AdventAI

A PIOUS HUMBUG.

By G. C. T.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 1., January 1, 1895

It is to us a disagreeable duty whenever it seems necessary to make remarks that reflect on personal actions or character. But it is a fact that censurable actions are always related to individuals, and sometimes very closely identified with them. But in all cases we would distinguish as far as possible between the person and the things we criticise. The country has been strewn with advertisements of the work being done in South Chicago by John Alexander Dowie, also commonly called “Rev.” “Zion’s Tabernacle” has been photographed, outside and in. The platform, hung with so-called trophies of victorious prayer in the shape of bandages, crutches, supports, etc., has been photographed, engraved, and distributed by many thousands.

Now Mr. Dowie has as much right to humbug the country as any one else, and he is only one of thousands who are doing it. The reason why we single him out is because he is doing it in the name of Christ and religion. His Chicago enterprise is not the beginning of his career. His tabernacle on Johnston St., Fitzroy, Melbourne, still stands, or a part of it does, we believe. New Zealand and the Pacific Coast well know of him; and the same stamp has marked his work all through. A late number of the Christian Herald, published in Detroit, contains a most scathing denunciation of the man as well as of his work, on the testimony of several who have known him. A few weeks since the Chicago papers told us that he became involved in trouble with the health department of that city by sending away those who died at his home without reporting them.

The Herald of the 25th Dec. states that a poor man from Wisconsin and his sister, the latter of whom had been brought to Dowie for treatment, were both rendered insane at Dowie’s home, the city physician deciding that the brother’s case was caused by “his interest in Dowie.” But there was no healing. And last Sunday a Mrs. Chas. Walker died in Dowie’s place, while he was praying for her, they refusing to consult a physician.

At the same time it is denied that he has ever had an authentic case of healing. Of this we are not certain. There may have been. But we do most emphatically protest against this work being accepted by the people as “divine healing.” It is nothing of the kind. Mr. Dowie is one to whom Prov. 28:9 will apply.p. 7

That the Lord has power to heal the sick, and that he hears the prayers of his children in behalf of the sick, we doubt not. We have not a word to say derogatory to divine healing; but this that we speak of and much more that passes under the same name is not the genuine article.

G. C. T.