CONCERNING COMMENTARIES.
By M. E. K.
It is a very common practice for writers on biblical subjects to quote frequently from the commentators. We are all liable to do this, and we often do it with considerable satisfaction. If in defense of any doctrine, one is able to say that "all Protestant commentators agree in saying," etc., etc., it is often supposed to be almost, if not quite, as good authority as the Bible itself. We are liable to quote the commentators much as the Catholic Church quotes the “Fathers,” and upon many subjects one is about as near the truth as the other. It is well to consult a commentary to learn what a man’s opinion is, and to examine the grounds upon which that opinion is based; but if that opinion is not in harmony with the Scripture, if it is an attempt to disprove or make of less force any fact or truth that is plainly stated in the word of God, it is not worth the paper upon which it is printed. When it is only a matter of inference or opinion, one man’s inference or opinion, generally speaking, is as good as another man’s. Commentators are not inspired, and after all they may say, the Scripture itself is the last court of appeal upon the matters of which they treat, and in harmony with it every disputed and vexed question must be decided. A commentator’s agreement with a plain text of Scripture does not add any force to it, nor does his disagreement take away one iota of strength. Commentaries enable the student of the Bible to study Bible subjects from the standpoint of different minds; then with the Scripture before him, to which alone loyalty is due, he can arrive at a satisfactory, and probably truthful, decision upon the question upon which he is seeking for light. And if in such investigation, the commentator is at variance with the apparent and plain meaning of the Scripture, man’s opinion, including our own, must give way, that the voice of God may be heard. Thus when a noted commentator, describing the baptism of the eunuch by the evangelist Philip, says that “while Philip was instructing him, and he professing his faith in Christ, he probably plunged himself under the water,” we should believe the Scripture instead of the commentator, and the Scripture says, “And they went down both into the water, both Philip and the eunuch; and he baptized him.” Acts 8:38. Again: when John says in the Revelation, “I was in the spirit on the Lord’s day,” it is of no account whatever that many commentators add, “the first day of the week,” or “the Christian Sabbath, which is the first day of the week;” for the Bible sanctions no such idea, and the opinions of ten thousand commentators will not change the word of God, or make it of none effect. The one grand and God-inspired declaration, covering all time and all the future of eternity, that “the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God,” cannot be changed in meaning, or made void by a multitude of adverse commentators, whose comments are not according to the “oracles of God.” “Let God be true, but every man a liar,” is a Scripture rule which will apply to commentators as well as to every person who exalts himself against the knowledge of Christ. Besides doctrinal topics, there are many other subjects introduced in the Bible,—some fully, and others only casually, such as the customs, habits, and religions of the different nations, and a variety of things concerning which a good commentary is an invaluable assistant, and should therefore not be despised. In short, the commentary is all right if it is not allowed to take the place of the book which has called it forth, and about which it is written. Many persons read the commentary because they are too indolent to study the Bible, and the result is that to that person the Bible is secondary, and the uninspired and fallible commentary is of chief importance. That thousands have done, and are now doing, this very thing, is one of the chief reasons why they are so slow to accept the words of the Bible itself. With many persons the Bible and some favorite commentary are inseparably joined together, and they do not know where to draw the dividing line between them. A quaint writer referring to the large number of “Lives of Christ” which are now selling, said that it “was probable that none of them were any improvement on those written by Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John!” If all will see the idea couched in this pithy sentence, and remember it, it will help them to preserve in their minds the proper relation which the commentary sustains to the Bible.