As has already been noticed in the REVIEW, the Catholic Church is taking advantage of the World's Columbian Exposition to attract the attention of the world to itself. The pope has appointed a commissioner, space has been secured, and a Catholic exhibit will be made at the Fair. They are also putting forth at this time the claim that this should be a Catholic country, on the ground that the discovery of America was a Catholic discovery. As Columbus is popularly supposed to have discovered America, and as he was a Catholic, they hold that this discovery was a Catholic feat, that therefore this is a Catholic country by right of discovery, and that to Catholics belongs all the glory. “There were,” say they, “no Protestants in the world in 1492.” In one sense this latter statement is true, and in another sense it is not true. It is true that there were no Protestants, distinctively so-called, in the days of Columbus; it is not true that the principles underlying Protestantism did not exist at that time. They not only existed, but had existed for ages. One hundred years before the time of the great German Reformation, from which the name of Protestantism arose, John Huss had preached in Bohemia the same principles afterward embodied in the Reformation. For this the Catholic Council of Constance condemned him to death. At the same time Jerome of Prague was arraigned for preaching the same doctrine, and he too was put to death for his faith. As these two cases we have mentioned are typical of hundreds of similar instances, which occurred in the history of the Catholic Church from the days of Constantine to Charles V of Germany, all of which were instigated and demanded by that church, it is no wonder that Protestantism did not flourish, and it is easy to see why it was unknown in 1492. But allowing that there were no Protestants at that time, and that Columbus and his crew were Catholics, this does not prove that that church has any particular and exclusive right to this country. Pirates have often been bold navigators, and many islands have been first visited and explored by them. This, however, would not be considered a good reason why the pirates’ peculiar maxims should be especially established in those islands.
But as Columbus never really discovered North America, but only the islands adjacent to Central America and also South America, the claim of especial religious privileges for the Catholics on the ground of Columbus’s faith, even if admissible, could only be effective in the countries he actually discovered. In these countries Catholicism has been the prevailing religion. The West Indies and the continent of South America have, as the result of the Spanish conquest, become adherents to the Catholic Church. Mexico, the southern portion of North America, was also settled by Catholics, and the Catholic Church has had a chance in that country, and in the various South American countries, to demonstrate the advantages which Catholic civilization has over the Protestant and liberal civilization of the United States. The different results achieved in this country where freedom from the exactions of religious bigotry has developed a national history so different from what has been accomplished in South American countries and Mexico under Catholic influences, are such as to convince us that it is a good thing for the United States that the claim of the Catholic Church to this country by right of discovery, was not made good by actual settlement and occupation.
We have only to look to Peru and Ecuador, countries completely under the control of the Catholic Church, to see what would have been the condition of the United States of America, had providence directed that the Catholic Church should have the control of this country. Some of the Catholic countries of the New World, like Mexico and Chili, are further advanced in civilization than those we have mentioned; but liberal influences entirely outside of the Catholic Church must receive the credit for their improved condition. In view of the intense ignorance among the common people of Catholic countries, both European and American, we are at a loss to understand how the Catholic Church can claim to be the friend of education and progress, or that the Catholic Church can be given any credit for the education of the people of the United States. The Catholic Church has had control of Italy for a thousand years, the last hundred years of which time it has been a disgrace for any person to be illiterate, and to-day sixty per cent of the population of Italy cannot read. Spain, intensely Catholic, is in about the same condition. The Catholic-French people in the Province of Quebec, who, by their language and religion, have been separated from the English people and from Protestant and liberal influences, and who have been under the influence of the priests 200 years, are a fair sample of what Catholicism does for the common people. Thousands of them are entirely ignorant of letters. We have felt sad to see these French Canadians, whose naturally intelligent minds showed an adaptability for a good education, so ignorant that they would not be able to read their own names, in their own or any other language.
It is useless for the Catholic Church to say that it is not responsible for this ignorance. If it had taken half the pains to establish schools of learning that it has to foster superstitious notions about the efficacy of beads and relics, the natural ability of the French people would long ago have risen from the ignorance which has so long held it down as with iron bands. The whole educational system of the province is under its control; but it makes no effort worthy of the name to rescue the common people from the ignorance which is a disgrace to the province and to the Catholic Church. When the priests in that province wish to build a new church, they can assess any Catholic in the diocese where the church is to be built, for any sum they see fit, and the law of the province gives them the power to collect it. If the money thus wrenched from the poor people of Quebec to build the grand stone temples which are being erected all over the province, could be used to build and equip school-houses, and to supply teachers, and the arbitrary power of the priests among their own people could be used to make education compulsory, ignorance would vanish from that benighted people as the dew disappears from the bright rays of the sun. And the reason that it does not do so, is that the priests do not want it so. Taking into consideration this undisputed fact of the ignorance of the common people in Catholic countries, which is in such marked contrast with Protestant countries, it can readily be seen that had Catholicism gained a controlling influence in the colonies, which afterward became the United States of America, the condition of this people as regards intelligence and enterprise would have been similar to what it is in those countries controlled by that church.
Looking at the settlement of this country with the firm belief that God governs in the affairs of men, we are fully persuaded that the hand of providence diverted Columbus to South America, reserving this land from settlement by Spanish Catholics, and even from English colonists, until the principles of the Reformation had made such progress in England that those who left her shores to settle here, and who laid the foundation of this country, and to a large extent directed its future course, were men who believed in the Scriptures, rather than the pope, in liberty of conscience, rather than religious tyranny, and thus the people of this country escaped the strangling meshes which in Catholic countries have kept the common people in ignorance, and have choked out all desire for education and progress.
That the greatest and most prosperous country of all the American States has thus developed under a liberal system of government which Catholicism has failed to dominate, could not have come about by accident; and we cannot but conclude that in this freedom from Catholicism the nation has been better prepared to accomplish the ends of divine providence. It is the best thing that ever happened to Catholics in this country that that church does not control the nation as it does the States of South America. It was the design of the fathers of this country that the government should be controlled by the people as a whole, and not by any church or any religion. When this fundamental principle of American government shall be destroyed, or in any way perverted, it will be the signal of the ruin of this country. And any claim that this country should be under the especial tutelage of the Catholic, or any other particular religion, is a menace to the liberty which so long has been the distinguishing characteristic of the American Republic.
M. E. K.