Men or Things?

7%

Pacific Press Publishing Company · Oakland, California · Jul 9, 1902

FromSigns of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 28.

Read the full edition

Men or Things?

Continued from page 9.
Certainly in good company; for, as you know, there are scores of institutions that have been financially helped by them.”
“But does that fact make his business methods any less worthy of censure?”
“But, Brother Dudley!” exclaimed the Dean eagerly, “are you not exaggerating unduly this matter? Is it possible for you to sift out the honest from the dishonest dollars that the business men in your own congregation pay into the church toward your own salary? Is it not a fact that in all probability some of the money that comes into your own hands is made in very unchristian ways?”
“I have no doubt that is so,” replied the minister. “And it would be an absolute impossibility for me to separate the good money from the bad. But I do not keep silent in my pulpit concerning the unchristian or selfish money-making of my business men. And if I knew of any case as clearly wrong as that of Mr. Roscoe’s company, I should consider it my duty to denounce it rather than encourage it by holding up the donor to the public view of my congregation as a type of Christian benevolence. This is the point I can not understand in connection with Mr. Roscoe’s gift to academy, college, and seminary. You not only do not reserve the right to criticize his methods in particular as bad, but you actually set him before the students as a type of modern Christian rich man who is illustrating the noble habit of giving. It is the giving you emphasize as a great exhibition of benevolence; the making of the money does not enter into your consideration. So the question comes right back to where we began, and I see no escape from it; what will be the moral effect on the seminary if Mr. Roscoe is accepted, either tacitly or openly, as the type of Christian benevolence?”
“I am sure you must be misinformed concerning Mr. Roscoe’s business methods,” murmured the Dean. “All business is more or less involved in transactions that meet with opposition, especially from unsuccessful rivals. I have no doubt Mr. Roscoe has been assailed and misrepresented by his business enemies.”
“Mr. Roscoe’s company,” said the minister, “has been guilty, according to well-established records in the courts, of crimes against the laws of the State. There are scores of individuals who have been financially ruined by him. He has, through his company, been guilty of the most unchristian practices in his business relations that I have no doubt he would be horrified to practise in his private life. These things are facts. They have been proved many times. Not to know them is to declare one’s self as ignorant of one of the commonest facts in the commercial world. And if one can not but look with the gravest concern upon the elevation of this man to a place where educational institutions have put him on a pedestal of honor because he has made enormous sums of money, and is giving a small portion of it to schools and seminaries and churches. The effect on our students in academy, college, and seminary will, I believe, be disastrous to their ethical life. It will lower the whole tone of spiritual definitions of conduct. It will greatly emphasize the already distorted valuation placed upon physical equipment in our schools. To have magnificent physical equipment in the shape of buildings, apparatus and endowment, and at the same time to lose the ethical standard or substitute for it a false conception of Christian benevolence, is to drag our educational institutions down into a material prosperity that is nothing more nor less than cultured paganism. The old idea of a college that consists of ‘Mark Hopkins on one end of a log and a student on the other end’ is a million times to be preferred to Mr. Roscoe’s endowed institutions with their imposing buildings, long array of faculty, and immense crowds of students.”
Reaching home, his wife tells him that he looks as tho he had been to three funerals. He tells her what he found, and the story closes with the following conversation:—
“Am I an old fogy, Sarah?” he asked.
“No, I do not believe you are,” she answered vigorously. “But the world will think you are if you say anything about it. The age in which we live is magnifying material prosperity.”
“I wonder,” he spoke slowly, “if we have gained in real power, or only in things? Are we at a crisis in our educational life? At any rate the ethical standard is confused in the case of Mr. Roscoe. I am not an old fogy. What will be the product of the educational system that asks no questions concerning the making of money so long as it gets money?”
“It is easy enough to prophesy what the product will be,” his wife replied. “It will be an educated paganism, a cultured heathenism, that will restore the worship of things, instead of demanding the worship of ideals.”
“Then,” said the minister, as he went into his study to prepare his sermon, “the sooner we get back to the Mark Hopkins kind of college the better for the republic. For I fear the present tendency means more serious consequences to our boys and girls than we dare to imagine. God save us from progress in things at the cost of the ideals of life!”
Reader, is this not true to life? Did not the minister’s wife tell the truth? Is not the condition an awful one? In the light of the Word it means that we are in the last days. Read 2 Tim. 3:1–5.