We greatly fear that our tithing will not receive sufficient consideration the present year, unless special attention is called to it. Within the last year or two, strenuous efforts have been made to impress our people with the great importance of this subject. Two pamphlets have been written and published, one each in our two leading publishing houses, forcibly calling the attention of all our church members to this subject, and pressing upon their minds the folly, yes, the sin, of robbing God. During the last year we have traveled far and wide among our people, and associated with all classes of them. We have never heard even an attempt made to set aside one single argument given in these pamphlets showing the solemn obligation of paying tithes. Is not this clear evidence, then, that so far as the arguments themselves are concerned, our people generally accept them as unanswerable?
At our last General Conference, the writer requested that a committee be appointed to examine the pamphlet entitled, “The Tithing System” (as he had written it since the previous Conference); to carefully scrutinize the work, and see if any unsound positions had been taken. This would have been very agreeable to us under the circumstances:—But the request met no response, and no hint indicated any dissatisfaction whatever with any of the arguments. But the Conference passed the following:—
“Whereas, God has represented a failure to pay tithes as robbery of him, and we have evidence that many in our churches do not pay tithes; and believing that in many cases their failure is the result of ignorance on the subject; therefore:—
“Resolved, That the ministers and officers of our Conferences and Tract Societies be instructed to make special efforts to place the pamphlets, ‘The Tithing System’ and ‘Honor Due to God,’ in every family of our people, and that we all make continued efforts until all not only become educated on this question, but have a conscience void of offense toward God in this important duty.”
This emphatic indorsement of these pamphlets, brings them before all our people as sanctioned by our General Conference, and as correctly representing the sentiments of our people on this subject. This recommendation to have them placed in the hands of all our membership, demonstrates the fact that our highest earthly authority considers the matter of great importance. How far are our State-Conferences acting upon this counsel? There is surely great need that something be done. The general average of the tithing paid, according to the Year Book table, is $6.23 per member. In the different Conferences, it ranges from $11.30 in Colorado and $10.82 in New England, all the way down to $3.88 in Indiana, $3.80 in Missouri, and $3.25 in Canada.
The tithing in the aggregate increased last year. In some States it increased very perceptibly, where there was considerable agitation of the subject, and circumstances favored; but in some others it decreased. There was a gain in the entire field of over $16,000. This is a little encouraging, as the year was not anywhere a prosperous one financially. But this increase is small compared with what it ought to be. We are satisfied that the general average of $6.23 paid by our membership throughout the American field, is not more than one third of what it would be if a full tithe of the actual income were paid by all our people. It is but very little above what would be a tithe of the income of a hired girl, working for $1 per week. But even girls working at house work (perhaps the poorest paid class of help receiving wages), generally receive from $2 to $3 per week, which would make a tithe of their income range from $10.40 to $15.60 per year,—far more than the general average paid by all our members. But many of our people receive from $8 to $20 per week, according to the occupation they follow and their efficiency in the same; while those who carry on farming or other business instead of working for wages, receive an income in some form as large as the average income of those who receive wages.
Who can question the fact that the true amount of tithing, if fully and honestly paid, would average as high as twenty dollars per year? We know of one church of small farmers in Iowa, where none were wealthy, whose tithe actually paid did amount to more than that. And we know of no reason why there would not be an equal average in many other places, if the people were equally conscientious; and even a larger amount, where the people were more wealthy.
What can be done to lead our people to see the wrong of robbing God? We must agitate this question. Our ministers must preach upon it, and labor with the people in private, taking the Holy Scriptures and showing them the sin of robbing God, instructing them as to what is a tithe.
Many who are not working for wages, whose income reaches them in a more indirect manner, do not properly estimate their income. Great losses occur from this cause, and the Lord is cheated. Some farmers seem to think that their income is only what they sell for money. If they have but little to sell, then they pay little or no tithe. If they could for a short time exchange positions with day laborers who rent their homes and buy everything they have, they would soon see the difference. All the grain, vegetables, fruit, hay, and stock they raise by their own labor, is income. They also derive a large profit from butter, cheese, milk, and eggs. Often by working out, hauling and selling wood, and doing other kinds of work, they have more or less income. It is strange that many who profess to pay tithes faithfully, should reckon their income in the manner in which they do, leaving out of the account their table expenses, and the feed given to their stock, while others have to buy these very things from the wages received.
Persons who buy and sell, or speculate, oftentimes make estimates of their income which are equally inexcusable. When they buy at a certain price and sell for a larger one, the difference between the two is income. The growth and increase of property between the price paid and that received, is income, and a tithe of it belongs to the Lord. It is in a great variety of such ways that the actual tithe is withheld, and God’s cause is robbed. When will we be honest, truly conscientious, with our God? The prophet Malachi promises us great blessings on conditions of faithfulness in this duty.
