“Life” and “Death” Literal Terms.
By Prof. Pettingell
It is only by accepting these words, Life and Death, according to their plain, literal sense, that the Scriptures—especially the historical, doctrinal, didactic, and hortatory portions—can be made intelligible and self-consistent. If the Bible is the word of God, as we believe, all of its utterances will be in harmony with each other. If they seem to conflict, it must be either because we misapprehend them, or because we have read a meaning into some of its passages that cannot be sustained by others. This is just the difficulty interpreters have found with the doctrine under consideration. It is quite possible to construe these terms, Life and Death, in certain passages which our opposers are in the habit of quoting, in such a way as to seem to favor their doctrine. But they are in such evident conflict with others, which most positively threaten absolute death and extermination to the wicked, or promise endless perpetuity of life to the righteous only; and so out of harmony with the whole drift of the Scriptures from Genesis to Revelation as to forbid any such construction to be put upon them. But there is nothing in all the Scriptures that forbids us to take these words in their ordinary sense. Yea, we cannot do otherwise without doing violence to the word of God. Dr. Farre, an eminent English physician, in a recent private remark, so well expresses our view, that we must quote his words:— “I believe that there are very few important doctrines of Christianity that do not meet with some apparent contradiction in Scripture, so that we can only get at the truth by taking the Scripture as a whole—whether this apparent contradiction arises from the desirableness of expressing the doctrine in high relief, so as to make it more striking and impressive; or from the somewhat exaggerated mode of Oriental speaking, which has this object; or from the different purposes for which the doctrine is mentioned on different occasions; or from viewing the doctrine, as it were, in all lights. But I think there are few important doctrines so free from contradiction as this—that eternal life is the gift of God through Jesus Christ, and that the finally impenitent will lose it.” We cannot, in this place, go into as extended a comparison of Scripture with Scripture as we could wish. It will hardly be necessary to do more than to direct the reader’s attention to a few passages. Take, for instance, the original threatening: “Thou shalt surely die;” or, as it is more exactly in the margin, “Dying thou shalt die.” Gen. 2:7. It is hardly possible to believe that Adam could have understood the language to mean anything but just what the words imply. No one would ever have thought of forcing another meaning into this language, had it not been for the purpose of sustaining a doctrine which the Scriptures do not teach. But when God himself proceeds to interpret the meaning of these words, which he does immediately after the fall (in the next chapter, Gen. 3:19): “For dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return,”—this surely ought to be the end of all question among those who have any regard whatever for the truth of God’s word. But still further, we have an exhibition of God’s mercy, as well as his justice, in dooming the sinner to death. He will not allow him to perpetuate a life of sin and misery. Hence the “tree of life,” to which he had hitherto had access, is now denied him; and for this very reason—as God himself tells us: “And now, lest he put forth his hand and take also of the tree of life, and eat and live forever,”—he is driven from the garden, and cherubim are stationed to guard the tree of life against the sinner’s approach. The tree is not destroyed. A new way of access is to be provided through an atoning Saviour, and a new life through him; and Christ’s ransomed people will again “have a right to the tree of life” in the Paradise beyond, to which he will bring them. It is impossible to make any sense out of this passage, unless we understand it, as it reads—that the death which follows sin is actual death, and the life which is the portion of the holy, is actual life with all its blessings. For if we take death to mean a forlorn and wretched condition of life or existence, endlessly perpetuated; and life to mean purity and joy; then why should not God, in his mercy, have been willing to let Adam “eat and live forever”? Or—and perhaps this is an effectual way to test the definition which is given of life—if the tree of life is only the tree of holiness and “well-being,” why was God so unwilling that man should put forth his hand, and take, and eat, and possess holiness and “well-being” forever? We once asked a theological professor, who gives this interpretation to these words, Why was God so unwilling to permit Adam to eat and live forever? After much hesitation and evident embarrassment, he replied: “It is a skeptical question. It don’t deserve an answer.” This is as satisfactory an answer as these expositors can give. What can be meant by those many expostulations, entreaties and warnings of God’s word, but actual death and extinction of being? “Turn ye, turn ye, for why will ye die?” “The wages of sin is death.” “Sin, when it is finished, bringeth forth death.” “If ye live after the flesh ye shall die.” “The end of those things is death.” “Whose end is destruction,” etc. These words are spoken to sinners and of sinners. They are already “spiritually dead,” according to theology. As for the death of the body, no one can avoid that. What other death can be meant, or possibly inflicted upon them, but actual death? What other kind of life do they possess, but their natural life? The popular theory is, that the second death, which will be inflicted upon impenitent sinners in the day of Judgment, will be a continuation of their present spiritual death; that is alienation from God, with a great addition to their sufferings, whether of mind or of body, or of both. But this is not the infliction of the death that is threatened. The word of God tells them that they SHALL DIE, and not that they shall continue dead under circumstances of aggravated misery. It represents God himself as inflicting this death upon them, by casting them into hell (Gehenna) for the destruction of both soul and body. God never inflicts spiritual death. That which is so called, is indeed the sin for which