THE INTERPRETATION OF SCRIPTURE.
By L. A. S.
THE true method of interpreting the language of Scripture seems always to have been a question of dispute and perplexity to theologians. However obvious its meaning may appear, the liberty of every one to use his own judgment, and construe its language accordingly, has left room for the rise of innumerable shades of religious belief, until it is sarcastically asserted by some who are skeptically inclined, that this “beautiful law of construction,” as they call it, enables one to get out of the Bible any meaning he may desire. But while each individual has liberty to interpret the Scriptures for himself, there are certain considerations which may and should guide him in his search for Bible truth, and which forbid his construing it merely to suit his purpose or his fancy. Since the beginning of the Christian era three different modes of interpretation have at various times, found favor in the Church. These may be named and defined as follows: (1) grammatical interpretation, which is mainly an investigation of the sense of the words; (2) allegorical interpretation, which proceeds on the supposition that the words of the Bible have, lying back of their simpler sense, a hidden meaning; and (3) dogmatical interpretation, which affirms that the Bible must be explained in harmony with the dogmas of the681 Church. The two latter, though widely different in principle, have at times been able to exist together in comparative harmony, but between these and the first method there has been an unceasing conflict. Each of the three has its representatives at the present time. The allegorical method finds adherents in the Swedenborgians and other peculiar sects; the Roman Catholic Church stands as the greatest champion of dogmatic interpretation; and among the various Protestant sects are chiefly to be found those who make the Scripture language itself, in its simple and grammatical sense, superior to all else as a basis for religious faith. Yet among the latter sects the dogmatic principle has never been wholly lacking, and has at times been very conspicuous. The dogmatic Protestant is not at the present day a difficult being to find. He is the one who says, when asked to define his position with reference to a certain doctrine, “I am nothing if not orthodox. Orthodoxy teaches this doctrine; therefore I believe it.” Call the attention of such an one to whatever texts of Scripture you may, he will twist and construe them to suit the view which the Church has said is correct. He naturally becomes an expert in “getting around” Scripture texts by the use of forced and improbable constructions. In the early centuries of the Christian era, when the “mystery of iniquity” had begun to obscure the pure light of the gospel, allegorical interpretation flourished, as is witnessed by the enigmatical and voluminous writings of “the fathers”; but as “the Church” increased in numbers and power under the further workings of this “mystery,” when the multiplicity of opinions began to be consolidated, and the authoritative voice of her councils to be heard formulating her universal dogmas, a new principle obtained pre-eminence, which was thus defined: “Since the Holy Scriptures, on account of their depth, are not understood by all in the same manner; but their sentences are understood differently by different persons, so that they might seem to admit as many meanings as there are men, we must well take care that within the pale of the Catholic Church we hold fast what has been believed everywhere, always, and by all.” Following out this principle, it was in due time decreed: “Let no one venture to interpret the Holy Scriptures in a sense contrary to that which the Holy Mother Church has held, and does hold, and which has the power of deciding what is the true sense and the right interpretation of the Holy Scriptures.” This was the principle which Luther and his associates met when they began the great work of antagonism to Rome, and which they successfully combatted by bringing home to the consciences of the people the simple and plain declarations of God’s word. Grammatical interpretation was revived, and as a means of exposing the heresies of Rome, was held by the Reformers in high honor. But in due time the Protestant churches themselves, having become powerful in numbers and influence, and following the example of Rome in imagining themselves the repositories of all religious truth, began to look upon grammatical interpretation as a dangerous adversary to their own dogmas, and it was again placed under the ban; but it still continued to be brought into conflict with dogmatical interpretation whenever an advance move was made in the discovery of Bible truth. It was the chief weapon in the hands of the later reformers, as it had been in those of their predecessors, for combatting the spiritual errors of their time. The great conflict between truth and error is in active progress to-day; and in the final work of reform which is going to the world, grammatical interpretation of God’s word is again arrayed against the dogmatical theology of the popular churches. The third angel’s message calls upon men to forsake all those doctrines, however honored by the Church, which the plain statements of the Bible do not support. It brings before them no mystical, incomprehensible rendering of God’s word, but the clear and forcible utterances of that word against the spiritual errors of the times. It declares that the word of God has a comprehensible meaning, and that it means just what it says. Reason supports this clear testimony of history in favor of grammatical interpretation. Considered as a revelation from God to finite man, it must be full of the deepest meaning, so expressed as to be adapted to the circumstances in which he is placed. It cannot be supposed that it comes to him as a mighty riddle, for the solution of which he has been left to drift without a compass on the sea of his own fancy. We are commanded to “search the Scriptures,” to understand them, and to order our lives by their teaching; and we shall certainly be held accountable for charging God with the folly of having made his word so ambiguous as to teach all doctrines, and so unintelligible as to render its study a profitless undertaking.