CORSICANA.—I have just had a discussion at the place with Elder Joseph Harding, evangelist of the Disciple Church. The way in which it came about is as follows:—
Elder Harding proposed to the ministers of the place to quote Scripture with them, with the understanding that if they were right, he would go with them; but if he was right, they should go with him. There was a student at the business college here who came to me frequently, desiring me to go and meet the minister and see what he had to say. I felt that the truth should be vindicated, so I arranged nine questions, as follows: Is there any Sabbath for God’s people now? If so, where do we find the injunction, obligation, example, or command for keeping the Sabbath? If not, where do we find any scripture for releasing us from keeping the Sabbath? What day is the Lord’s day? Where do we find any scripture for the first day being called the Lord’s day? Do the Old and New Testament scriptures harmonize? Have we any standard by which we may know if we are living without sin? What is sin? Have we immortality out of Christ?
Elder Harding wished me (privately) to agree to postpone the matter indefinitely, but I felt that it was not best to let him slip out in this way. So he finally agreed to announce the discussion, and when it should take place.
The following Friday night was chosen. Our brethren were somewhat cautious, as we did not want to discuss in a way to dishonor the Lord’s Sabbath. But with the fear of God before us, we went into the matter with the desire to do our Master’s will; and the Lord certainly did exalt the truth through his humble instrumentality.
Just to show you an example of how he answered the questions, the following will suffice: “Is there any Sabbath for God’s people now?” He said, “I say no, and if I am asked the question again, I say no, and if I am asked the question again,—jumping down from the rostrum and stamping both feet on the floor at the same time,—I say NO.” And so he passed on without a single quotation of scripture on the first question, and almost the same was with the other questions.
When it came my turn, I asked permission to sing. So the privilege was granted, with the understanding that it would go on my time. A number of our brethren and sisters were in attendance and were seated near each other, and we sang, “What Says the Bible, the Blessed Bible?” How thankful I was for such a blessed song. Of course I could not do anything like justice to so many subjects in so short a time, and I called upon “Weeping Joe,” as he is called, to know how much time was to be granted in the discussion. He said he would take all the time he wanted, and I could do the same.
I occupied an hour and fifteen minutes, and he, on the following Monday night, reviewed me; afterward proposed, as he had offered me all the time I wanted, to discuss the subjects, taking an evening for each one. There was an agreement to meet the next day and arrange matters; but when the time came, he declined, as his brethren did not want him to carry the discussion any further. The matters went on till last Friday. Then two of his brethren (one a minister) came to me denouncing him, and saying they would send for another man who would discuss the questions, and asked if I would have a discussion with him. I told them I would. May the Lord have his precious truth exalted high. After the discussion our brethren insisted that we should press the battle further, and we believe it is in God’s order that it should be. ELIJAH TAYLOR.