One important reason why we feel so sad to see our people neglecting this duty, is because it hinders and directly interferes with the prosperity and growth of the cause and the salvation of our fellow-men. There is Conference after Conference where the tithing is wholly inadequate to properly sustain the work. Workers who would and could do good, are forced to remain at home and labor for the support of their families, because through this unfaithfulness in paying tithes, the treasury is empty and the Conference in debt.
This brings a blight, a cloud, over the whole work in the State where this condition exists. Nothing can be done to venture out and encourage those who need to be assisted in a small degree. The greatest economy has to be used to keep those in the field who are laboring. They receive such stinted pay that they can scarcely live decently and clothe and feed their families, while those whose duty it is to stand byp. 121 them, are robbing God and stingily paying three to five dollars per year, on an average, to show their gratitude for the truth, and to acknowledge the blessings they are receiving. Many of these are making money all the time, and living in comfort and even luxury. Will not God judge for such things as this?
In other Conferences, where funds are plenty, the managers have such close, economical views of administration, that sufficient encouragement is not given to those who, with a little assistance, would make valuable helpers. Some of the most successful laborers we have in the cause, were very fearful when they commenced, doubting their ability to accomplish anything. Had not a generous spirit prevailed, and they been rather urged out and made to feel that others had faith and hope in their success, they might have been working in some secular business to-day, and the cause would have suffered a great loss.
There are many who could labor successfully if proper encouragement was given them. Perhaps not as ministers and public speakers at first, but as helpers, Bible readers, colporters, and canvassers; and some of them would gradually develop into able laborers even as ministers. This has been demonstrated over and over in the past. Granted that some may fail, and risks must be run, and some means lost; what of that? One devoted laborer in the cause of God, will pay for many failures.
We are reaching an important phase of the work, when every gift which can be employed successfully, should be brought in. The education and development of workers, is the most important element of success we can now introduce. Hundreds and thousands of our people should be preparing themselves to labor in some capacity in the great work of warning the world. Let not our brethren in official positions, stand at the door with such vigilance and caution, to prevent persons from working who they think ought not to work, that none but the most fearless will dare to make the venture. But rather let them encourage all to make the effort who are worthy persons, and manifest a desire to do something. Let us instruct, admonish, and kindly educate all who we can hope may succeed.
We consider the tithing as the fund which God has designed to support laborers of all classes in the work of God. It cannot in justice be confined alone to ministers that preach in the desk. A good colporter or Bible worker who benefits the cause, is just as properly to be supported from the tithes as the minister who preaches. We decidedly object to the idea that none of these classes can receive anything from the tithing, but must have a special fund raised or they receive nothing. We believe this position, if maintained, will prove detrimental to the work, and greatly hinder its progress.
We believe the true rule to be this: Encourage workers to labor in any and every branch of the cause, if they give evidence of devotion and reasonable ability. Those who can prove their fitness, and really do good, should be supported from the tithing, and left in the field. Canvassers, of course, sustain themselves by the difference between the wholesale and retail prices, or nearly so. When the tithing proves to be insufficient, then make solemn appeals to the brethren to donate of their means that the work may not be hindered. We believe they will do so when they can see the work is going forward and funds are needed. But while thousands of dollars are in the tithing treasury, and all confined to the ministers, and it is considered too good to be used to pay a godly, devoted colporter or missionary worker, they will not be apt to give much; for they will feel it is not the right way to do. Thus these gifts will be kept back and discouraged. We are sure this is the only reasonable ground we can take.
How important, then, that the tithe be promptly and fully paid! It is the true source of supply to meet all the requirements of the laborers. If our people will pay an honest tithe, there will be no lack of funds with which to help forward the work. We must therefore look after this matter carefully. Brethren in the ministry, do not neglect to labor publicly and privately to bring up and keep up the tithing. Make our brethren ashamed of robbing God who are paying in some Conferences only from three to six dollars per year on the average for the support of God’s work and the sustenance of the laborers who leave their homes and go out to meet the chilling influences of this ungodly world. Let us pursue a liberal, generous policy, and encourage all we can to labor who show some degree of fitness for the work. Let us sustain them without acting as if we felt they were likely to do us damage or had some selfish project in view. A generous, noble-spirited, encouraging policy, pursued with good sense and sound judgment, counseling with brethren of experience, will work wonders in bringing up our languishing Conferences.
O. I. B.