actual death is the penalty. They who are spiritually dead—that is, alienated from God, and necessarily wretched as long as they live—cannot be permitted to live at all, after their reclamation has become hopeless and justice has been satisfied. They are to be gathered as the tares and chaff—not to be preserved forever, but only to be burned. It is the good seed only that is gathered into the garner. Why are we exhorted to seek for glory, honor, and immortality, if this immortality is what all men have without seeking? Why are we urged to “lay hold on eternal life,” or why is eternal life so emphatically and repeatedly promised to the righteous as their own peculiar portion, as the special gift of God through Christ? Surely something more than purity and happiness must be meant. All this, of course, is included in the gift of that blessed life. But it is the life itself that is promised. Life must have a deeper and more radical meaning than its accompanying conditions; for we speak of a sinful and wretched life, as well as a pure and happy life. But the evident teaching of Scripture is, that the latter only can endure forever, and the former must inevitably come to an end; “the end of those things is death.” The miseries that accompany sin are likened to the diseases of the body. They are especially likened to that dreadful, fatal disease, called leprosy, which terminates only in the death of the victim. It is declared to be the great, universal law of God’s government, that nothing can live permanently that is not in conformity with his holy law; that sin is self-destructive, and must inevitably end in death; not merely in misery and wretchedness—these are only the first-fruits—but in death, when it is finished. In this way the universe is to be cleansed, “and there shall be no more death, neither sorrow, nor crying, neither shall there be any more pain; for the former things are passed away.” If the word zōē, life, is to be taken to mean simply a state of blessedness, and the word thanatos, death, a state of misery, why should not the epithet aiōnios be equally applicable to both, if they are both equally enduring? But never, never in one single instance is it applied to the latter in the word of God, while it is continually used to designate the endless perpetuity of the former. It is this false philosophy concerning the natural and necessary immortality of all men, that has rendered the arguments of the apostle Paul in his epistles to the Romans and Corinthians respecting the universality of death in consequence of Adam’s sin, so inexplicable, and has necessitated the invention of so many various theories to make the dealings of God with the heathen world, and with infants, appear to be just. Let him be understood to mean just what he says, and his arguments need no explanation, nor do the ways of God need any apology. They are most evidently “just and true.” The words of our Lord, as recorded in John, especially in that notable sixth chapter, where he proclaims himself as the “bread of life,” are explicable only as we understand him to mean life, as he says, and not mere happiness as these teachers would fain explain them: “Verily, verily, I say unto you, he that believeth on me hath everlasting life. I am the bread of life. Your fathers did eat manna in the wilderness, and are dead,”—not, are wretched, but are dead. The manna which they ate had no power to give them perpetual life. But “I am the living bread which came down from heaven; if any man eat of this bread, he shall live forever.” There is no analogy here, unless we understand by the life which Christ gives, endless perpetuity of life. So, in the fifth chapter, he asserts with great emphasis, that everlasting life is from him: “Verily, verily, I say unto you, he that heareth my words, and believeth on him that sent me, hath everlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation; but is passed from death unto life;”—that principle of life is already generated in him which shall never be extinguished. “For, as the Father hath life in himself,”—not happiness, but life,—“so hath he given to the Son to have life in himself.” The Jewish people had come, very generally, to claim this future life of eternal blessedness for themselves, as the special favorites of Heaven—as the children of Abraham; but our Lord assures them that they can only secure it through him: “He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life; he that believeth not the Son shall not see life.” “Search the Scriptures, for in them ye think ye have eternal life [or the promise of eternal life]; and they are they which testify of me”—as the only giver of this life—“and ye will not come unto Me that ye might have life.” “If ye believe not that I am He, ye shall die in your sins.” Again, when at the grave of Lazarus our Lord proclaims himself as the resurrection and the life, how could those who heard him, or how can we, understand him as declaring anything else than that the dead can live again only by a resurrection, and that this resurrection and this life are only through him? On this point, Bishop Hampton, in one of his Bampton Lectures, says:— “The notion of the separate existence of the soul has so incorporated itself with Christian theology, that we are apt, at this day, to regard a belief in it as essential to orthodox doctrine. I cannot, however, help viewing this popular belief as a remnant of scholasticism. I feel assured that the truth of the resurrection does not rest on such an assumption. What our Lord says to Martha’s declaration, ‘I know that he shall rise again,’ when he proclaims himself the resurrection and the life, is to this point. The Jews then entertained a philosophical belief in a future state. Our Lord tacitly reproves an assurance on such grounds, by his strong reference to himself: ‘I am the resurrection and the life; whosoever believeth in me shall live though he die.’” In short—for we must hasten to the conclusion—what else can be meant by having one’s name “blotted out of the book of life,” but to be counted unfit any longer to live, and to be consigned to that “second death,” from which there is no resurrection? This will be a fearful doom, indeed, and one in view of which the sinner may well tremble; for he cannot dispute its justice, while all Heaven exclaims, “Behold the goodness and severity of God!”—From “Life Everlasting,” by Prof. Pettingell.