ONLY CALL IT A KITTEN

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 31, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 22.

Read the full edition

ONLY CALL IT A KITTEN.

We have reached the age of surprises—an age of the most startling logic—a time when men will suffer themselves to be juggled by a word out of all correct principle and correct practice! Men denounce the religious intolerance and tyranny of the past, and hold up their hands in holy horror at the ghastly scenes of torture and death resulting from it during the Dark Ages; but they now suffer themselves to be drawn complacently and deliberately into the same spirit and to turn in the same direction, by the simple trick of calling it by another term.
This is most clearly illustrated in the position now being assumed in reference to a Sunday law. To enforce Sunday as a religious institution, would, they say, be all wrong, and contrary to conscience and religious liberty; but to enforce it as a civil institution, is both necessary and right.
But what is the difference? Calling the day a civil institution does not change, in one single iota, the fact that religion is behind it, and in it, and through it, and that the end to be gained by the proposed law is a religious end, pure and simple, first and last. Then wherein is the matter changed either in principle or practice? The promoters of it would gain all they have in view from a religious standpoint; and the victims of the oppression it would bring, would suffer all the evils and wrongs of religious persecution; for as calling it a civil law does not change it from its religious nature, so it does not remove it from the realm of conscience, and enable those to bow down to it, who conscientiously observe the Bible day.
It is not strange to see some carried away by such logic, but it is a little surprising that Baptists should come to view the question in that light. Yet this is the very ground taken by the Canadian Baptist of May 19, 1892. In an article on “The Sunday Observance Bill,” which some have been trying to get through the Canadian Parliament, but which has, happily, failed to carry, this Baptist paper takes occasion to state its position. It prides itself on Baptist precedents and Baptist principles, in opposition to all religious legislation and oppression. It says the Baptists have suffered too much in the past to regard such principles with favor. After stating at length its convictions that Sunday-keeping is supported by the Scriptures, it says:—
“As servants of God and followers of Christ, Baptists yield to none in their profound conviction of the divine sanction and the blessed results of Sabbath keeping; but as firm and uncompromising believers in religious liberty and voluntaryism, they hold also that the civil power has nothing to do with the enforcement of this or any other religious obligation. In this they differ from many of their brethren in other evangelical denominations.”
This is all very well so far, did not the editor immediately proceed to kick the whole underpinning out from what he says “they hold,” and reverse its principles completely. After stating that it had received again and again copies of petitions, remonstrances, and appeals to Parliament, and to individual members thereof, against the perpetration of the great wrong, which the petitioners, as they maintained, would suffer from the passing of an Act which they denounce as one of “religious persecution,” it adds:—
“If the act were based on the religious grounds to which we have adverted, and which are urged by many of its supporters, it would be clearly impossible to deny the impeachment. But divested of everything which does not necessarily belong to it as a measure for securing to the workingmen of every class their weekly day of rest, it can be amply justified on the broadest grounds. And the injury inflicted on the few who conscientiously observe another day as their religious Sabbath, becomes one of those minor hardships which are inseparable from the enforcement of much of human legislation which must necessarily regard the greatest good of the greatest number.”
Here the Baptist frankly admits that oppression and persecution will be the result of the enforcement of the law, even if it is called a civil law. But yet it argues that calling it a civil law makes it all right, and takes away all grounds of complaint by those who would suffer from it. In other words, here is the bloodthirsty tiger of persecution glaring upon the community, and quivering with a desire to spring upon them. And one says, “As a tiger, I object to letting that beast loose; as a tiger, he has no right to rend and devour the people. But only call him a kitten, just give him another name, though he may have the same nature and do the same work, then it is necessary that he should be set at liberty, and we will help him in his work, and if any suffer from it, it is only what they must expect by being in a minority, and incurring some of the minor hardships, inseparable from legislation, while the greatest good is being secured to the greatest number!”
The most shameful trick by which those who are already bigots in spirit, and would-be tyrants and persecutors in practice, have disgraced themselves, is this claim that a law, which if called “religious,” would be unrighteous and cruel, will, if only called “civil,” be just and right. We hope our Baptist friends will not be taken with such logic. It is very easy to cry out against persecution in the past. The more important question is, Will we take our stand against it in the present? The Pharisees could say, “If we had only lived in the days of our fathers, we would not have persecuted the prophets.” Oh, no! But what did they do with the Greater than the prophets in their own day?