THE RELATION BETWEEN A WELL-ORDERED GOVERNMENT AND THE PROGRESS OF CHRISTIANITY

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 24, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 12.

Read the full edition

THE RELATION BETWEEN A WELL-ORDERED GOVERNMENT AND THE PROGRESS OF CHRISTIANITY.

BY PERCY T. MAGAN.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
(Concluded.)
In his third line of proof, the doctor brought forth a vast array of Bible texts, whereby it would appear he is trying to establish as fact that when the nation gets to a certain stage of wickedness, the Lord will call upon the ministers to labor no more with the politicians, but to let them go on in their own way; and that he will visit desolations upon them. If this be so, we are inclined to believe that this fearful state of wickedness has been in existence ever since the time of Christ; for when he was on earth, he commanded to keep politics and religion separate, and bade those who would be his disciples, to do likewise. We read of this One who is the pattern for all gospel ministers to follow, laboring to make individual conversions, and teaching Bible truths; but nowhere recorded in God’s word do we find that from Mount Olivet or elsewhere he spoke politics to the people, or reasoned with the law-givers of the age to prove to them that it was their duty to enact measures to coerce people to believe on him. Moreover, we are of the opinion that if Dr. Hays will study the context of the verses he quotes, he will find that they were threatenings to individuals, and not to nations, and therefore cannot be applied to such.
Lastly, by way of proof, he gave the following:—
If, again, we turn to the New Testament, we have a direct apostolic injunction as to what should be the conduct of God’s people in all ages under very similar circumstances: “This know also, that in the last days perilous times shall come. For men shall be lovers of their own selves, covetous, boasters, proud, blasphemers, disobedient to parents, unthankful, unholy, without natural affection, truce-breakers, false accusers, incontinent, fierce, . . . heady, high-minded, lovers of pleasures more than lovers of God; having a form of godliness, but denying the power thereof.” Well, what then? What are you going to do about it? Are God’s ministers to blow more loudly than ever the trumpet, and sound the alarm, and with might and main resist the incoming flood of iniquity?—No. “From such turn away.” The time for witness-bearing is over. The corruption of the body politic is incurable. The only thing to be done under such circumstances, is to come out from among them. “From such turn away.”
Here again he gets hopelessly astray; for while the apostle distinctly states that those to whom Paul’s words to Timothy apply, have a “form of godliness but deny the power thereof,” and therefore must be church-members devoid of the Spirit of God, from whom we are to turn away because they have apostatized and lost the love of the truth, the doctor applies the text not to the church, but to the “body politic,” which Paul does not mention, and concerning which he has given no warning; thus he makes a false application of the whole text. He said further:—
Thus we see reason and experience, the history of nations, and the plain teachings of God’s word, all most clearly show that there is a most intimate, close, and vital relationship between the condition of the body politic, and the growth and spread of religion among any people; and that there comes a point in the downward progress of nations when the right arm of the church becomes paralyzed. Witness-bearing is useless, and the nation’s doom is sealed.
We are glad we have found one point on which we can agree; viz., “that there is a point in the downward progress of nations when the right arm of the Church becomes paralyzed;” but we believe it to be when the Church has so far departed from God and the doctrines of the Bible, that the Spirit of Heaven is withdrawn, the power of God to win souls to him is no longer with her, and in order to make up for this lack, which is vital in itself, she seeks the aid of civil power. This is how churches are paralyzed, and this is what they always resort to, instead of confessing their sins, putting away their backslidings, and returning to the Lord.
How strange that Paul should not have imbibed this enlightened theory, and sought the aid of the legislature, and used his learning and eloquence before the Roman Court, endeavoring to secure a city ordinance for Corinth, that all men therein might be coerced into Christianity; instead of wasting his time preaching Christ Jesus, and him only, to the people, and permitting them to judge for themselves whether they would accept Jesus as the Christ or not. How strange that he should say, “Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind,” instead of, Let every man be coerced by a decree of the Roman Senate.
