The following is the third of a series of communications from J. M. Foster, of Cincinnati, Ohio, together with our reply, the beginning of which was an attempted answer to our twenty-five “questions for Sunday-keepers” which was noticed in the REVIEW of Sept. 10. The nature of the second communication and reply may be gleaned from the present one.
616 Freeman Ave., Cincinnati, O., Sept. 25, ’89.
Editor Review and Herald: Your letter has been received, and read with interest. I do not think your proposition, that in the nature of things the seventh day and not the first is to be observed [is correct]. Those who keep the first day are just as healthy, their minds are as active, and their soul-life is as vigorous as those who keep the seventh day. That proves that nature requires one-seventh part of time, but does not specify the day. Hence we infer that the particular day to be observed is a positive enactment of the Lawgiver, and may be altered at his pleasure, without disturbing nature. It would unhinge nature to change the ordinance from one-seventh to one-sixth or one-tenth. Nature calls for one-seventh. But it does not disturb nature to change from the seventh to the first day. Hence the day to be kept is moral positive.
As to persecution, I do not think there need be any great suffering by our seventh-day brethren. In a republic, the majority rules. The majority believe in keeping the first day. They have a right to keep that day undisturbed. But if a portion of the people are allowed to work on that day, the rest are disturbed in their worship. The law does not compel any one to observe the first day as a holy day, but only to abstain from work because it disturbs the public generally in the enjoyment of their right. The only way for the seventh-day people is to deny themselves work on the first day.
I belong to the Reformed Presbyterian Church. We hold that it is wrong to exercise our political privileges under an immoral constitution, and so we deny ourselves the political privileges of voting or holding office in this country. So our seventh-day brethren will have to deny themselves the privilege of working on the first day of the week. They can afford to do that for conscience’s sake. I am sure that if the same kindly spirit that you discover in your letters prevails among your people, there will be no difficulty in this direction. It seems to me the seventh-day people should favor a Sabbath law. In the United States there are 2,000,000 unwilling Sabbath toilers. They work seven days in the week because compelled to do so on pain of losing their position. You, I take it, think this is wrong. They are deprived of their right to keep one-seventh part of time for rest. Why should you not advocate a measure to secure for them their right? Instead of opposing all Sabbath law, why do you not plead for a Sabbath law from your own stand-point? That would be consistent as it seems to me. With kind regards,
J. M. Foster.
THE REPLY.
Battle Creek, Mich., Sept. 29, 1889.
J. M. Foster, Cincinnati, O.
Dear Sir: Yours dated Sept. 25, duly received. Let me correct a false impression you seem to be under. I am not the editor of the REVIEW AND HERALD. Eld. U. Smith occupies that position.
According to the fourth commandment, God’s example is the foundation for Sabbath observance. He rested the seventh day. In the nature of things this day, and this only, is the proper day for the Sabbath as a memorial of creation. No other day can be kept and follow the example of the Creator. You said you observed the first day as a memorial of the resurrection. In my last I called for the proof that it had ever been divinely set apart for this purpose. You fail to give it. I called your attention to the fact that baptism is the appropriate and divinely appointed memorial of the resurrection, citing Rom. 6:3, 4 and Col. 2:12 as proof. This you fail to notice in any way whatever. I press this point. In your change of day you rob creation of its memorial, and give the resurrection two. I should like to see you come up and meet this argument squarely.
In your last you say, “It would unhinge nature to change the ordinance from one-seventh to one-sixth or one-tenth. . . . But it does not disturb nature to change from the seventh day.” I should like to ask how such a change could take place and not interfere with the one-seventh arrangement? When the change took place, there must have been a one-eighth or two-eighth proportion adopted. So, according to your own idea, nature must have been unhinged. Of course, God could change both the day and the proportion; but I see little good to result from a discussion of that point when there is no evidence that he has ever done either. It is certain that God has made no such distinction in his moral law of ten commandments as you make, calling one “moral natural” and another “moral positive.” He has simply shown that they define our duties to him and our fellow-men, and that he who breaks one is guilty of all. Matt. 22:37-40; James 2:10.
In my last I admitted your right to keep the day that is in accordance with your religious convictions. I claimed the same right for myself. Then I asked why you have any more right to petition Congress to pass a law compelling me to observe the day you think should be kept, than I have to ask for a law compelling you to observe the day I believe should be regarded, and wherein one law would savor any more of justice than the other. These propositions you have carefully avoided. Now, I should like to see you take them up, and give a clear and explicit answer. I challenge you, in the light of these interrogatories, to harmonize your compulsory Sunday-law theory with the Golden Rule. Right here, Mr. Foster, is betrayed the unchristian character of the National Reform Association, of which you say you are a secretary. You are in favor of doing to others that which you would not wish to have others do to you.
