AdventAI

CONFESSION

By H. A. St. John

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 43., October 29, 1889

BY ELD. H. A. ST. JOHN.

(San Francisco, Cal.)

PROPOSITION I.—The object of confession is to secure pardon, or justification.

God requires it as a means to this end. 1 John 1:9. There can be no genuine reformation without it.

PROP. II.—All valid confession must necessarily embrace a full purpose to abandon the practice of all known sin, henceforth and forever.

Certainly no one could believe for a moment that a confession would be valid, that is, meet the mind of God, if the confessor retained a purpose to continue the practice of any sin whatsoever. Indeed, heart-felt confession is not at all compatible with such purpose.

PROP. III.—All valid confession must embrace the SPIRIT of restitution, and the WORK of restitution to the extent of ability.

Many repentant sinners find in the category of sins to be confessed, some sins of defrauding their fellow-men. They will, if truly penitent, have the spirit of restitution, which will be revealed in the work of restitution to the extent of their ability. If they have not the ability, as is frequently the case, undoubtedly God will accept the will for the deed, and abundantly pardon. But as all pardon is conditional, the Lord might give his child the ability at a subsequent date from pardon, and require the restitution.

PROP. IV.—All sins known to the individual must be confessed to God in order to forgiveness.

All sin is against God, or is a transgression of his law, hence must be confessed to him. Some sins should be confessed to our fellow-men also. But no confession of sin to man alone is valid, as such confession does not cover the entire ground of the wrong. God is sinned against, and must be confessed to.

PROP. V.—Secret sins, known only to God and the individual, and not against another person, should be confessed to God only.

Why should they go farther, or be known farther? As before stated, the object of confession is to secure pardon. Our fellow-men cannot forgive our secret sins not against them, if they should try; then why should they know them? Some say the open confession of secret sins to fellow-mortals brings humiliation. This we do not believe; but suppose it were so, where are we required to confess our sins in order to secure humility? Is not this changing the object of confession? Some say that to confess known sin is not humiliating. Then it is never humiliating to confess to God; for all sin is known to him, and is recorded, before confessed. Our neighbor knows we have wronged him. We know he is tried with us. Now, because he thus knows and feels, is there no humility on our part in making the proper confession? Absurd to say there is not! But, after all, is there not a mistake as to the thing received by open confession of secret sins to our fellow-men? Is it not degradation instead of humiliation that is received?

Furthermore, it would seem preferable if we were going to make confession of secret sins to fellow-mortals, to make such confession to a Catholic priest rather than to a Protestant minister. You ask, Why?—Well, the Catholic priest is under the most solemn obligation to keep such confessions profoundly secret, whereas the Protestant minister, not thus bound, is very liable to publish your confessions to others, and thus make a bad matter worse.