AdventAI

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 22., May 31, 1892

[We aim to reply under this head, to questions which are of such a nature that the answers will be of general interest and profit to the readers of the REVIEW. Those sending in long lists of disconnected texts for explanation, evidently as a mere matter of curiosity to see how certain puzzling passages will be disposed of, need not be surprised if no notice is taken of them. Many more inquiries are received than can be answered in this department; and the editor reserves the right to decide which to notice in this manner. All correspondents should therefore give their names and true post-office address, that queries not replied to here may be answered by mail.]

198.—CLEAN OR UNCLEAN. LEV. 11:25.

1. Is the law of clean and unclean, as recorded in Leviticus 11, especially verses 25, 32, 33, and 35, applicable to Christians now? Do we commit sin by eating the unclean animals? 2. Do we commit sin by refusing to pay tithes? If so, what sin? 3. How minutely did the services of the worldly sanctuary represent the services of the heavenly? C. B. De F.

Answer.—1. The law concerning clean and unclean meats in the passages referred to, is not now binding upon any people. Certain kinds of meat are now refused by all well-informed persons, because they are unhealthful, and it is a sin to eat that which is not healthful, no matter what it is; and by that law we are now to be governed.

2. Withholding the tithe is called in the Scriptures, “robbing the Lord;” and there can be no question as to whether or not such a course is wrong. But to be acceptable to God, the tithe must be voluntary and cheerful. 2 Cor. 9:7. Tithes paid under compulsion, either physical or moral, is a tax, and not in such ways does the Lord require means to be raised for his cause. So this matter is left to each one’s own conscience. But one can hardly expect to enjoy much spiritual prosperity, to say nothing of secular, who comes short of his duty in tithes and offerings.

3. In all essential features, the type set forth, in figure, the heavenly sanctuary and the heavenly priesthood. There were, of course, points in which the earthly was inferior, because on earth there were only animal sacrifices and a human priesthood. So the apostle says in Heb. 10:1, “The law being a shadow of good things to come, and not the very image of things.” We may set this much down as certain: That the priesthood on earth shadowed forth that of Christ; that the offering of the blood of beasts shadowed forth the offering of the blood of Christ; that the earthly sanctuary was a figure of the heavenly, showing that the heavenly has two apartments, a holy and a most holy place; that the service in the heavenly sanctuary is carried on as it was in the earthly, first by a long service in the first apartment, or holy place, and, secondly, a short service in the second apartment, or most holy place, to make the atonement and cleanse the sanctuary; that the atonement is the close of the complete round of priestly service, not the beginning of it. It is consequently the last work that Christ does as priest before his coming in the clouds of heaven.

199.—TITHING.

Will you please answer the following questions plainly and directly in regards to tithing: 1. If a person owns a house and lot worth $2,000, and there is a mortgage of $1,000 on it, and he receives $200 per year on it for rent, but the interest and taxes are $100, how much is a just and true tithe to pay? 2. If a person keeps boarders who pay $20 per week, but the outlay for them is $15 per week, what would be the tithe on the same? These are questions that are often brought up, and all do not seem to understand them alike.

F. F. W.

Ans.—The general principle by which to be governed in the tithing system is this: that everything that comes into one’s hands from the proceeds of business, or labor, of any kind, which is for his own personal support, use, benefit, and behoof, is to be tithed. Thus, if a person goes into business, and his investment and running of the business for a year costs him $10,000, and at the end of the year he has $15,000, as a result of his business, he has cleared $5,000. But he has actually taken in from his business $15,000; yet he should not pay tithes on this $15,000; for it has cost him $10,000 to obtain it. His net income, which remains for his own use, after deducting the expense, is $5,000, and on that only, should he pay a tithe, which would be $500.

In the case referred to in the question, we suppose of course that the $1,000 paid on the property had been tithed, and the other thousand is a debt on which interest has to be paid. The rent of the building is $200. That is all the owner derives from it. But to hold the property and receive this $200, costs him $100 each year. Therefore he should not pay tithes on the gross returns, or $200 rent, but only on his net income from it, which is $100, the tithe being ten dollars. So with a person keeping boarders; if for every twenty dollars received for their board, there is an outlay of fifteen dollars, the remaining five dollars is all that the housekeeper receives as the fruits of the business, and consequently that only should be tithed. But in keeping boarders, or in farming, or any other business involving one’s own personal labor, of course the worth of that labor is not to be deducted, as that is his income. In short, a tithe should be paid on whatever one earns by the use of capital and by his own labors, either mental or physical, single or combined.

200.—FOREORDINATION.

Some are troubled over the following texts, supposingp. 345 them to teach that some are predestinated to be lost, do what they will. Will you please explain them? The texts are Jude 4; Rom. 9:21, 22; 1 Pet. 2:8; Ex. 9:16.

E. R.

Ans.—Jude 4 does not say that God ordained the persons in question to final destruction, or that God ordained them to anything. The word ordained is prographo, which simply means to “write about beforehand; to make a subject of public notice,” and Jude merely mentions some of whom they had previously been notified and warned, who were to be condemned and avoided as unbelievers. He then refers, as illustrations, to the Jews who came out of Egypt, to the angels which kept not their first estate, and to the Sodomites, all of whom were destroyed for their own unbelief.

Rom. 9:22 refers to the clay and the potter. The figure is borrowed from Jer. 18:1–10, which should be read in connection. Verses 7–10 of Jeremiah 18 show that the great truth to be illustrated by the potter and the clay is this: that if we turn away from evil, God will turn from his threatened judgments against that evil; but if we turn from good to evil, then God will turn from the good he thought to do to us. God will make us a vessel of honor if we will let him, but if we will not yield to him, we mar the clay in his hands; and then he can only make us vessels of dishonor. We are in his power, and should not deceive ourselves by thinking that we can rebel against him and persist in an evil course, and yet be made vessels of honor.

On 1 Pet. 2:8, read verse 7. To those who are disobedient, Christ will become, instead of a chief cornerstone, elect and precious, a stone of stumbling. And what people are “appointed” to in verse 8 is, not to be disobedient, but to stumble and fall into darkness and lose the benefits of Christ’s sacrifice, if they are disobedient.

Ex. 9:16 does not assert that God had given Pharaoh existence; that he might destroy him. The expression, “Raised thee up,” refers simply to his coming to the throne of Egypt. (See margin, “Made thee stand.”) Pharaoh had proved himself an incorrigible rebel against God, and God had suffered long with him. Rom. 9:22. He had determined to thwart God’s plans, yet God suffered him to come to the throne of Egypt, the mightiest nation then on earth, and exert all the power of the kingdom against his plans, that God might show how easily he could triumph over it all. There is not a text, nor an intimation, in all the Scriptures, that God ever gave any being existence, who, before he had a being, was foreordained, predestinated, and doomed, to inevitable destruction. A doctrine so horrible would at once nullify all the declarations of the Scriptures concerning the character of God, as a God of justice and mercy and love.