Dr. Hays evidently believes that if the State does not enact laws to make the people go to church and listen to the preachers, it must necessarily be antagonistic to their doing so. Such is not the case. The very best way that the State can assist the Church is to give her full liberty to propagate her doctrines, and make no laws concerning them.
We now come to the finale of the discourse, and to the conclusion arrived at as to the duty of ministers. We clip the most spicy extract:—
Now, what is the great lesson we, as a nation and a church, and above all as Christian citizens, are to learn from these incontrovertible facts? Is it that politics and religion have nothing to do with each other? that we are to leave our politics at home when we go to church, and our religion at home when we go to the polls? that they are not only separate from each other, but antagonistic to each other? Is it that we ministers, “the sacramental host of God’s elect,” are to leave the discussion of the great living issues of the day, the visible enthronement of King Jesus, the temperance question, the Sabbath question, etc., to the care of a set of godless politicians, and give ourselves, as the servants of Christ, to serving tables, and preaching a milk-and-water gospel which has neither backbone nor substance, and wilts and withers at the approach of the very evils it was intended to cure?—No, no; we have not so learned Christ nor read our commission. We are not only to be the light of the world, but the salt of the earth,—the conservators of the nation as well as the builders on the walls of Zion. Not only will we preach moral suasion from our pulpits, but legal suasion, and, if need be, coercion and prohibition. [Italics ours], until all let and hindrance shall be taken away, and the scepter placed in the hands of Him who won it on the plains of Calvary.
From all this we can gather but one conclusion, which is evident on the face of the argument—that unless politics and religion be mingled, and given to the people as a mixed dose, nothing can be accomplished by the Church; and that those who do not do this, teach a milk-and-water gospel which has neither backbone nor substance. But is it not such a gospel that the world’s Redeemer preached? and is it not such a gospel that he commanded all those who would be his disciples through all ages, to teach? Matt. 28:19, 20. They are to preach whatever the Lord commanded; but nowhere do we find that he taught them to preach politics, or “legal suasion;” nor yet to “coerce,” but rather to be “harmless as doves.” Paul told Timothy to preach the word, but not politics or legal suasion. And again, in Gal. 1: 8, 9, we read that though an angel from heaven preach any other gospel than that of Jesus Christ, let him be accursed. Christ taught a total separation of politics and religion, and Dr. Hays preaches that they should be united. Which is to be obeyed? In 1 Pet. 2:2, we are told to desire the “sincere milk of the word;” and this is what the apostles claim to have taught. But they preached the gospel of Jesus Christ, and that alone; therefore the logic of the matter resolves itself simply into this: that the gospel of Christ is pure milk, and not till it is mixed with politics does it become as “milk and water.”
Dr. Hays proposes to preach not only “moral suasion,” but “legal suasion, and, if need be, coercion and prohibition.” What more did the priests and pontiffs of Rome ever preach in the days of their most palmy supremacy? “Coercion and prohibition”—what does this mean? What did it mean in the Dark Ages?—Persecution, torture, the rack, the inquisition. And if Dr. Hays is permitted to carry his scheme into effect, such will be the inevitable result to those in the nineteenth century who see fit to differ with his creed.
Again he says:—
Away, then, with your so-called secular Sabbath, founded on mere human expediency! . . . We want the good old Puritan Sabbath, enacted in the garden of Eden, and re-enacted amid the thunders of Sinai, prefaced by those awful words, “Thus saith the Lord.”
In this he also differs from many of his coat, for it is a favorite retreat our National Reform friends have, when forced to acknowledge the point that it would be wrong to coerce men into keeping a day as a religious rest which they do not believe to be the Sabbath, that they only seek to enforce the Sabbath as a secular rest day. We are inclined to believe that the doctor has the Lord doing things a little ahead of time, enacting a “Puritan Sabbath” in the garden of Eden, nearly 6,000 years before ever the form of a Puritan decorated the face of this fair universe. And where is his text for it? In Gen. 2:2, we find the seventh-day Sabbath blessed and sanctified in the garden of Eden; and, again, in Ex. 20:10, commanded to be kept holy, and called “the Sabbath of the Lord thy God”—not the “Puritan Sabbath,” the “secular Sabbath,” the “American Sabbath,” nor any such name. Here once more the Lord and the doctor are at variance; for the Lord consecrated the seventh day, and commanded that it be kept holy, and the doctor desires a law to help him keep Sunday, the first day of the week, which the Lord never consecrated, and which the Bible nowhere calls the Sabbath.