AdventAI

SOME SUNDAY PROPS.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 45., November 15, 1892

In the Detroit Tribune of Oct. 3, 1892, appears a synopsis of a discourse by Rev. J. B. Johnson, against the Sabbath and in favor of Sunday. He endeavors to prove that the Sabbath was a local matter, designed for the Jews alone, and not for the Gentiles at all. To prove this he quotes Col. 2:14: “Blotting out the handwriting of ordinances that was against us, which was contrary to us, and took it out of the way, nailing it to his cross.” On this he comments, “called ‘handwriting,’ because written by God himself on tables of stone.”

But the ten commandments are never said to have been written by the hand of God, but by the finger of God, and hence cannot be called “handwriting” in any sense. Other statutes were given through Moses, and are expressly said to have been given by the hand of Moses, and so could properly be called “handwriting.”

But Paul is careful to qualify his statement still further by saying, “handwriting of ordinances.” Were the ten commandments ordinances? Was it a mere ordinance not to have any other gods before Jehovah? not to swear, lie, steal, murder, and commit adultery? Were all these things only ordinances?

But still further, Paul adds that all this handwriting of ordinances was “against us” and “contrary to us.” Does Mr. J. consider it against him, that is, as interfering with his best interests and his right relation to God, to be required not to steal, kill, nor commit adultery? Is freedom from these restraints the liberty he hopes for under the gospel? It is, if his argument is good for anything.

Then he sails up to what he evidently thinks a triumphant conclusion: “Let no man judge you in respect of the Sabbath days [spelled with a big ‘S,’ though Paul doesn’t refer to the weekly Sabbath at all]. ‘No man has a right,’ he indignantly exclaims, ‘to judge us in regard to the Sabbath days, yet some people wish to judge us because we keep the Lord’s day instead of the Hebrew Sabbath.’”

By “Lord’s day” he of course means Sunday, which is not the Lord’s day. But if we must not judge him for keeping that day, how about his people judging us for not keeping it? Will not the rule work both ways? But religionists do judge us, and not only judge us, but condemn us, and fine us, and imprison us, and chain-gang us, for not keeping Sunday. And yet Mr. J., with all his indignation against “judging,” has no word of condemnation for this treatment. Verily it makes a wonderful difference on which side the judging happens to be.

Then, like every man who wishes to break down the Sabbath, Mr. J. hastens to Gal. 3:24: “Wherefore the law was our school-master to bring us unto Christ.” And “as we are not now under the school-master,” he says, “‘nor any part of the school-master, how then can we be under the Sabbath law?’ The trouble with him here is that he forgets that Paul is not in this place speaking about that law which has the weekly Sabbath in it, but about that law which was composed of types and shadows, pointing forward to Christ, and illustrating his work before the world. So far he finds no support for his cause, except in such utter misapplications of Scripture.”},{

WHAT IS WANTED?

“If any one,” he says, “insists on our keeping the Hebrew Sabbath, tell him what is wanted.”

The Sunday doctors use language so inaccurately, and betray such a confusion of ideas that it is hard to follow them. We don’t read of any “Hebrew Sabbath” except the seven yearly sabbaths of the ceremonial law; but that is not what he wishes to refer to. Was the weekly Sabbath ever called the Hebrew Sabbath, or the Jewish Sabbath?—Never; and he ought to know that fact. There was but one weekly Sabbath, and it had no connection with the ceremonial law. It was not a ceremony, nor a type, nor a shadow, nor an ordinance, but a memorial of the great Jehovah, established in Eden before the fall. It is the Sabbath, not of any man or race of men, but from first to last, from beginning to end, the Sabbath of the Lord our God. It was placed in the bosom of the moral law, showing that like every other principle of that law, which can no more change than the character of God can change, it is binding on all his creatures, without respect to where they live, or when they live. But we must not forget Mr. J.’s wants. He says:—

“WANTED.—One New Testament meeting of Christians on the seventh day after the death of Christ; not one where the preacher went to a Jewish meeting to convert the people from Judaism, but one meeting of Christians for worship on that day. The seventh-day cause demands this. It is badly wanted. But we call for it in vain.”

Poor man! How long has he been wanting and calling for this? His want might have been supplied long and long ago. The seventh-day cause has not been aware of any such demand for itself. Everything that is needed, by any candid, honest mind, in its behalf is abundantly supplied in the Scriptures. The seventh-day cause knows this: that when Christ came to this world, God had a moral law in full force, for the government of the world, and Christ affirmed the immutability and perpetuity of that law, in every jot and tittle, while heaven and earth should last. That law enjoined the keeping of the seventh day; and they, said Christ, must do and teach it who would have a part in the kingdom of heaven. Matt. 5:17-20.

We know that this commandment, at least, survived the cross; for after the crucifixion, the holy women, who, if following Christ ever makes one a Christian, were certainly Christians, “returned and prepared spices and ointments; and rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment.” Luke 23:56.

If the Christian disciples therefore did not keep the Sabbath, they simply disobeyed a law to which they were still amenable.

We know further that the seventh day was the only ordinary day for worship for the disciples. No other can be found. And this was the day chosen when the Gentiles, not Jews, were the special objects of the preaching. Acts 13:42-44.

