would never have found so many willing hearers. The communications which compose the Book of Mormon, are claimed by the Mormons to have been revealed to Joseph Smith by Moroni, a prophet who once lived in America, but who died hundreds of years ago. Spiritualism, with its foul brood of immortalities and affinities, comes from the same source. Among the Catholics this doctrine establishes purgatory; and prayers for and to the dead as practised by that church, are the inevitable result of such belief. Among the so-called evangelical churches, this doctrine has been for some time developing its legitimate fruit. The doctrine of the immortality of the soul, and the resulting beliefs that souls go to heaven or hell at death has, in the minds of the masses of the people, undermined the doctrine of the Saviour's second advent and the literal resurrection of the dead, and robbed them of their glory. These grand Bible doctrines which are both the inspiration and the hope of the church, are rarely mentioned by the popular preachers of the age, and by many they are entirely ignored. A bishop of the Methodist Episcopal Church has written a book entitled “Beyond the Grave,” in which he denies the resurrection of the body. This book, which a hundred years ago would not have been tolerated for a day by that church, is now allowed to be printed by the Methodist Book Concern, and no serious protest that we are aware of has yet been made. It will be seen from the above that we have good and sufficient reasons for saying that but for this doctrine, there would be no burning of living people as a religious duty, no Mormonism, no Spiritualism, no purgatorial fires, from whence men only escape by the generous donations of money paid into the coffers of a crafty priesthood, and no denial of the true hope of the church, “the glorious appearing of the great God and our Saviour Jesus Christ.” Titus 2:13. The great errors we have mentioned have certainly grown out of this doctrine; and it is as useless for ministers of the gospel to declaim against Spiritualism, Mormonism, purgatory, etc., while still advocating the foundation upon which all these delusions rest, as it would be to try to destroy a vigorous tree by nipping off a few of its leaves. The immortal soul theory is a bad tree; root and fruit are alike, and the fruit cannot be made good while the root is bad; and the only true and effective way of destroying it is the plan used as an illustration by John the Baptist: “And now also the ax is laid unto the root of the trees: therefore every tree which bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire.” Matt. 3:10. If this plan should be adopted, there might become hope that this tree of evil fruit would die. But alas! there is small prospect of such thorough work, and it will doubtless thrive and grow until the end. Not only does it thrive along the old lines of error, but this doctrine seems capable of multiplying new forms. An instance of this kind has lately been brought to our notice. Among some of the Baptists of the southern States, there has arisen another fruit of the immortal soul theory, known as the “two-soul theory!” According to this new idea, the original soul in a man is never regenerated, but the Lord puts a new soul into the individual, the old soul still remaining. These two souls in one body do not live together very amicably, and a battle is the result, each trying to expel the other. This struggle they call the Christian warfare; and they believe this struggle is carried on, each soul trying to expel the other, until the new soul entirely defeats the old soul, and utterly destroys it. We gather these facts from the Baptist Gleaner. Absurd as the above theory is, it is scarcely more so than the one-soul theory as it is generally believed. If a man has an immortal entity, separate, distinct, and independent of the body, why cannot he have two of them? If we accept the statements of those who have undertaken to tell what a soul is, they describe it as being so minute that its size would be no serious objection why a man might not have a million all at one time! If it should be objected against the two-soul theory that it would not be right thus to thrust a pure soul right from heaven into a defiled and sinful body, we would remark that the same objection holds good against the commonly received doctrine. We can ask our immortal soul friends several questions, which they find very difficult to answer: 1. Are these souls made by natural causes, or by a direct act of the Creator's power? 2. Did they have a pre-existence, or were they made expressly for each person, just when needed? 3. Do souls come by natural descent, or, in other words, was John Smith's soul descended from the souls of his father and mother, and if not, how is John Smith's soul related to his parents' souls; and how can the consequences of Adam's transgressions by right have any effect upon him, or how can he be redeemed by the blood of Christ, who died only for Adam and his posterity? The two-soul theory may involve serious difficulties, but we cannot see how they can be much greater than those which inevitably follow the popular theory of one soul in every body. The doctrine taught in the Bible, unlike the one we have been considering, is one of reason and common sense. Man as a whole is the soul. He thinks, reasons, and acts for himself. He needs no other entity, great or small, to think or act for him. The consequences of Adam's sin came down to him by direct and undisputable line of descent; and for the same reason he is included in the salvation which is offered to the fallen race. In death he is unconscious, and needs no help of wife or servant. No prayers can reach him, and he needs not the prayers of the living. He cannot communicate with those who were his friends on earth, nor does666 he feel any purgatorial fires. His love, hatred, and envy are now perished (see Eccl. 9:6), and not until the voice of the archangel shall raise the dead, will he know or care aught for all that is taking place on the earth. Job 14:21. Then, and not till then, will the good be rewarded, and the bad receive their punishment. “Thou shalt be recompensed at the resurrection of the just.” “For the Son of man shall come in the glory of his Father with his angels; and then he shall reward every man according to his works.” Matt. 16:27.