You endeavor to pass this vital point all by, by saying, “I do not think there need be any great suffering by our seventh-day brethren.” No; certainly not, if they will give up their rights, convictions, and opinions, and surrender all unconditionally to Sunday-keepers. This is just what the bigoted and intolerant papists thought of the Protestants in the days of the most violent persecution. They did not need to die. All they needed to do was to renounce their belief, and comply with popish rules and regulations. That was all. When they put them on the rack and tortured them until almost dead, they told them if they died under the torture they would be guilty of taking their own lives. All they had to do was to yield and renounce. Yours is a papal argument, Mr. Foster, through and through. You say, “The only way for seventh-day people is to deny themselves work on the first day.” That is it; just yield. But seventh-day people will not have to deny themselves work on that day. You will do that for them.
Again you say, “In a republic the majority rules.” I am forced to ask you whether you profess to be governed in your decisions by Christian or political principles. If the former, then I wish to ask you if you consider that might makes right. If the ruling of the majority is always right, why are you finding fault with this republican Government, and seeking to remodel, amend, and enact laws in it? Is it the majority in this wicked world you are seeking to be with? Read Matt. 7:13, 14. Unchristian again in your argument, Mr. F.
You continue: “The majority believe in keeping the first day. They have a right to keep that day undisturbed.” They have no more right to keep that day undisturbed than seventh-day observers have to keep the seventh day undisturbed. No one has a right to unnecessarily disturb the observers of either day in their worship. Why have first-day keepers more rights than seventh-day keepers? You make laws to protect the strong, while you totally ignore the weak. I had supposed that laws were made to protect the weak against the strong. Sunday-keepers are acting very selfishly in this.
You say you belong to the Reformed Presbyterian Church, and hold that it is wrong to exercise your political privileges under an immoral constitution, and so deny yourselves the political privilege of voting or holding office in this country. “So,” you say, “our seventh-day brethren will have to deny themselves the privilege of working on the first day of the week.” I do not like your comparison. I can see no parallel whatever between the two circumstances. In the first case you have the privilege, but deny yourselves the right. In the second, we will not have the privilege, and somebody else will deny us the right. You put it, “Our seventh-day brethren will have to deny themselves the privilege of working on the first day.” But that is a crooked way to state it, to say the least. In the first place, they will not have the privilege, and in the second it will be somebody else that will deny it them.
Just before this you were arguing in favor of the ruling of the majority, and everybody’s being made to comply. I believe in this, but not for all things. But the majority believe in voting and holding office. Now, suppose we pass a law that everybody must vote (as you say all will have to keep the first day); and, irrespective of Mr. Foster’s religious convictions in the matter, we compel him to cast his vote or hold an office in this country. How would this comport with your ideas of the majority’s ruling? And yet it is an exact parallel to your theory of Sunday-keeping. This would only interfere with the religious convictions of the Reformed Presbyterians, and they are not half so large a body as Seventh-day Adventists. Of all people to talk about majorities’ ruling, I should think they would be the last.
You are greatly astray in saying there are “2,000,000 unwilling Sabbath toilers” in this country, and that they are “deprived of their right to keep one-seventh of time for rest.” In the first place, many of them are not so unwilling as you might try to make it appear. If they had very strong conscience or determination in the matter, they wouldn’t do it; for there isn’t a law in the land compelling them to do so. In the second place, they are not deprived of their right to rest. They can exercise that right whenever they choose, and not be fined nor sent to jail for it either.
But you say they are “compelled to do so on pain of losing their position.” Ah! that is it. You are going to have them get into the kingdom without its costing them anything. You are going to take all the crosses out of the way, and have them make money by being saved! Well, that is not the gospel as I have learned it. I have been taught, and I teach, that a man should do right regardless of consequences. My Saviour says, “If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me.” Seventh-day Adventists deny themselves the opportunity of engaging in the majority of the common pursuits of life, in order to live in accordance with their religious convictions. They not only have to lose their positions, but are forever debarred from securing many others on account of their faith. But they make no fuss about this. They ask for no law compelling others to retain them or engage them and still allow them their day of rest. They willingly deny themselves thus for the sake of what they hold as truth. But you want to relieve Sunday-keepers from all such embarrassment. But let me tell you candidly, Mr. Foster, if these Sunday toilers haven’t enough moral stamina and love for truth and right to live up to their conscientious convictions, I seriously doubt whether they have enough to carry them through to the kingdom of God. What do you think about it? Now, wouldn’t you better go to preaching to them, converting them, and strengthening their moral courage, than be electioneering around over the country to enact laws that they may “be carried to the skies on flowery beds of ease”? Teach them Matt. 6:33; 16:25; 18:8.
I hope you will examine these things in candor, and in view of a just God and a future judgment. As you profess to be a minister of the gospel, I cannot see why you are so concerned over political matters. The apostle says, “Seek those things which are above.” Unless you come out and accept my views, or come up and meetp. 675 them squarely, I promise you this is the longest letter I shall ever write you.
Yours truly, W. A. Colcord.