Nor is this all. We know that James expressly declares that there was no other Sabbath but the seventh day in his time. Acts 15:21: “For Moses of old time hath in every city them that preach him, being read in the synagogues every Sabbath day.” Will Mr. J. or any other one, have the hardihood to affirm that Moses was read in the synagogues on the first day of the week, or on any day except the seventh day?—Not one. And this seventh day was, according to James, every Sabbath. There was no other day that was known, or in any way recognized, as the Sabbath, but the seventh day, so late as A. D. 52. This text, as with a scourge of small cords, drives from the Sabbatic temple every day but the seventh, as a fraud and an intruder, a thief and a robber.

Besides this, we know that there is no record of any religious meeting on the first day of the week but one, and that was an evening meeting; and while Paul remained behind to speak a little while longer to the brethren, his companions were off upon their journey; and he, after preaching all night, started off Sunday morning on his long walk of nearly twenty miles, from Troas to Assos. This is the way the only Sunday on which we have any record of a religious meeting, was kept by the apostles—the companions of Paul sailing all the twenty-four hours, and Paul himself devoting all the light part of the day to secular pursuits. Acts 20:7-14.

So much for meetings in the New Testament. The Sabbath was their only regular day of religious meeting. And if the first day of the week had been ordained as the day for the Christian Sabbath, it is very singular that they did not use it as such, or at least give us some record concerning it. But let us look at another of Mr. J.’s wants:—

“WANTED.—One verse of Scripture wherein some apostle, after Pentecost, taught any Christian to keep the Sabbath day. Without it the seventh-day cause rests on no foundation. But alas, there is no such verse.”

The more we see of Sunday arguments, the more we are convinced that those who use them count largely on the supposition that they can keep the eyes of the people fixed on the one point of the Sabbath, so that they will not see their bearing on other parts of the subject. Thus, here is a wonderful flourish over the demand for a text teaching the seventh day. But suppose we turn the question to the first day of the week and say, “WANTED.—One verse of Scripture wherein some apostle, after Pentecost, ever taught any Christian to keep the first day of the week. Without it the Sunday cause rests on no foundation. But alas, there is no such text.” How would that work? It is amusing to see theologians acting over the antic of the Irishman who ascended a tree to saw off a limb, and having taken his position upon the limb, sawed it off between himself and the trunk of the tree,—with what effect the reader can imagine!

In this proposition, the truth, and so the advantage, is wholly on the side of the seventh day. There is not one syllable of instruction or command in all the Bible, for the observance of the first day of the week. And this is generally conceded by first-day writers. But there is all the necessary instruction for the seventh day. As we have seen, Christ taught, in the most positive manner, the perpetuity of the law which contains the Sabbath. And when the young man asked him what he should do to have eternal life, he answered, “Keep the commandments.” Matt. 19:17. And then he quoted enough of them to show to what code he referred, which was the decalogue, the law that enjoins the observance of the seventh day.

But our friend tries most desperately to make some showing for Sunday. He says: “But did Christians meet on the first day of the week?” And he answers, “They met on the resurrection day.” Yes, we reply, they were necessarily together; for they had one common place of abode. Acts 1:13. It would be a wonderful thing, indeed, if they kept entirely apart from each other, under those circumstances. But they were not together for a religious meeting, or for worship. All the eleven were together only when “they sat at meat,” or were partaking of their evening meal. Mark 16:14; Luke 24:33. This was at the very close of the day; and so far from being a meeting to celebrate the resurrection, they did not then believe that their Lord had risen; and when he appeared to them, they were terrified and affrighted, and supposed he was a ghost; and he upbraided them for their unbelief. Yet with this plain record before them, religious teachers will try to make it appear that the disciples were met together by special appointment, for a religious meeting, to celebrate the resurrection which had taken place in the morning of that day, and to lay the foundation of the Christian Sabbath, to reach to the end of time! Such attempted jugglery with the sacred record is most astonishing.

“They met,” he continues, “on the day of Pentecost.” Yes; but because it was the day of Pentecost, not because it was the first day of the week. But now comes perhaps the most astonishing statement of all: “Which [Pentecost] always came on the first day of the week.” This is just as false as it would be to say that the 4th of July always comes on the first day of the week. The Pentecost was a yearly festival, fixed by the day of the month, not the day of the week. But does it not say that the wave sheaf was offered on “the morrow after the Sabbath,” and the Pentecost was fifty days after?—Yes; but that sabbath was the sabbath of the passover and not the weekly Sabbath. This mistake arises from not regarding the distinction between the moral and ceremonial laws.

Then referring to Acts 20:7 and 1 Cor. 16:2, he says: “These first-day meetings, we see, were customary.” But 1 Corinthians 16:2 brings to view no meeting, and both that and Acts 20, show that the day was devoted to secular uses. But he concludes: “Under the guidance of the Spirit, the apostles and disciples adopted it as their special day of worship.” To which it is sufficient to reply that under the guidance of the Spirit the apostles and disciples uniformly observed the seventh day, and as uniformly ignored the first day as the Sabbath. They never gave any command for its observance as a Sabbath, nor any example for such observance, nor affixed any title of honor to it,p. 713 and never held but one religious meeting on that day that we know anything about, and then devoted the remainder of even that day, and every other first day, to secular uses.

Such, in brief, are the comparative claims of the Sabbath and first day in the New Testament. If any reader doubts that the testimony is all in favor of the seventh day, and that alone, let him “SEARCH AND SEE.”