AdventAI

A DISTINCTION WITHOUT A DIFFERENCE.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 15., April 11, 1893

The ease with which our modern theologians and would-be reformers can pose as champions of the historic American theory of the separation of the State from the Church, and practically contradict each other, themselves, and every principle of logic, and still keep right on as though nothing had happened, is well illustrated by the queer position taken by Joseph Cook upon the part the Bible and the fourth commandment should take in the Sunday-closing act of Congress. In a late speech in Boston, speaking of the time when the Sunday-closing bill was pending in Congress, and referring to the action of Senator Quay in sending his Bible up to the clerk’s desk, that the fourth commandment might be read as the basis of the Sunday-closing, Mr. Cook said: “I do not agree with him. I wish to shake myself loose from all theories which tend toward a union of Church and State.”

Does not this sound finely? Behold the great Joseph Cook! He doesn’t want to do anything that would “tend toward a union of Church and State!” Not he.

But some of his fellow-reformers felt very much hurt by such an exhibition of honesty; they thought he meant it. They felt pained over what they thought was a departure from the National Reformers’ faith, or, as they have themselves expressed their feelings, his statement “was the ‘dead fly’ that caused the ointment [National Reform ointment], to send forth a stinking savor.” That is to say, the great Boston lecturer was a stench in the nostrils of his brethren. One of them was so nearly suffocated by this “odor” that he addressed Mr. Cook the following letter:—

“Your statement last Monday that the civil Sabbath is not based upon the fourth commandment, it seems to me, deprives our Sabbath laws of their moral value; for a law that has not the authority of God behind it will not bind the conscience. The ten commandments are a translation of the law of nature, as well as an authoritative rule of spiritual life. They are both a civil code and an ecclesiastical law. They were given to the nation of Israel as their constitution, and to the church of Israel as a law of ecclesiastical life. For the State to recognize them as the foundation of moral legislation no more tends to unite Church and State than family worship creates a union between the family and the church. The ten commandments have been placed in Christ’s hands as the administrator. Every believer is under that law to Christ. Christ is King of nations. And nations, as moral beings, are under this law to him. The church is under this law to Christ. But this law, being a rule of life to the individual, the family, the Church, and the State, in their respective spheres, brings all into subjection to Christ. Our Sabbath laws are rooted and grounded in the fourth commandment. Separate from that edict of Jehovah, they are not worth the paper they were written upon.”

This letter had the desired effect. No sooner does Mr. Cook become apprised of the fact that his dead fly is poisoning the whole National Reform pot of ointment, and having had the glory of making a grandiloquent speech which was trumpeted through all the papers, he now shows that he did not mean what he said, by the following very interesting reply:—

“Dear Dr. Foster:—

“We do not disagree in fundamental principles as to the divine authority of the civic rest day. But I could not make that divine authority depend wholly or chiefly on the fourth commandment; for I believe there was a day for rest and worship set apart at the creation; that the Sabbath is as old as the family, and that apostolic example and precept justify the observance of the Lord’s day as a Christian Sabbath. The fourth commandment begins with the word ‘Remember,’ and itself stands on much that went before it as well as on what accompanied it. The self-revelation of God in the whole history of the rest day from creation until now was the ground on which I placed the divine authority of our Sunday laws in their general outlines.

“Yours very respectfully, “Joseph Cook.”

With the above letter Dr. Foster tries to be content. He is so glad that Mr. Cook did not mean what he said, that he doesn’t seem to care much how he tells it.

But let us examine his logic a little. He does not disagree with his brethren upon “fundamental principles.” He would not make “that divine authority depend wholly or solely upon the fourth commandment.” He believes there “was a day for rest and worship set apart at creation,” and that the “self-revelation of God in the whole history of the rest day from creation until now” is the proper ground, and upon this basis and not upon the fourth commandment, he would base the Sunday law; and what is the strangest thing of all, he holds that Sunday enforced upon this ground would not be a union of Church and State; while if it should be enforced simply upon the basis of the fourth commandment, it would be forming such a union! The Sabbath enforced because of the fourth commandment would be a union of the State with the Church, and this he will not allow, but the Sabbath enforced because it existed from creation, which is the very thing that the fourth command states and upon which it rests, is all right, and should be done! To enforce the Sabbath by law on account of the fourth commandment, would be a union of the Church with the State, and he opposes it; but to enforce it upon the ground that it is a “self-revelation of God in the whole history of the rest day from creation until now,” which revelation begins at creation, where the Sabbath was made, takes in the fourth command as given by God upon Sinai, and all the Bible, that can be enforced, and no harm will ensue, and the State will not be united with the Church.

Again: to enforce it because of the fourth commandment, would unite Church and State, and he is against it; but to enforce it because “apostolic example and precept” is added to all the other evidences, would not be doing so! And that is to say that because the apostles did a certain thing, and that which they did was sanctioned by the whole revelation, then it ought to be enforced by fines and penalties! Was there ever a more shallow attempt to make a distinction without a difference?

The revelation in regard to the Sabbath, Mr. Cook says, extends from creation till now. As there is no revelation concerning Sunday as the Sabbath during the time covered between the creation and the last recorded acts of Christ and his apostles; and since Mr. Cook does not seem willing to enforce his Sunday Sabbath upon either the original institution of the Sabbath at creation, the authority of the fourth commandment, or the general authority of all the Scriptures, but expressly includes in his authority for Sunday what he calls “self-revelations . . . until now,” it therefore follows that the real authority upon which he depends, upon which his Sunday Sabbath actually rests, and upon which it is to be enforced, is some later revelation than the one given in the word of God.

As he does not say himself what that revelation is, it would, perhaps, be idle for us to speculate upon it. But since we are certain that it is not in the Bible, and in its practical working it contradicts both the letter and spirit of the Scriptures, we shall hold that it is anti-Christ, and consequently not to be regarded. Mr. Cook will have to “shake himself” a little harder than he has done yet before he gets all the Church-and-State theories eradicated from his mind.

M. E. K.